La Fours said:
CY has been impressive so far since taking over. To that point, I wish someone would write a book or a long form article that details JD's tenure and what changed after the 2011 season until his exit. From 2009-2011 seemed like everything JD touched was gold with trades and FA signings. Then a decade + of mediocrity.
Here you go:
JD is interesting... I think they found some ways to game the system and MLB closed those loopholes for the sake of parity.
For example, in 2007, losing Top FAs would get a Comp pick. So, the Rangers signed a bunch of guys in 2006 to 1yr contracts. The rule has been changed that the player has to be on the team 1yr, so mid-season traded players no longer carry that extra value.
Eric Gagne -> Traded to BoSox for Engel Beltre, Gabbard, and David Murphy.
That was the year of the Teixeira trade. The Rangers had leverage that a QO for Teixeira would return basically a pick after the 1st Rd. So, Atlanta knowing THEY'D get the pick were willing to offer more for Teixeira.
Preller - He was with the Rangers from '04-14. You can read his impact, but he opened up the DR to the Rangers.
https://www.espn.co.uk/dallas/mlb/story/_/id/6967542/texas-rangers-committed-dominican-republic-part-international-scouting-plan Preller got busted for several violations, including forging birth certificates, etc. Agents were getting slid money to steer players to sign in different places and birth certificates were highly unreliable.
MLB closed that exploit by creating an International signing period with limited Pool money. I think losing Preller was a big deal.
Most importantly, Preller brought Don Welke to the Rangers from the Dodgers organization, wehre Welke mentored Preller. Preller took Welke to SD when he left. I think that was huge. Rangers were able to get a longtime, well respected Scouting Director.
I think guys like Matt Bush and Hamilton gave him confidence in taking risk. And guys like Darvish and Fielder, among others caused pause. JD at one point either directly or indirectly expressed that if he had $40M to spend on SP... he could sign 4 guys at $10M... 2 guys at $20M/ea or 1 ToTR guy for $40M.
Losing Fielder was a waste. He believed SPs were more likley going to be lost for TJ at some point, so rather than putting all his eggs in a $40M basket, and then only have a minor leaguer behind him, he could sign a bunch of guys and when one SP goes down, he would have another waiting. In ST, you just let it sort itself out.
Next came the problem of Rule V where now he can't just stockpile all this talent.
When he sat in the dugout after the Cardinals game, you knew he had been broken.
I think he became too attached to the money/cost aspect and became too tentative. I'm not sure what the Owner situation was. I believe one of the owners was going through divorce and Oil was down, so I'm not sure if the FO tightened up the money, but things certainly changed.