As they played at A&M and not NBA related

PG Acie
SG Sloan
SF House
PF Jones
C Tyler Davis

PG Caruso
SG Elston Turner
SF Khris Middleton
PF Robert Williams
C Bryan Davis

Law
Kirk
House
Joe Jones
Davis

Sloan
Turner
Carter
Jones
Davis

Might have a different lineup if I was building a team to put on the court, but as far as their total contributions to the program while here

PG Acie
SG Sloan
SF Khris Middleton
PF Joseph Jones
C Tyler Davis

PG Caruso
SG Admon Gilder (gave him the benefit of a good Sr yr)
SF Josh Carter
PF Robert Williams
C Bryan Davis

G Law IV
G Sloan
F Wright
F jones
C Davis

G Caruso
G Turner
G House
F Williams
C Elonu

Man there are some tough choices in there. Can we just put 10 guys on each team like they do now?

No House, wac? Cmon. Dude was way better than Carter. I'm saying you're putting a team together to win a game moreso than lifetime contribution or whatever but using their time here as the barometer.

No. Wright should be up there. I may have to recalculate. He was a stud. He bashed us on hbo so I forgot about him a little.

Josh Carter was a good player.

No doubt. He had a lot of 2/8 games but I liked him. His shot against NU may be the happiest I've been outside of Law shot. Not sure why but that win was just so great.

Not based on stats but what I feel would be my top rosters...

A+ Team:
PG - Law
SG - Sloan
SF - House
PF - Joe Jones
C - Robert Williams

A- Team:
PG - Caruso
SG - Gilder
SF - Wright
PF - Kavilaskus
C - Tyler Davis

B Team:
PG- Holmes
SG- Elston Turner
SF - Middleton
PF - Jalen Jones
C - Jordan

^ that's a fun squad

Method Man said:

---

No House, wac? Cmon. Dude was way better than Carter. I'm saying you're putting a team together to win a game moreso than lifetime contribution or whatever but using their time here as the barometer.

---

If it's picking a team to win a game, then explain your selections

What's to explain? What major flaws do you see? Three penetrators who could shoot. Two posts one who could shoot from 12-15 and one in the low post. All tough.

wacarnolds said:

---

Method Man said:

---

No House, wac? Cmon. Dude was way better than Carter. I'm saying you're putting a team together to win a game moreso than lifetime contribution or whatever but using their time here as the barometer.

---

If it's picking a team to win a game, then explain your selections

---

Isn't Carter our best 3 pt specialist in this time frame? him or Middleton, right?

Method Man said:

---

What's to explain? What major flaws do you see? Three penetrators who could shoot. Two posts one who could shoot from 12-15 and one in the low post. All tough.

---

-Both teams are too slow (I'm assuming PF Jones is Joseph Jones) and look like they were built to win a game 10 years ago
-You left off the best 3 pt shooter (Carter) and the outside shooting is kinda meh in general
-You left off the 3 best on-ball defenders (Kirk, Roland, Admon)
-I like Elston but woof picking him over some other guys like Wright, Kirk, Roland

If I was building two teams

Law
Kirk
Carter
Antoine
R Williams
---------
Caruso
Sloan
Gilder
Middleton
Tyler

PatAg said:

---

wacarnolds said:

---

Method Man said:

---

No House, wac? Cmon. Dude was way better than Carter. I'm saying you're putting a team together to win a game moreso than lifetime contribution or whatever but using their time here as the barometer.

---

If it's picking a team to win a game, then explain your selections

---

Isn't Carter our best 3 pt specialist in this time frame? him or Middleton, right?

---

I think Carter is easily the best in school history, regardless of time frame. He shot 40%, 50%, 38% and 39% from 3 and averaged 180 3PA per year

Yeah but what about Josh Morgan

I think Elston was the best shooter. I think House could shoot. Carter was a great shooter when he just stood there waiting for open 3s.

Is this based on their performance as Aggies or who you would want at the peak of their career if you were assembling a team to take into battle.
I'm going to answer the second one.

PG: Acie
SG: Sloan
SF: Middleton
PF: Williams
C: Jordan

PG: Caruso
SG: Gilder
SF: House
PF: torn between AK and Jalen
C: Davis

Law
Sloan
Wright
Joe Jones
Davis

Caruso
House
Middleton
Jalen Jones
Williams

Hop? Logan? Ol yeller? Mike Syracuse? Mhayden? Jorts?

Assuming we mean at their best, and not like a career average, AND that I'm not necessarily building these team around how the pieces would fit together...

PG: Acie
SG: Sloan
SF: Wright
PF: Jo. Jones
C: T. Davis

PG: Caruso
SG: Turner
SF: Carter
PF: Ja. Jones
C: R. Williams (do I have to consider him a PF?)

No. Robert Williams can play center.

Most of these teams are distinguished by Guard or Forward, unless a true Center exists. Rarely are they broken down to PG, SG, SF, PF, C. Caruso made my 2nd team because of his versatility at the Guard position, but not necessarily PG.

Well yeah, hell sometimes now they don't even have positions at all, I was just trying to play within Method Man's rules.

Carter vs House was my toughest debate, and really the only one I struggled with at all. House was a better player, but Carter was more consistent, and since it's my team I can pick which I value more.

Only other one I even had to think about was Jalen vs Antanas.

You sure Carter was that consistent?

I didn't say he was especially consistent, just more so than House to me. I also never felt like Carter was trying to do too much like I did with House a lot. I readily admit that House was better in every sense of the word, I just feel like Carter was really good in his specific role so I went with him.

Oh i can't argue. House needed a stronger hand or something to make sure he didn't freewheel too much.

Method Man said:

---

As they played at A&M and not NBA related

PG Acie
SG Sloan
SF House
PF Jones
C Tyler Davis

PG Caruso
SG Elston Turner
SF Khris Middleton
PF Robert Williams
C Bryan Davis

---

I'm good with this, assuming PF is Joseph Jones and not Jalen Jones, though Jalen was certainly a very good college player.

I think Jalen has maybe taken Sloan's crown of being the most underappreciated by our fans. It was Caruso while he was here but then everyone saw how awful our offense looked without him and then reverted back to Sloan.

He led a 3-seed caliber A&M team in rebounds and was only .3 pts per game off of House for the lead in points. Dude averaged 15 & 7 and actually shot the three fairly well at 32.4%. That's not stellar but House only shot 30.9% and he took 140 more attempts.

It was

Building for fit and not necessarily the best at their position:

PG: Law
SG: Turner
SF: WRIGHT
PF: Jalen Jones
C: Davis

PG: Caruso
SG: Sloan
SF: HOUSE
PF: Williams
C: Jones

I think Middleton is a little overrated on here if we're being honest...

bobinator said:

---

I think Middleton is a little overrated on here if we're being honest...

---

For sure, especially with regards to individual seasons in an Aggie uniform. With Wright, House and even Carter, I'm not sure how you put Khris on either team.

Antoine was better. I think Khris was underrated but I'm thinking of games he took over