tjack16 said:Twisted Helix said:
No
Why would you have him on it based on his current performances? Playoffs aren't the time for the "back of the baseball card" argument.
Unless he turns it around tonight and going forward he won't be on until maybe the ALCS when it's a 7 game series
Twisted Helix said:
What happened to 2015? I'd like to hear him opine on JV.
What role is he going to fill? Why on earth would you carry a guy who you can't trust with a start and who you have no idea how he would pitch as a reliever and use him as a dead spot on your roster? With the rotation we have now and the bullpen arms we know we can (usually) rely on, whose spot are you going to give him?Beat40 said:tjack16 said:Twisted Helix said:
No
Why would you have him on it based on his current performances? Playoffs aren't the time for the "back of the baseball card" argument.
Unless he turns it around tonight and going forward he won't be on until maybe the ALCS when it's a 7 game series
I don't think they're leaving a future HOF off the postseason roster. He may not pitch, but I'm not sure he's getting left off.
txags92 said:What role is he going to fill? Why on earth would you carry a guy who you can't trust with a start and who you have no idea how he would pitch as a reliever and use him as a dead spot on your roster? With the rotation we have now and the bullpen arms we know we can (usually) rely on, whose spot are you going to give him?Beat40 said:tjack16 said:Twisted Helix said:
No
Why would you have him on it based on his current performances? Playoffs aren't the time for the "back of the baseball card" argument.
Unless he turns it around tonight and going forward he won't be on until maybe the ALCS when it's a 7 game series
I don't think they're leaving a future HOF off the postseason roster. He may not pitch, but I'm not sure he's getting left off.
Beat40 said:tjack16 said:Twisted Helix said:
No
Why would you have him on it based on his current performances? Playoffs aren't the time for the "back of the baseball card" argument.
Unless he turns it around tonight and going forward he won't be on until maybe the ALCS when it's a 7 game series
I don't think they're leaving a future HOF off the postseason roster. He may not pitch, but I'm not sure he's getting left off.
Yeshtxag09 said:
I'm very confused by mlb rules. How's rock the baby illegal but this guys motion isn't?
Mathguy64 said:Beat40 said:tjack16 said:Twisted Helix said:
No
Why would you have him on it based on his current performances? Playoffs aren't the time for the "back of the baseball card" argument.
Unless he turns it around tonight and going forward he won't be on until maybe the ALCS when it's a 7 game series
I don't think they're leaving a future HOF off the postseason roster. He may not pitch, but I'm not sure he's getting left off.
It's pointless to put him on the WC roster unless you plan on him starting game 3. He's not coming out of the pen.
