I agree but then Cory really doesn't possess that much better PG skills (passing, vision, creating for others, etc) than Patty does. Now were just getting into what would you rather have on the floor, a better shooter or a better defender.
Whoever is consistently getting it done at their specialty skill is the answer, I suppose. There are times, like last night, where Cory is an absolute terror on the defensive side of the ball and there are times where he just isn't making that much of an impact defensively for whatever reason. Then on the other side, there's Patty, who we know can change the game with his three pt shot but who's shot is way off the mark this season. Patty is still hustling defensively but just doesn't have the tools that Cory does.
Problem with Cory is that when he's not making much of an impact defensively, is he really going to be a net positive on the court? I don't want to say the offense is inevitably going to struggle every time he's on the court, but the offense certainly isn't going to be hitting its peak consistently with him out there. His presence alone on the court make's it harder for others to create whereas the defense has no alternative then to get out and guard Patty on the three-pt line. Much like Bonner.
Certainly an interesting battle. Patty made it an easy decision last year but this is a tough one to call this season.