Food & Spirits
Sponsored by

Santa Fe Restaurant Recommendations

1,651 Views | 31 Replies | Last: 24 min ago by ILikeTacos
TikiBarrel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Taking a road trip with my wife and daughter to Santa Fe, NM next week! Looking for restaurant recs! Doesn't necessarily have to be super fancy. Open to whatever...Interior Mexican, Asian, Southwestern, etc. Looking for good breakfast/brunch spot as well. We're also doing a day trip to Taos so if you have something there you recommend that's great too!
CDub06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Everyone is going to recommend The Shed, which is fine. But it's the must visit spot.

I really like Radish & Rye as a fancy spot.
Sazon is a great fancy Mexican spot.

Clafoutis would be a good breakfast spot. It's a French place that has a great breakfast.
Cafe Pasquals is another favorite for breakfast.

For New Mexican, I like The Pantry Rio or Casa Chimayo.
Tune Up Cafe is a cool Salvadorean / New Mexican spot.

Dr. Field Goods is probably the place I eat lunch at the most.

Rowley Farmhouse is a nice wild ale brewery with great food.
Paper Dosa is tremendous for Indian food.
Jambo Cafe for African.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Michael's Kitchen in Taos for breakfast/lunch. Been there since I was a kid, thinking of their stuffed sopapillas smothered in green chile is making me hungry
Garrelli 5000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Shed sucks. Anyone who says otherwise went because another tourist told them the Shed is party balls in your mouth explosions of awesomeality.

The Shed sucks even if there isn't 2 hour wait.
jah003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
S
Rachos Plaza Grill in Taos (well basically Taos) is one of my favorites. Orlando's is also really good in Taos

Wife and I had an incredible dinner at Geronimo's a few years back. It's pretty pricey but I thought it was worth it.

I'll defer to Cdub though because he is far more of a NM expert than me.
HTownAg98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Escondido for tacos and cocktails.
Radish & Rye or Geronimo for your high-end dinner.
Izanami if you want Japanese with the most extensive sake list I've ever seen.
Mr. Awesome Time
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rowley Farmhouse Ales
ILikeTacos
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Geronimo hands down one of my favorite dining experiences ever. It is fancier, but southwest fancy, so not that fancy? Definitely pricey.
EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We enjoyed the casual casual rooftop cantina at Coyote Cafe, if you're looking for something quick and easy.

88Warrior
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Was not impressed with The Shed at all…I walked out of there afterwards thinking "Really…all that hype for this??"
CDub06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yeah, for real. It's fine.

I've never understood all the hype.
PeekingDuck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Market Street
Sazon
Clafoutis
Cafe Pascal
Geronimo

All good spots. If you must do the shed (it is unremarkable), might as well go to la choza instead and skip the wait if you have a car. I feel like its more comfortable there anyway.

Boxcar is a good sports bar if you're there for the super bowl.
HTownAg98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If you have a chance, go hit the farmer's market at the old rail station. I believe it is Saturday morning. They have some stands that have really interesting local bites.
agcrock2005
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It's been a while but when I was there I went to Casa Chimayo for New Mexican food and it was great. Blue corn enchiladas with Christmas sauce was incredible. So was the Pazole.
AlaskanAg99
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
What about the Pink Adobe?

Been on my list to hit up after making a home version of the Steak Dunigan.
aTm '99
TikiBarrel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thanks for the recommendations...I'm excited to try some of these!
Snowball
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Shed
(or La Choza)
(or Maria's)

These three restaurants all serve phenomenal red chile enchiladas and great margaritas in Santa Fe, which is what I think of as the classic Northern New Mexican dinner. The Shed and La Choza are owned by the same family, and they have the best red chile - you want the Enchilada Plate, Red, with extra onions, and a silver coin margarita (optionally with a float of mezcal). They will ask you if you want sopaipilla or garlic bread, and the pro answer is "Is there any way I can get both?" - you want to use the garlic bread to mop up the red chile so you can put honey on your sopaipilla. The Shed is the more soulful and storied location of the two, downtown near the plaza, so you should go there. There will be a long wait - sometimes if you call in advance you can get a reservation, but usually even then they give you a buzzer and you have to wait. Find a way to enjoy it. Maria's is the main competition for The Shed, with similar culinary strengths - their red chile is not quite as good but their margaritas are even better. Since the purity of the red chile enchilada at Maria's is slightly less sacrosanct, a fun plus-up when I'm there is to get the enchiladas filled with carne adovada and have them put an egg on top. It's a lot, but it's great.
https://sfshed.com/
https://www.lachozasf.com/
https://www.marias-santafe.com/

Horseman's Haven
Despite appearances, Horseman's Haven is a temple to green chile. It doesn't look like a temple - it's a smallish diner (used to be much smaller) attached to a gas station out on Cerillos, with photos of a few local sports teams and locals eating breakfast at beat up linoleum tables. They don't have a website, I'll just include the address, but if you Google it it's readily found. Their green chile is the best in the world. Warning - it is also legitimately hot. The best thing to order here is a breakfast burrito with green chile, but the 3D burrito with green chile is also excellent (adovada is a strong play), and their green chile cheeseburgers are a very real thing. The pros all stick to bacon in their breakfast burritos, but personally I like to go with chorizo; everyone agrees, though, that you want to ask for the potatoes extra crispy and get your burrito smothered in green chile and cheese. I like to get a side of level 2, but you don't strictly need it unless there is something wrong with you - the normal level 1 green chile will already light you up good. Don't make plans to operate heavy machinery after eating here.
4354 Cerrillos Rd, Santa Fe, NM 87507

Tia Sophia's
Another place too caught out of time to have a proper website, this very New Mexican breakfast/lunch place is downtown, just a few short blocks from the plaza, and they close pretty early. Great green, but their red is also killer. Can't go wrong with the Atrisco plate, but I think everything there is pretty great. If I'm extra hungry and can convince someone to split it with me, I like to get a single blue corn pancake on the side and cover it with a side of green chile, which I know sounds crazy but trust me it's awesome.
210 W San Francisco St, Santa Fe, NM 87501

El Parasol
Rounding out my list of essential eateries in Santa Fe proper is El Parasol, a local chain. Their shredded beef tacos and their chicken tacos with guacamole are some of the very best tacos I've ever eaten - don't forget to add some of their excellent hot sauce. The burritos are killer too - a bean and cheese burrito, Christmas, makes a great eat-in-the-car-on-the-way-back-to-San-Antonio meal.
https://elparasol.com/

Rancho de Chimayo

(outside of Santa Fe, but a reasonable day trip, or you can stay there - see below)
This place is a temple to red chile, and, unlike Horseman's, it lets you know it's a temple. Behind the beautiful terraced seating out back there is an old wooden gate you can walk through to a quiet rolling kind of dried orchard, which seems utterly magical. While in Chimayo, admire the Spanish colonial art in the nave of the sanctuario, get yourself some holy dirt, and stop by El Potrero Trading Post to buy the highest quality dried red chile I know how to find with any regularity. It can also be fun to buy chile from people selling it in the parking lot, though obviously that's more of a crap shoot.
https://www.ranchodechimayo.com/
https://www.nps.gov/places/el-santuario-de-chimayo.htm
https://santafelibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2022/05/Chimayo.pdf

El Modelo- If you are going to ABQ
(outside of Santa Fe, down in ABQ)
If you find yourself down in ABQ, I heartily recommend El Modelo. There are other storied eateries down there, but in my admittedly limited experience none of them hold a candle to this place. I have not really explored the menu here, because I don't go often, and every time I do I feel compelled to get either their magnificent chile relleno burrito or their mathematically perfect stuffed sopaipilla. Which is a shame, because I suspect their Carne Adovada Burrito might actually be the best thing to get. Anyway, this place is amazing. No seating, but there are a precious few picnic tables in their parking lot.
https://www.elmodelomexicanfood.com/

Honorable Mentions:

- The Pantry -
I'm scandalized that this place is only going in the honorable mentions list and isn't a main recommendation. Incredibly solid Santa Fe mainstay, great diner food and great New Mexican food, excellent red and green. I once figured out the perfect order here, but I can never remember it - maybe it was a carne adovada omelette? That sure sounds perfect as I type this... My brother always gets the Buenos Dias plate, usually Christmas. Man, I love this place. But I'm leaving it down here for some reason.
https://www.pantrysantafe.com/
- Santa Fe Bite - used to be the home of the best burger in the world. Now the home of a damn fine green chile cheeseburger, probably still the best in the city (though Horseman's might have something to say about that) and still one of the better burgers in the world.
https://www.santafebitenm.com/home
- Posa's - The best tamales in town, fueled by red and green (you want the red). Their burritos are also serious contenders for best in town.
https://santafetamales.com/
- Cafe Pasqual's - takes a chef-y, high-end approach to New Mexican food, serves a killer breakfast but there will be a wait. And a pricetag.
https://pasquals.com/
- Clafouti's - in case you need a break from New Mexican food, this french cafe is really great. Absolutely killer pastries, too.
https://www.clafoutis.biz/
- Harry's Roadhouse - not sure why you would go here if you don't spend a lot of time in Santa Fe, but this place is just cool, a favorite among the locals, run by good people, serving reliably good food.
https://www.harrysroadhousesf.com/
- La Reina - slightly too cool tequila/mezcal/margarita bar in the slightly too cool El Rey Court (see below), a fixed-up old Route 66 motel that has been lovingly and artistically gentrified/restored. I'm being overly harsh in my description - I actually love this place, it's great. A breath of 21st century in a very 19th century town, but very much in a good way. Austinites and Los Angelenos will feel at home here.
https://elreycourt.com/la-reina
- The Matador - if you need a dive bar in Santa Fe, this is it.
116 W San Francisco St, Santa Fe, NM 87501

I figured I might as well go all the way. Hope this is useful, or at least decent reading. If you go to any of these spots let me know! I also have places to visit and stay if you need rec's!
bularry
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Is Snowball some AI travel influencer?
Snowball
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
just a dude that loves NM, my guy.
walton91
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ILikeTacos said:

Geronimo hands down one of my favorite dining experiences ever. It is fancier, but southwest fancy, so not that fancy? Definitely pricey.

I still dream of the pork shank I had there 4 years ago
EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We had reservations at Sazon but had to cancel due to an injury someone in our party suffered while walking on Canyon Road. If you go there, be careful. The sidewalk is uneven and missing in some parts, and you have to watch where you step.

"Canyon Road is a historic district, which means that it's super charming, but it's not the most accessible area of Santa Fe. Sidewalks are often cracked and uneven. There are stretches of dirt and gravel instead of cement, and there are a few spots where the sidewalk all but disappears. Many of the galleries have steps and stairs, but no ramps or elevators. If there is a gallery that you really want to visit and you have mobility concerns, we recommend calling ahead to ensure that you will be able to access the gallery."
TikiBarrel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Garrelli 5000 said:

The Shed sucks. Anyone who says otherwise went because another tourist told them the Shed is party balls in your mouth explosions of awesomeality.

The Shed sucks even if there isn't 2 hour wait.

Sadly, I can 100% attest this as truth!!!
Tecolote
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TikiBarrel said:

Taking a road trip with my wife and daughter to Santa Fe, NM next week! Looking for restaurant recs! Doesn't necessarily have to be super fancy. Open to whatever...Interior Mexican, Asian, Southwestern, etc. Looking for good breakfast/brunch spot as well. We're also doing a day trip to Taos so if you have something there you recommend that's great too!

These threads are a blast. I grew up just outside Santa Fe, and have/had grandparents, a sister, and countless cousins live in Santa Fe for generations. Live not too far now. After all the tourist strong recommendations of knowing it all, I, as a local, wouldn't dare suggest something. Especially if it's a restaurant that not only locals but tourist go to but somehow the tourists don't like it. So, please do stay away so locals have less wait.

You know places like per ce in NYC and Keller's sister French Laundry have people walk out going "dang, I just don't get what all the hype is about that place.
Tecolote
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Snowball said:

The Shed
(or La Choza)
(or Maria's)

These three restaurants all serve phenomenal red chile enchiladas and great margaritas in Santa Fe, which is what I think of as the classic Northern New Mexican dinner. The Shed and La Choza are owned by the same family, and they have the best red chile - you want the Enchilada Plate, Red, with extra onions, and a silver coin margarita (optionally with a float of mezcal). They will ask you if you want sopaipilla or garlic bread, and the pro answer is "Is there any way I can get both?" - you want to use the garlic bread to mop up the red chile so you can put honey on your sopaipilla. The Shed is the more soulful and storied location of the two, downtown near the plaza, so you should go there. There will be a long wait - sometimes if you call in advance you can get a reservation, but usually even then they give you a buzzer and you have to wait. Find a way to enjoy it. Maria's is the main competition for The Shed, with similar culinary strengths - their red chile is not quite as good but their margaritas are even better. Since the purity of the red chile enchilada at Maria's is slightly less sacrosanct, a fun plus-up when I'm there is to get the enchiladas filled with carne adovada and have them put an egg on top. It's a lot, but it's great.
https://sfshed.com/
https://www.lachozasf.com/
https://www.marias-santafe.com/

Horseman's Haven
Despite appearances, Horseman's Haven is a temple to green chile. It doesn't look like a temple - it's a smallish diner (used to be much smaller) attached to a gas station out on Cerillos, with photos of a few local sports teams and locals eating breakfast at beat up linoleum tables. They don't have a website, I'll just include the address, but if you Google it it's readily found. Their green chile is the best in the world. Warning - it is also legitimately hot. The best thing to order here is a breakfast burrito with green chile, but the 3D burrito with green chile is also excellent (adovada is a strong play), and their green chile cheeseburgers are a very real thing. The pros all stick to bacon in their breakfast burritos, but personally I like to go with chorizo; everyone agrees, though, that you want to ask for the potatoes extra crispy and get your burrito smothered in green chile and cheese. I like to get a side of level 2, but you don't strictly need it unless there is something wrong with you - the normal level 1 green chile will already light you up good. Don't make plans to operate heavy machinery after eating here.
4354 Cerrillos Rd, Santa Fe, NM 87507

Tia Sophia's
Another place too caught out of time to have a proper website, this very New Mexican breakfast/lunch place is downtown, just a few short blocks from the plaza, and they close pretty early. Great green, but their red is also killer. Can't go wrong with the Atrisco plate, but I think everything there is pretty great. If I'm extra hungry and can convince someone to split it with me, I like to get a single blue corn pancake on the side and cover it with a side of green chile, which I know sounds crazy but trust me it's awesome.
210 W San Francisco St, Santa Fe, NM 87501

El Parasol
Rounding out my list of essential eateries in Santa Fe proper is El Parasol, a local chain. Their shredded beef tacos and their chicken tacos with guacamole are some of the very best tacos I've ever eaten - don't forget to add some of their excellent hot sauce. The burritos are killer too - a bean and cheese burrito, Christmas, makes a great eat-in-the-car-on-the-way-back-to-San-Antonio meal.
https://elparasol.com/

Rancho de Chimayo

(outside of Santa Fe, but a reasonable day trip, or you can stay there - see below)
This place is a temple to red chile, and, unlike Horseman's, it lets you know it's a temple. Behind the beautiful terraced seating out back there is an old wooden gate you can walk through to a quiet rolling kind of dried orchard, which seems utterly magical. While in Chimayo, admire the Spanish colonial art in the nave of the sanctuario, get yourself some holy dirt, and stop by El Potrero Trading Post to buy the highest quality dried red chile I know how to find with any regularity. It can also be fun to buy chile from people selling it in the parking lot, though obviously that's more of a crap shoot.
https://www.ranchodechimayo.com/
https://www.nps.gov/places/el-santuario-de-chimayo.htm
https://santafelibrary.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2022/05/Chimayo.pdf

El Modelo- If you are going to ABQ
(outside of Santa Fe, down in ABQ)
If you find yourself down in ABQ, I heartily recommend El Modelo. There are other storied eateries down there, but in my admittedly limited experience none of them hold a candle to this place. I have not really explored the menu here, because I don't go often, and every time I do I feel compelled to get either their magnificent chile relleno burrito or their mathematically perfect stuffed sopaipilla. Which is a shame, because I suspect their Carne Adovada Burrito might actually be the best thing to get. Anyway, this place is amazing. No seating, but there are a precious few picnic tables in their parking lot.
https://www.elmodelomexicanfood.com/

Honorable Mentions:

- The Pantry -
I'm scandalized that this place is only going in the honorable mentions list and isn't a main recommendation. Incredibly solid Santa Fe mainstay, great diner food and great New Mexican food, excellent red and green. I once figured out the perfect order here, but I can never remember it - maybe it was a carne adovada omelette? That sure sounds perfect as I type this... My brother always gets the Buenos Dias plate, usually Christmas. Man, I love this place. But I'm leaving it down here for some reason.
https://www.pantrysantafe.com/
- Santa Fe Bite - used to be the home of the best burger in the world. Now the home of a damn fine green chile cheeseburger, probably still the best in the city (though Horseman's might have something to say about that) and still one of the better burgers in the world.
https://www.santafebitenm.com/home
- Posa's - The best tamales in town, fueled by red and green (you want the red). Their burritos are also serious contenders for best in town.
https://santafetamales.com/
- Cafe Pasqual's - takes a chef-y, high-end approach to New Mexican food, serves a killer breakfast but there will be a wait. And a pricetag.
https://pasquals.com/
- Clafouti's - in case you need a break from New Mexican food, this french cafe is really great. Absolutely killer pastries, too.
https://www.clafoutis.biz/
- Harry's Roadhouse - not sure why you would go here if you don't spend a lot of time in Santa Fe, but this place is just cool, a favorite among the locals, run by good people, serving reliably good food.
https://www.harrysroadhousesf.com/
- La Reina - slightly too cool tequila/mezcal/margarita bar in the slightly too cool El Rey Court (see below), a fixed-up old Route 66 motel that has been lovingly and artistically gentrified/restored. I'm being overly harsh in my description - I actually love this place, it's great. A breath of 21st century in a very 19th century town, but very much in a good way. Austinites and Los Angelenos will feel at home here.
https://elreycourt.com/la-reina
- The Matador - if you need a dive bar in Santa Fe, this is it.
116 W San Francisco St, Santa Fe, NM 87501

I figured I might as well go all the way. Hope this is useful, or at least decent reading. If you go to any of these spots let me know! I also have places to visit and stay if you need rec's!

You've got a great list there. Great to see you put Harry's Roadhouse. Only contradiction I have is Posa's suck donkey balls. Those are not good tamales.
reload85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Tiny's has live music and killer Chile Rellenos.
Streetfighter 02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
CDub06 said:

Everyone is going to recommend The Shed, which is fine. But it's the must visit spot.

I really like Radish & Rye as a fancy spot.
Sazon is a great fancy Mexican spot.

Clafoutis would be a good breakfast spot. It's a French place that has a great breakfast.
Cafe Pasquals is another favorite for breakfast.

For New Mexican, I like The Pantry Rio or Casa Chimayo.
Tune Up Cafe is a cool Salvadorean / New Mexican spot.

Dr. Field Goods is probably the place I eat lunch at the most.

Rowley Farmhouse is a nice wild ale brewery with great food.
Paper Dosa is tremendous for Indian food.
Jambo Cafe for African.

Cafe Pasquals is good for any meal of the day.

I ate at Alkeme in October and it was the surprise meal of my trip. Very good Vietnamese.
Reel Aggies
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Pantry for breakfast, the xmas breakfast burrito with chorizo makes me hungry everytime I think about it. Cant wait to go back.
austinag1997
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dang! I went to The Shed some 25 yrs ago when there was no line
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

You know places like per ce in NYC and Keller's sister French Laundry have people walk out going "dang, I just don't get what all the hype is about that place.


That was definitely not my experience at either of those places
Tecolote
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
GAC06 said:

Quote:

You know places like per ce in NYC and Keller's sister French Laundry have people walk out going "dang, I just don't get what all the hype is about that place.


That was definitely not my experience at either of those places

Same for me - there is a reason both are 3-stars. Keller is a friend of my wife. He's a nice guy. Love going back in the kitchens at both places as they have big screens up showing the other restaurant's kitchen.

Was just saying that the craziest thing is restaurant recommendations. As I've said being local to Santa Fe, everyone has their opinion. Lots on this thread bash the Shed. But, their No. 5 Enchilada plate with beans and posole and extra garlic bread is pretty ****ing good even if people think it is a touristy place.

EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Tecolote said:

GAC06 said:

Quote:

You know places like per ce in NYC and Keller's sister French Laundry have people walk out going "dang, I just don't get what all the hype is about that place.


That was definitely not my experience at either of those places

Same for me - there is a reason both are 3-stars. Keller is a friend of my wife. He's a nice guy. Love going back in the kitchens at both places as they have big screens up showing the other restaurant's kitchen.

Was just saying that the craziest thing is restaurant recommendations. As I've said being local to Santa Fe, everyone has their opinion. Lots on this thread bash the Shed. But, their No. 5 Enchilada plate with beans and posole and extra garlic bread is pretty ****ing good even if people think it is a touristy place.



Thomas Keller could not have been more gracious when we went into the kitchen at TFL. He talked with us for a couple of minutes, posed for a bunch of photos and acted like we were the most important guests he's ever served. I was in awe.

Plus, I agree about The Shed. It's one of those restaurants that you have to try as a tourist. And I thought it was pretty good for a casual dining joint. I enjoyed experiencing the difference between Tex-Mex and New Mexico-Mex.
ILikeTacos
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
EclipseAg said:

Tecolote said:

GAC06 said:

Quote:

You know places like per ce in NYC and Keller's sister French Laundry have people walk out going "dang, I just don't get what all the hype is about that place.


That was definitely not my experience at either of those places

Same for me - there is a reason both are 3-stars. Keller is a friend of my wife. He's a nice guy. Love going back in the kitchens at both places as they have big screens up showing the other restaurant's kitchen.

Was just saying that the craziest thing is restaurant recommendations. As I've said being local to Santa Fe, everyone has their opinion. Lots on this thread bash the Shed. But, their No. 5 Enchilada plate with beans and posole and extra garlic bread is pretty ****ing good even if people think it is a touristy place.



Thomas Keller could not have been more gracious when we went into the kitchen at TFL. He talked with us for a couple of minutes, posed for a bunch of photos and acted like we were the most important guests he's ever served. I was in awe.



Same experience we had with the kitchen visit at French Laundry.

On the lines of TK restaurants that were originally quoted, I did walk out of Bouchon in Yountville not really getting the hype, It was good, but not great for me. However the bakery in the morning, perfection. And Ad Hoc, holy crap, been there 4 times and every time blown away. The fried chicken outside.... good lord.

Back to Santa Fe restaurants, I don't have anything to contribute, but want to visit again. I live in Denver and that would be a great weekend trip for the wife and I this spring, so will keep an eye on this thread.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.