My wife and I are kicking around a trip there in a few months. We've never been, so are starting to do some research. One of the things we've looked at are the smaller boat cruises (e.g. Windstar). Thoughts? We're not averse to just a traditional one island hotel stay. If it were just a single island, which is your favorite? Night life is not a big factor; she's more interested in nice beaches, snorkeling, some scenery or sightseeing options and that other "s" word (shopping).