What does this even mean?...CD's, a savings account, treasuries, money market account, money market fund, treasury etf's, individual bonds..what? All of the above or none of the above?
Post Reply
1 of 1
"Going to Cash"
6,278 Views |
28 Replies |
Last: 4 mo ago by jamey
Yes
timing the marketmatureag said:
What does this even mean?
it doesn't mean treasury etfs or individual bonds.
Money market is the easiest instrument to use as "cash". It's paying ~ 5% and you can easily purchase equities with it if you want to get back in. Most big bank savings accounts still pay less than 1%. High yield savings accounts are out there, but it's not as easy to move back to a position where you can purchase stock.matureag said:
What does this even mean?...CD's, a savings account, treasuries, money market account, money market fund, treasury etf's, individual bonds..what? All of the above or none of the above?
Fidelity, Schwab and I'm sure others all have money market accounts paying ~5% right now.
In order of liquidity, here's my take:
1. Paper money stuffed under a mattress
2. Checking account
3. Savings account
4. Money market funds
5. CDs
6. Annuity or Life Insurance Cash Value
Most other things are not really cash equivalents -- not gold bullion, treasuries, bonds, bitcoin, commercial paper, etc. They all have enough market risk, credit risk, liquidity risk, or interest rate risk to make them VERY poor cash substitutes (although they might be very good investments).
That said, I'd generally stick to options 4 and 5 above to get the best current risk/reward tradeoff on cash positions you choose to maintain. Specifically, I'd say half in money market and half in laddered CDs would be a good starting point to begin your analysis.
1. Paper money stuffed under a mattress
2. Checking account
3. Savings account
4. Money market funds
5. CDs
6. Annuity or Life Insurance Cash Value
Most other things are not really cash equivalents -- not gold bullion, treasuries, bonds, bitcoin, commercial paper, etc. They all have enough market risk, credit risk, liquidity risk, or interest rate risk to make them VERY poor cash substitutes (although they might be very good investments).
That said, I'd generally stick to options 4 and 5 above to get the best current risk/reward tradeoff on cash positions you choose to maintain. Specifically, I'd say half in money market and half in laddered CDs would be a good starting point to begin your analysis.
Please explain the difference in risk between buying a CD vs buying a treasury note/bond.
With the bank weirdness going on in Australia, cashless banking, "going cash" means something entirely different.
"Customers have five days until Macquarie Bank goes cashless"
"Customers have five days until Macquarie Bank goes cashless"
Globalists demand cashless societies. All digital means tighter controls on people's spending. I don't like it...not one bit.Quote:
From November 1, Australia's fifth-largest bank will become completely cashless.
Customers will be unable to write or deposit personal cheques, deposit or request bank cheques, deposit cash or cheques over the counter at NAB branches and make a super contribution or payment via cheque.
Any cheques received after October 31 will be returned to the sender.
That is a very involved question, but maybe if I give a few examples, it will help. They really are quite different. One of our banker posters could do a much better job than I.GasAg90 said:
Please explain the difference in risk between buying a CD vs buying a treasury note/bond.
An attempt to explain interest rate risk and reinvestment risk: First: If you could buy a 30 year CD (you can't) to match the timeframe of a newly issued 30 year treasury, the differences might be small, and they might be large. The timing of semi-annual T-bond interest payments (coupons) vs. the internal reinvestment of the CD's interest crediting method and compounding (daily, monthly, quarterly, annual?) of a particular CD is a big factor. How do you reinvest the first treasury coupon? In a new 30-year bond? In a 29.5 year maturity bond? In a 6 month CD? Who knows? Obviously, interest rates are changing every day, so it is virtually impossible that you will get the same result. So, at any time, the CD or the Treasury will be "riskier", but you never know which direction rates will go, or how the future you personally decides to reinvest the income.
As I understand it, the idea of "moving to cash" involves staying liquid, to invest elsewhere on some future "better day". We're generally looking at a pretty short time horizon, right? A CD does a pretty good job of this when you buy short term (3-12 months?) instruments. Worst case, you cash out early and pay a small penalty. A T-bond is quite different, as you're very dependent on the future interest rate environment. Bonds lost significant value in the last couple of years as the Fed hiked interest rates (as you were locked into long term lower interest coupons than what is currently available). In fact, it probably erased the value of all interest paid on the bonds if you bought in early 2022, for example. If you need the money now and liquidate, you'll be taking quite a hit. So, CDs probably win if your start date was Jan. '22. If you invest today, and rates plummet back to where they were in 2021, your t-bond will be quite a bit more valuable, and probably wins over a short-term CD. Timing is everything.
Bottom line - - treasuries are not a good place to hold short-term cash. Fit the solution to the problem, and I stand by my statement that money market and maybe laddered CDs are a good place to stash cash for future investment needs. If you want to get exotic and hedge the interest rate risk of treasuries, you might get closer to something optimal, but I doubt the results are worth the effort and frictional costs.
I bleed maroon said:That is a very involved question, but maybe if I give a few examples, it will help. They really are quite different. One of our banker posters could do a much better job than I.GasAg90 said:
Please explain the difference in risk between buying a CD vs buying a treasury note/bond.
An attempt to explain interest rate risk and reinvestment risk: First: If you could buy a 30 year CD (you can't) to match the timeframe of a newly issued 30 year treasury, the differences might be small, and they might be large. The timing of semi-annual T-bond interest payments (coupons) vs. the internal reinvestment of the CD's interest crediting method and compounding (daily, monthly, quarterly, annual?) of a particular CD is a big factor. How do you reinvest the first treasury coupon? In a new 30-year bond? In a 29.5 year maturity bond? In a 6 month CD? Who knows? Obviously, interest rates are changing every day, so it is virtually impossible that you will get the same result. So, at any time, the CD or the Treasury will be "riskier", but you never know which direction rates will go, or how the future you personally decides to reinvest the income.
As I understand it, the idea of "moving to cash" involves staying liquid, to invest elsewhere on some future "better day". We're generally looking at a pretty short time horizon, right? A CD does a pretty good job of this when you buy short term (3-12 months?) instruments. Worst case, you cash out early and pay a small penalty. A T-bond is quite different, as you're very dependent on the future interest rate environment. Bonds lost significant value in the last couple of years as the Fed hiked interest rates (as you were locked into long term lower interest coupons than what is currently available). In fact, it probably erased the value of all interest paid on the bonds if you bought in early 2022, for example. If you need the money now and liquidate, you'll be taking quite a hit. So, CDs probably win if your start date was Jan. '22. If you invest today, and rates plummet back to where they were in 2021, your t-bond will be quite a bit more valuable, and probably wins over a short-term CD. Timing is everything.
Bottom line - - treasuries are not a good place to hold short-term cash. Fit the solution to the problem, and I stand by my statement that money market and maybe laddered CDs are a good place to stash cash for future investment needs. If you want to get exotic and hedge the interest rate risk of treasuries, you might get closer to something optimal, but I doubt the results are worth the effort and frictional costs.
For short-term "cash" needs, a T-bill is better than a CD right now.
If you live somewhere with a state income tax, that's likely true. For others, it's close to a wash. You can't really go wrong with either for short term needs in the current inverted yield curve environment.BTHOB said:
For short-term "cash" needs, a T-bill is better than a CD right now.
My statements above were in response to the poster's question about longer term t-bonds and T-notes, not short-term T-bills.
Treasuries are not cash. While you are technically "guaranteed" a return of your money, you are still investing with faith in the treasury to pay you back, and the treasury has no money. While that's seemingly never been a problem in our history, we've never been in a time of peace, in an inflationary environment, with record debt and deficits. Also, should you need the liquidity, you are at risk of losing money.
A money market account through your broker is not cash, unless you know for certain you can pull every dollar out tomorrow. Do they have your cash? If not, where did they put it and what is the risk profile of that holder? And what if you stock broker goes under? Where is your cash? Is some government entity that is also broke guaranteeing you cash they don't have?
While technically cash in your bank account is "cash", they don't have your money. They don't have 90% of any deposits. It's been loaned out or is parked somewhere else. The entire system is leveraged 100 times over. Should you come calling for your cash at a time where many others are as well, you likely aren't going to get it.
If you are truly going cash, as in.. you want to guarantee the cash you have is in your hands and you have direct access to it, you better be sure your bank is safe or you better have physical cash.
Now I'm not saying that's what you should do. But you absolutely need to understand the unprecedented risks in the system right now.
A money market account through your broker is not cash, unless you know for certain you can pull every dollar out tomorrow. Do they have your cash? If not, where did they put it and what is the risk profile of that holder? And what if you stock broker goes under? Where is your cash? Is some government entity that is also broke guaranteeing you cash they don't have?
While technically cash in your bank account is "cash", they don't have your money. They don't have 90% of any deposits. It's been loaned out or is parked somewhere else. The entire system is leveraged 100 times over. Should you come calling for your cash at a time where many others are as well, you likely aren't going to get it.
If you are truly going cash, as in.. you want to guarantee the cash you have is in your hands and you have direct access to it, you better be sure your bank is safe or you better have physical cash.
Now I'm not saying that's what you should do. But you absolutely need to understand the unprecedented risks in the system right now.
"H-A: In return for the flattery, can you reduce the size of your signature? It's the only part of your posts that don't add value. In its' place, just put "I'm an investing savant, and make no apologies for it", as oldarmy1 would do."
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
I bleed maroon said:
In order of liquidity, here's my take:
1. Paper money stuffed under a mattress
2. Checking account
3. Savings account
4. Money market funds
5. CDs
6. Annuity or Life Insurance Cash Value
Most other things are not really cash equivalents -- not gold bullion, treasuries, bonds, bitcoin, commercial paper, etc. They all have enough market risk, credit risk, liquidity risk, or interest rate risk to make them VERY poor cash substitutes (although they might be very good investments).
That said, I'd generally stick to options 4 and 5 above to get the best current risk/reward tradeoff on cash positions you choose to maintain. Specifically, I'd say half in money market and half in laddered CDs would be a good starting point to begin your analysis.
Paper money really isn't liquid anymore unless you are talking amounts under $10k. It is very hard to move large sums of cash.
The most liquid thing is a checking account by far. you can write a check for 100k and no one blinks, I can transfer 100k online in seconds. Leaves a trail, but by far the easiest way to move money.
Disagree completely. You introduced new information (who was talking about $100k+?). Checks are not cleared immediately - money is held at the receiving bank until cleared, and any number of verification processes happen (especially for larger checks) which can slow the process down. Cash is transferred physically, and immediately, in almost all cases (regulatory reporting of transactions over $10k is a separate issue to consider).knoxtom said:I bleed maroon said:
In order of liquidity, here's my take:
1. Paper money stuffed under a mattress
2. Checking account
3. Savings account
4. Money market funds
5. CDs
6. Annuity or Life Insurance Cash Value
Most other things are not really cash equivalents -- not gold bullion, treasuries, bonds, bitcoin, commercial paper, etc. They all have enough market risk, credit risk, liquidity risk, or interest rate risk to make them VERY poor cash substitutes (although they might be very good investments).
That said, I'd generally stick to options 4 and 5 above to get the best current risk/reward tradeoff on cash positions you choose to maintain. Specifically, I'd say half in money market and half in laddered CDs would be a good starting point to begin your analysis.
Paper money really isn't liquid anymore unless you are talking amounts under $10k. It is very hard to move large sums of cash.
The most liquid thing is a checking account by far. you can write a check for 100k and no one blinks, I can transfer 100k online in seconds. Leaves a trail, but by far the easiest way to move money.
While I in no way recommend it, cash is king.
Okay...those in heavy cash (I'm sort of one of them) when does the FOMO win vs the patience to wait for a better buying opportunity?
my cash has been slowly 'building up' close to 3% (I'm typically <1%) mainly due to my increasing hesitancy in buying into broader market at ATH's
401K still auto DCA's $2K monthly into S&P, but the 60% of take home getting saved has been mainly getting shoveled into money market and used to buy occasional individual dips now (TSLA/ENPH/SOFI/SMCI/POWL most recently)
portfolio gains ytd is approaching 1.5x annual income already so suppose keeping a bit of cash on hand isn't terrible
401K still auto DCA's $2K monthly into S&P, but the 60% of take home getting saved has been mainly getting shoveled into money market and used to buy occasional individual dips now (TSLA/ENPH/SOFI/SMCI/POWL most recently)
portfolio gains ytd is approaching 1.5x annual income already so suppose keeping a bit of cash on hand isn't terrible
I went from like 80% cash in March/April to slightly less than 50%, buying metals, promising energy stock setups, and recently, TLT. I have less than 10% exposure to broader equities with TSLA being the bulk of it.El Chupacabra said:
Okay...those in heavy cash (I'm sort of one of them) when does the FOMO win vs the patience to wait for a better buying opportunity?
"H-A: In return for the flattery, can you reduce the size of your signature? It's the only part of your posts that don't add value. In its' place, just put "I'm an investing savant, and make no apologies for it", as oldarmy1 would do."
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
when was your initial move into majority cash?
Speaking of moving to cash...
Is anyone concerned about the market valuation right now? Shiller is at 36.21, highest since the 2000 bubble.
Im not sure we can ever match that 2000 bubble again because of program trading and day traders. We didn't have that back then. The ability to panic trade at high speed did not exist.
Surely we are in correction territory?
Is anyone concerned about the market valuation right now? Shiller is at 36.21, highest since the 2000 bubble.
Im not sure we can ever match that 2000 bubble again because of program trading and day traders. We didn't have that back then. The ability to panic trade at high speed did not exist.
Surely we are in correction territory?
To me "moving to cash" involves staying liquid and also preserving principle.
We have 2 years of cash all in our online savings account earning around 5.3% last I looked. We keep another 2 months of cash (equal to monthly expenses) in our checking account. To clarify, my two, current month paychecks cover the month we are in and then I keep another equivalent month of cash in checking on top of that.
We have another portion of our portfolio in a muni bond ladder that spins off cash every quarter equal to about $50k per year, currently. We usually reinvest that right back into the ladder as long as the rates are staying at 5-6%. We can take that quarterly pay out as cash if we need to but have only done that once to cover some house reno we did when we moved.
When/if the munis stop paying what they are paying, we will divert all that money elsewhere to some other semi-conservative vehicle.
We have another portion of our portfolio in a muni bond ladder that spins off cash every quarter equal to about $50k per year, currently. We usually reinvest that right back into the ladder as long as the rates are staying at 5-6%. We can take that quarterly pay out as cash if we need to but have only done that once to cover some house reno we did when we moved.
When/if the munis stop paying what they are paying, we will divert all that money elsewhere to some other semi-conservative vehicle.
Big chunk in late last year, with goal of moving into metals if the setups formed. They did and I've been layering in for half a year. Another chunk when bonds looked to be making a bullish setup earlier. Bond setup failed on first go around as it chopped around a bit, but is taking hold now. Another chunk when oil and energy started showing a good setup. Started layering in two months ago and will layer a little more over the next month or so.EliteZags said:
when was your initial move into majority cash?
My thesis is to align with the bull markets as they form, not to catch the high in the ones that have already happened.
"H-A: In return for the flattery, can you reduce the size of your signature? It's the only part of your posts that don't add value. In its' place, just put "I'm an investing savant, and make no apologies for it", as oldarmy1 would do."
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
What's your bond setup?
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
My "tradeable" money is in TLT. My 401k is in bond funds. I see TLT going to $105 this year and possibly $120 over the next 1-2 years as rates come down, setting up a crash heading into 2026-2028 period.jamey said:
What's your bond setup?
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
"H-A: In return for the flattery, can you reduce the size of your signature? It's the only part of your posts that don't add value. In its' place, just put "I'm an investing savant, and make no apologies for it", as oldarmy1 would do."
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
Heineken-Ashi said:My "tradeable" money is in TLT. My 401k is in bond funds. I see TLT going to $105 this year and possibly $120 over the next 1-2 years as rates come down, setting up a crash heading into 2026-2028 period.jamey said:
What's your bond setup?
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
All mine is in my 401K bond fund which replicates the Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index. I hope that's good enough
Everything in the self managed account is pretty small potatos, and mostly AI and other rate plays like XBI
That's probably the same fund I'm in. Should do well for a while.jamey said:Heineken-Ashi said:My "tradeable" money is in TLT. My 401k is in bond funds. I see TLT going to $105 this year and possibly $120 over the next 1-2 years as rates come down, setting up a crash heading into 2026-2028 period.jamey said:
What's your bond setup?
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
All mine is in my 401K bond fund which replicates the Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index. I hope that's good enough
Everything in the self managed account is pretty small potatos, and mostly AI and other rate plays like XBI
I was going to tell you to look at individual Russell plays, but wait for the market to sort out Monday. Might be crazy.
"H-A: In return for the flattery, can you reduce the size of your signature? It's the only part of your posts that don't add value. In its' place, just put "I'm an investing savant, and make no apologies for it", as oldarmy1 would do."
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
Heineken-Ashi said:That's probably the same fund I'm in. Should do well for a while.jamey said:Heineken-Ashi said:My "tradeable" money is in TLT. My 401k is in bond funds. I see TLT going to $105 this year and possibly $120 over the next 1-2 years as rates come down, setting up a crash heading into 2026-2028 period.jamey said:
What's your bond setup?
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
All mine is in my 401K bond fund which replicates the Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index. I hope that's good enough
Everything in the self managed account is pretty small potatos, and mostly AI and other rate plays like XBI
I was going to tell you to look at individual Russell plays, but wait for the market to sort out Monday. Might be crazy.
I'm looking at WEC energy, located up north as a combination rate, energy and AI play
I went with the Russell as whole in the 401K fund, probably in on average around 1850 - 1950 and at around 22% of my portfolio and plan to sell it off as it goes up until it's closer to 10 or 12% of portfolio. For now I'm still buying the Russell fund with new money on my weekly paycheck but 75% of new money is going to bonds fund
One of my bigger rate plays in the self managed account is XBI at $70 average
Just be careful. Crazy environment we're in and small caps will be hardest to fall in a bloodbath.jamey said:Heineken-Ashi said:That's probably the same fund I'm in. Should do well for a while.jamey said:Heineken-Ashi said:My "tradeable" money is in TLT. My 401k is in bond funds. I see TLT going to $105 this year and possibly $120 over the next 1-2 years as rates come down, setting up a crash heading into 2026-2028 period.jamey said:
What's your bond setup?
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
All mine is in my 401K bond fund which replicates the Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index. I hope that's good enough
Everything in the self managed account is pretty small potatos, and mostly AI and other rate plays like XBI
I was going to tell you to look at individual Russell plays, but wait for the market to sort out Monday. Might be crazy.
I'm looking at WEC energy, located up north as a combination rate, energy and AI play
I went with the Russell as whole in the 401K fund, probably in on average around 1850 - 1950 and at around 22% of my portfolio and plan to sell it off as it goes up until it's closer to 10 or 12% of portfolio. For now I'm still buying the Russell fund with new money on my weekly paycheck but 75% of new money is going to bonds fund
One of my bigger rate plays in the self managed account is XBI at $70 average
"H-A: In return for the flattery, can you reduce the size of your signature? It's the only part of your posts that don't add value. In its' place, just put "I'm an investing savant, and make no apologies for it", as oldarmy1 would do."
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
- I Bleed Maroon (distracted easily by signatures)
Heineken-Ashi said:Just be careful. Crazy environment we're in and small caps will be hardest to fall in a bloodbath.jamey said:Heineken-Ashi said:That's probably the same fund I'm in. Should do well for a while.jamey said:Heineken-Ashi said:My "tradeable" money is in TLT. My 401k is in bond funds. I see TLT going to $105 this year and possibly $120 over the next 1-2 years as rates come down, setting up a crash heading into 2026-2028 period.jamey said:
What's your bond setup?
I've been buying bonds for the first time over the last year or so when the yields got better
I assume prices on what I have will be better too when the rates come down
All mine is in my 401K bond fund which replicates the Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index. I hope that's good enough
Everything in the self managed account is pretty small potatos, and mostly AI and other rate plays like XBI
I was going to tell you to look at individual Russell plays, but wait for the market to sort out Monday. Might be crazy.
I'm looking at WEC energy, located up north as a combination rate, energy and AI play
I went with the Russell as whole in the 401K fund, probably in on average around 1850 - 1950 and at around 22% of my portfolio and plan to sell it off as it goes up until it's closer to 10 or 12% of portfolio. For now I'm still buying the Russell fund with new money on my weekly paycheck but 75% of new money is going to bonds fund
One of my bigger rate plays in the self managed account is XBI at $70 average
Is most or all of your 401K money in the bond fund?
Featured Stories
See All
19:50
2h ago
2.1k
Donors can now earn priority points by giving to Texas Aggies United
by Texas Aggies United
A&M's approach remains the same with NMSU coming to Aggieland
by Olin Buchanan
61:40
3h ago
1.2k
Keys to the Game: No. 23 Texas A&M vs. No. 21 Ohio State
by Luke Evangelist
6:01
1h ago
434
ConfidentAg
Michigan to Offer 5 Star LSU QB Commit 8 Figure Deal
in Billy Liucci's TexAgs Premium
46
ElkoSZN
Instead of scheduling tough non-conference games like ND...
in Billy Liucci's TexAgs Premium
29