Imagine someone throwing an actual beach ball at you while you were on ADHD meds. It would be downright scary.
Why?Corporal Punishment said:
I'm going to burn in Hell because I'm enjoying the **** out of this.
I won't deny the claims Adderall helps you concentrate on what you want to concentrate on. I will not deny it allows you (and many others) to actually sit and when when you take it. Does Adderall affect people the way it claims? Absolutely.iceman08 said:Soap Box Two*:DallasAg 94 said:
Soap Box Two
Having said that... I've been very critical of his use of Adderral. ADHD is a made up disease that only requires 3 people to say you have it, in order to be diagnosed. It is a scam. As one poster on here noted, it makes the ball come in looking like a beach ball.
No it's not. I have ADHD, and I can tell you, Adderall is not a miracle drug that will make a ball coming in looking like a beach ball. It just helps me be "normal" and concentrate on what I want to concentrate on. I'm able to actually sit and read when I take it. And to anyone saying "ugh, it's just in your head" - why yes,yes it is.
It is just as folly to assume I have no experience with it because you don't like my position. I deal with learning-differenced kids every day. My kid attends such a school, and almost half of the kids have "ADHD" diagnosis, and after about the 3rd or 4th time the kid is sent to the principal, the kid gets Adderall (or other such drug).Chase said:It is very easy for someone without a problem to believe that problem doesn't exist but to speak so definitively on a subject you obviously don't have experience with is just inane.DallasAg 94 said:
Soap Box Two
Having said that... I've been very critical of his use of Adderral. ADHD is a made up disease that only requires 3 people to say you have it, in order to be diagnosed. It is a scam. As one poster on here noted, it makes the ball come in looking like a beach ball.
ADHD is very much a real problem but there should be proper diagnosis and attempts at correction without stimulants (including therapy) before testing to see which medication works best for the person and in what dosage.
THAT IS THE PROBLEM. The progression is:Quote:
Don't misconstrue my response to mean that I believe it to be free from misdiagnosis, over-diagnosis and parental pressure to have a child labeled ADHD to help them with school and/or extracurricular activity. If the above actions aren't in the process, the doctor is just rubber-stamping a shotgun approach to a problem that may not exist.
Educate me.powerbelly said:
That process is nothing like the process I have seen family members go through when they are evaluated for ADHD.
DallasAg 94 said:It is just as folly to assume I have no experience with it because you don't like my position. I deal with learning-differenced kids every day. My kid attends such a school, and almost half of the kids have "ADHD" diagnosis, and after about the 3rd or 4th time the kid is sent to the principal, the kid gets Adderall (or other such drug).Chase said:It is very easy for someone without a problem to believe that problem doesn't exist but to speak so definitively on a subject you obviously don't have experience with is just inane.DallasAg 94 said:
Soap Box Two
Having said that... I've been very critical of his use of Adderral. ADHD is a made up disease that only requires 3 people to say you have it, in order to be diagnosed. It is a scam. As one poster on here noted, it makes the ball come in looking like a beach ball.
ADHD is very much a real problem but there should be proper diagnosis and attempts at correction without stimulants (including therapy) before testing to see which medication works best for the person and in what dosage.
What is funny... the class just went on a field trip and I think our kid was the only one that didn't have to sign a prescription drug doc. Several teachers had pushed us towards getting our child medicated, and I assume they thought we did. The headmaster even came to us and said, "we didn't get a waiver for meds, did you fill this out?" When we said "he doesn't take meds," there is a surprising "really??" Funny enough, though... shortly after they realize he isn't on meds, we start getting calls from the school about how he seems distracted and unable to comply.THAT IS THE PROBLEM. The progression is:Quote:
Don't misconstrue my response to mean that I believe it to be free from misdiagnosis, over-diagnosis and parental pressure to have a child labeled ADHD to help them with school and/or extracurricular activity. If the above actions aren't in the process, the doctor is just rubber-stamping a shotgun approach to a problem that may not exist.
Teacher to Parent: "I think your kid needs testing" <for ADHD>
Parent to Teacher: "I struggle with my kid. I think I might have him "tested.'"
Parent to Doctor: "My school thinks my kid needs to be tested."
Doctor to Parent: "Are you willing to put him on medication? If so, have 3-4 people fill out this questionnaire."
Parent to Teacher: "My Dr wants people to fill this out, since you seem to have this child when he struggles, I'm asking you to fill it out."
Teacher to Parent: "Yes, I fill these out all the time <for the students, whose parents I recommend testing>."
Doctor to Parent: "Got the test results back. Yep, he has ADHD based on the results given by the teacher that told you to get tested."
Parent: "Adderall?"
Doctor to Parent: "Yes."
Teacher to Parent: "Your kid is so much better. He no longer disrupts my class. See, I knew Adderall would improve not just his class room, but don't you see it at home, too?"
Parent to Teacher: "I love Adderall. I have such an obedient and wonderful son."
I deal with this issue ALL THE TIME. And talk to many teachers who see how abused it is. IMO, parent don't advocate enough for their kids and strive as much for compliance as teachers do.
powerbelly said:
There was no form filled out by teachers. Several specialist visits were required and much longer and in-depth evaluation was done by doctors. The school was not involved at all.
Oyster DuPree said:
This thread sucks now. Can we get back to some good old-fashioned enjoyment of the misery of others?
It was 5 or 6 years ago. He was observed, but not by his teachers for this. It was a several month process and several therapies were tried before medication.DallasAg 94 said:powerbelly said:
There was no form filled out by teachers. Several specialist visits were required and much longer and in-depth evaluation was done by doctors. The school was not involved at all.
That doesn't make sense. I'm curious when and where that was done. Maybe 30 years ago?! But it would not meet the definition of the diagnosis, today. Has to be observed in 2 or more environments. Home, school, work. It has to meet the anecdotal markers on 6 or more of 10 observations.
I'll post a clinical definition, and encourage you to find your own source you like. I have one on my PC, but am in carpool, right now, dodging zombies. LoL
0-53RealTalk said:
So, uhm, Davis recorded a hit yet.
Corporal Punishment said:
He PH'd last night and lined out L4. I think it's 0 for 54 now. Hitless in his last 62 plate appearances.
I think he gets a hit off Porcello Saturday.
DVC2010 said:Corporal Punishment said:
He PH'd last night and lined out L4. I think it's 0 for 54 now. Hitless in his last 62 plate appearances.
I think he gets a hit off Porcello Saturday.
Was it the kind of screaming liner that makes you want to hit someone with your bat on the way back to the dugout one of those soft things that only avoided being a ground out by some trick of the launch angle?