I had a similar experience with the recipe on the front page and the queso not being to my preferred thickness level. I would reduce the amount of water you are using.schmendeler said:
That's possible. I consider what I get at Pappasito's or el tiempo to be about perfect when piping hot (similar to heavy cream). When cold, those are the consistency of a thick yogurt. The queso I ended up with was the consistency of whole milk when hot and heavy cream when cold.