Texas A&M Football
Sponsored by

Players not buying in?

14,578 Views | 50 Replies | Last: 5 yr ago by Chiro1
Cancelled
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I was speaking to a friend of mine and he regularly maintains that we look like the same team year after year and experience mediocrity regardless of coach or scheme because players aren't buying into the culture of TAMU. I agree with him that short of 2012, we always look the same mediocre team.

He says that students and alumni have their vision of TAMU culture (yell practice, Silver taps, muster, E-walk etc), but players obviously aren't interested in this and aren't buying into it, which is expected. Players at Bama probably don't buy into the same things the students at Bama buy into, but they are invested in the Bama program.

He believes it is all due to the Athletic department. Says that we really have nothing to distinguish us from any other school except for a great stadium. You look at Texas or Ohio State and they celebrate their greatness and even fabricated greatness with a monumental trophy room, etc. they also have the good fortune to have a wonderful history of greatness.

Our players really have nothing to buy into. Our last NC was 1939 and our last conference championship was 1998. Fran was supposedly the best coach, he couldn't get it done. He thinks that if Jimbo can't get it done here, then we will know that nobody short of a Saban could get it done, and Saban is one in a million.

I'm sure the first few posts will consist of "shut up" and other flames, but once we get past that, we can have a discussion. Thoughts? If he is on the right train of thought, how do we fix it? Is it fixable?
Bill Superman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sounds like they're buying into the culture of mediocrity pretty well then
black_hat_ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Remember. Keep your feelings and emotions in check. Very important.
"Go drink Lysol." - BallerStaf2003
gopitt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Dumbest post of the day.
How about players and coaches just do their damn jobs?
Top 10 recruiting classes should not breed mediocrity, which is A&M's middle name.
Just another dumb excuse.
bv86ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Only problem with that theory is Clemson....who only had 1 national title to their credit prior to a couple years ago.

They gave Dabo Swinney a lot of time to build...and he did it. But they had no history of sustained greatness prior to Dabo. In fact, if you recall....people used to make fun of them choking in big games just 5 years or so ago....remember the term "clemsoning"?

Now look at them.

If it can be done at Clemson...it can be done at Texas A&M.
TxAg76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
They knew our history before they signed on. And definitely didn't sign up for what's in the past.
Dumb post is dumb. Respectfully.
HoustonAg2106
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It's silly to think players at this level should be motivated by anything other than winning championships and making it to the NFL.

Players attending fish camp, yell practice, silver taps, e-walk, etc wouldn't change a damn thing

NoahAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Posts like this are really over complicating and psychoanalyzing things. Simply put, we just haven't fielded great teams consistently over the history of our program. And that's due to recruiting and being the second team in the state.

Now over the last 8 years or so, and with the move to the SEC that has started to change. We now have the facilities. We supposedly have the coach. And most important, we are signing higher ranked classes. The downside is that we can pull a top 10 class but it's still only 5th or 6th in the conference.

Cancelled
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HoustonAg2106 said:

It's silly to think players at this level should be motivated by anything other than winning championships and making it to the NFL.

Players attending fish camp, yell practice, silver taps, e-walk, etc wouldn't change a damn thing




Reread. I didn't say they needed to attend Fish Camp; quite the opposite.
Sgt. Schultz
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think its a culture that is based a lot on the adulation that is heaped on our student athletes. We as fans, students, former students, donors, employees, etc... strut around like we are the best in everything, have the best in everything, and by extension, the best student athletes. ****, we have multiple web sites, including this one, where there is a whole lot of sunshine pumping going on. The media pumps the sunshine as well because it sells copy. And unless there is a scandal, which also sells copy, the sunshine will continue to be cast about the program. This culture is pervasive and affects football, basketball, and baseball.

When a student athlete becomes immersed with this culture, I can see how he/she would begin to think they are special. They walk into facilities that are second to none. They have every resource imaginable at their disposal. For instance, we take a 737 for the men's basketball team to travel, a 737 that seats 125+ for a team that has 12 players and maybe 10 support staff. Granted they are taller than most but it is this over the top treatment they receive that I think takes away the hunger to be great. Our student athletes do not lack or want for anything. It breeds complacency. I don't know how much it has filtered over to the women's side but it definitely resides on the men's side.
I know NOTHING!!!!
Cancelled
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
black_hat_ag said:

Remember. Keep your feelings and emotions in check. Very important.


Lol.
A Bald Fat Guy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm not convinced that the players don't buy in to A&M's culture.

I remember late last year Jimbo gave an interview or made a comment about some of the players receiving their rings, and noticing how important it was to them.

I'm not sure that the feeling is the same across the board, but I can't imagine that they spend that much time in College Station and don't make a connection somewhere.
PeekingDuck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Starts with the coach. We'll find out soon if he's what we need. I don't read much into two losses against very good teams.
Panama Red
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Players need only buy into the coach to be successful.

Their feelings on the school, what happened 20 years ago or traditions is irrelevant.


Does anyone really think the players on the Bob Stoops team in 90s cared about the OU championship from 85 and 70?

How did Florida get great under Spurrier with nothing for players to buy into?

LSU was terrible for a decade before Saban. We're those players glorying in the Curly Hallman nostalgia?
EliteZags
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
queso1 said:

He believes it is all due to the Athletic department. Says that we really have nothing to distinguish us from any other school except for a great stadium. You look at Texas or Ohio State and they celebrate their greatness and even fabricated greatness with a monumental trophy room, etc. they also have the good fortune to have a wonderful history of greatness.

Our players really have nothing to buy into.

here's what distinguishes us: the whiniest fanboard in all of college football
Indignitas
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
OP makes good points, and the responses are mostly grade 5 Zoo biowaste. Most responses on here make Tekashi69's verses seem like Richard Feynman's lectures.
BTKAG97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Why would they give a **** once the clock starts counting down?
Cynic
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I don't think it matters if the players like the culture or not. It's how well they play football.
TyHolden
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
We don't have a running game. It's as simple as that. Why we'll take at least 3 rbs this year in the draft.
Nonregdrummer09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I believe it, Von Miller hates A&M
83Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Why did the players buy in to RC in the 90s? Was it tradition, facilities, etc? No it was one of if not the best Defense in the country. It was an identity, the Wrecking Crew. It's all about the culture and that's why Jimbo is here. He will get it done.
HoustonAg2106
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Indignitas said:

OP makes good points, and the responses are mostly grade 5 Zoo biowaste. Most responses on here make Tekashi69's verses seem like Richard Feynman's lectures.


What good point did the OP make exactly?
cords12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Dude, It's not like our traditions are all we have to offer! We have World Class facilities, 100k plus stadium, SEC conference, a top education, a kind and loyal fanbase, HOT girls, etc etc etc...

Only thing they need to buy into is Jimbo's coaching philosophies
Reveille2004
How long do you want to ignore this user?
queso1 said:

I was speaking to a friend of mine and he regularly maintains that we look like the same team year after year and experience mediocrity regardless of coach or scheme because players aren't buying into the culture of TAMU. I agree with him that short of 2012, we always look the same mediocre team.

He says that students and alumni have their vision of TAMU culture (yell practice, Silver taps, muster, E-walk etc), but players obviously aren't interested in this and aren't buying into it, which is expected. Players at Bama probably don't buy into the same things the students at Bama buy into, but they are invested in the Bama program.

He believes it is all due to the Athletic department. Says that we really have nothing to distinguish us from any other school except for a great stadium. You look at Texas or Ohio State and they celebrate their greatness and even fabricated greatness with a monumental trophy room, etc. they also have the good fortune to have a wonderful history of greatness.

Our players really have nothing to buy into. Our last NC was 1939 and our last conference championship was 1998. Fran was supposedly the best coach, he couldn't get it done. He thinks that if Jimbo can't get it done here, then we will know that nobody short of a Saban could get it done, and Saban is one in a million.

I'm sure the first few posts will consist of "shut up" and other flames, but once we get past that, we can have a discussion. Thoughts? If he is on the right train of thought, how do we fix it? Is it fixable?


"Agree with him short of 2012..." Gee, I wonder what was different about that year? We had elite talent with one of greatest college players of all time with Jff and multiple first round nfl talent. THAT is the difference. Nobody has ever consistently recruited in top 10 here, and top 5 is needed to win championships. You are right, lots of players don't care about tradition, they want to play with other great players, win and get to the league. Trust in Jimbo, he needs to keep recruiting!!
Kill Switch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
F This

1 Who is the richest school in the SEC and one of the richest public schools in the US? We are!
2. Who sits in the middle of BEast Texas, the richest and most fertal recruiting grounds in the US?
3. Who has a more hungry set of fans ?
4. Who has an Alumni as big and wealthy as we have? Very F'ing few.

We have all we need to be a top school, we need to quit tripping over our own dicks with stupid **** like this and just be fans of the team.

It's not about trusting Jimbo, it's about giving him real time to build something. It would be nice if we had Bob Stoops type success, and win a Natty 2 years after he arrives. Mack Brown went 7 years before he won a Natty, that was also the same time he won his first conference championship.

Quit crying that we don't have a winning tradition. What did Miami have before Bernie Kosar and Howard Schnellenberger? What did Clemson have before Dabo? What did FSU have before Bowden?

Greatness has to start somewhere. If we don't have greatness, let it start with Jimbo.
SA-AG72
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Do we have any swag copter recruits remaining? Asking for a friend.
Wheaty44
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Would you guys just sit back and watch this program grow.How long has he (Jimbo) been here? Only one class is his from beginning to end and that is the 2019 class. Just chill
Foxo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
OP should find better friends.
MondayMorningQB
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So in summary, you must have championships before you can achieve peak greatness?
4
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Did not read. We lack athletes that can win consistently at this level. It's as simple as that.
ETXag4life
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Your friend is simply misinformed. That ring on Jimbo's finger carries weight with our soldiers. These are young men that signed on to play for one of if not the greatest college football coaches in the last decade. I don't think anybody would argue that. Our culture is Aggie pride and Aggie tradition, it is probably one of the biggest selling points along with our state-of-the-art facilities and the fact that we are one of the premiere CFB teams in America playing in the most prestigious conference in CFB history. Take my word for it these Ags are ALL IN. Its not about this year people its about 2020 and 2021! Look at our roster, plus Demas and Evans (100% Texas Aggie btw) and look at the future schedules. Be patient! We are on the precipice of CFB and SEC history. Our brothers over at Bama and LSU and Auburn, etc., can laugh now but little brother about to come take the torch away!!!!
ClassOf17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I get that players come to A&M and don't care about traditions as much as students and alumni who grew up around there..

But to say THAT is the reason they aren't now performing is just plain stupid. They came to play football. They're giving their all out there regardless of what the band does at halftime or if someone doesn't stand the entire game.

Not to mention, Jimbo is one of very few coaches still coaching that has a NC, just six years ago. If that isn't something to buy into then idk what is.
33
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bv86ag said:

Only problem with that theory is Clemson....who only had 1 national title to their credit prior to a couple years ago.

They gave Dabo Swinney a lot of time to build...and he did it. But they had no history of sustained greatness prior to Dabo. In fact, if you recall....people used to make fun of them choking in big games just 5 years or so ago....remember the term "clemsoning"?

Now look at them.

If it can be done at Clemson...it can be done at Texas A&M.


In a lot of respects, Clemson had an easier path to greatness. The only real competition for them was FSU.

A&M has to deal with LSU, Bama, Auburn in conference. In addition to that, the Ags have to out-recruit OU and Texas.

I think A&M is in a great position and Jimbo will do well. But, it will take some luck along the way, consistent recruiting and the others to stumble a little.
Win At Life
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
queso1 said:

I was speaking to a friend of mine and he regularly maintains that we look like the same team year after year and experience mediocrity regardless of coach or scheme because players aren't buying into the culture of TAMU. I agree with him that short of 2012, we always look the same mediocre team.

He says that students and alumni have their vision of TAMU culture (yell practice, Silver taps, muster, E-walk etc), but players obviously aren't interested in this and aren't buying into it, which is expected. Players at Bama probably don't buy into the same things the students at Bama buy into, but they are invested in the Bama program.

He believes it is all due to the Athletic department. Says that we really have nothing to distinguish us from any other school except for a great stadium. You look at Texas or Ohio State and they celebrate their greatness and even fabricated greatness with a monumental trophy room, etc. they also have the good fortune to have a wonderful history of greatness.

Our players really have nothing to buy into. Our last NC was 1939 and our last conference championship was 1998. Fran was supposedly the best coach, he couldn't get it done. He thinks that if Jimbo can't get it done here, then we will know that nobody short of a Saban could get it done, and Saban is one in a million.

I'm sure the first few posts will consist of "shut up" and other flames, but once we get past that, we can have a discussion. Thoughts? If he is on the right train of thought, how do we fix it? Is it fixable?


Completely disagree. Saban is a one in 50,000 coach; not one in a million coach. You couldn't be more wrong. And I could care less.
JoeAggie5
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sorry I didn't read all the posts, but seems a little insulting to accuse players of not buying in. Our schedule is a ***** this year. Our offense didn't show up for Clemson, or Auburn. I know we all have our opinions there, but it's not because they players aren't buying in.
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.