Anyone try any of these? I'm trying to avoid too much sugar, but I saw some on clearance at Walmart a few months ago and bought some. Saw some more again, but not on clearance, so I justified not buying them. I like them for the novelty, and they're ok, but I don't think I'd get them on a regular basis. Also brings back memories of being a kid and eating like crap.

So far I've tried
-Oatmeal Cream pies - a little too much cream and sweatness, would've been better with more of the cookie base
-Christmas tree cakes - icing was too sweet, and glitter sprinkles a bit annoying, but not bad
-Star crunch - wasn't a fan of the actual snack, but liked the ice cream
-Unicorn cake - similar to christmas tree cake ice cream


What I think I'd like to try
-Nutty bars
-Cosmic brownie
-Swiss cake rolls

Not particularly interested in
-Strawberry shortcake rolls
-Honey buns
-Zebra cakes
-Pumpkin delights

Am I missing any? Anyone have any experience with them? What are your thoughts on the different flavors?

Who are they using for dairy and ice cream?

MarathonAg12 said:

---

Who are they using for dairy and ice cream?

---

Is there chunks of the food in the ice cream or is like someone nutted in a pint of ice cream?

MarathonAg12 said:

---

MarathonAg12 said:

---

Who are they using for dairy and ice cream?

---

Is there chunks of the food in the ice cream or is like someone nutted in a pint of ice cream?

---

I'm not sure who makes the ice cream. I think the ice cream is of ok quality. Hard to tell with the other stuff in it. But it's basically like they took the actual pastry and mixed it in the ice cream. So like with the Christmas tree one there was chunks of the Christmas tree cake with icing layers still between cake. Even in my freezer for a day, it didn't freeze as hard as typical ice cream does. I suspect the cake pieces prevented it from freezing hard, but I don't know if they added extra thickeners/ gums to it.

It's only sold at Walmart, so probably the same ice cream in Great Value brand.

I have had them all and cosmic brownie is easily the best

MookieBlaylock said:

---

I have had them all and cosmic brownie is easily the best

---

How would you rank them?

Haven't seen those, but the Blue Bell Oatmeal cream pie ice cream was fantastic.

Cosmic
Nutty Bar
Cream pie
Zebra / swiss same
Honey buns
Strawberry yuk

Now the cakes too 3
Fudge round
Zebra
Brownie - original with nuts
Form into a terd shape and enjoy

Little Debbie's are ass, my dude.

Know Your Enemy said:

---

Little Debbie's are ass, my dude.

---

U wood know what ass tastes like

Thanks. I might hit pause on my healthiness for a bit and get my hands on some cosmic brownie and nutty bar.

Yeah it was a bad month when I saw those

Life's too short for **** ice cream….

htxag09 said:

---

Life's too short for **** ice cream….

---

But it's long enough for you to care about what others like

Swiss rolls don't need ice cream