What is a historical fact or situation you learned about this year of which you were

31,733 Views | 140 Replies | Last: 4 yr ago by YZ250
VanZandt92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What is a historical fact or situation you learned about this year of which you were not aware previously? General word on this thread:

- There will be those who know more or less about any topic in history. This thread isn't meant to show how much you know and so please refrain from acting aghast that an individual is not aware of an event or fact. Nobody wants to hear that and it will cause some to go silent.

- It can probably be recognized that there are some history professionals on here, while many on here are amateur historians at all levels. Please be aware of your audience in your response and fashion your response in that manner.

For me here are a couple:

1. The majority of Confederate soldiers were married and / or had families.

I didn't know this and it has caused a great deal of change in my view of some things. I am blanking on the academic source where I read this sorry.

2. Native Americans in Canada during the French and Indian war and in those times used slavery a good deal. This seems to make sense, but I actually didn't know how precarious life was in the Canada in the 18th century.
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jaydoug
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Kennedy knew the Vietnam War was unwinnable but felt he could not get re-elected if it seemed he was soft on communism if he shut down the war
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
VanZandt92 said:

What is a historical fact or situation you learned about this year of which you were not aware previously?

For me here are a couple:

1. The majority of Confederate soldiers were married and / or had families.

I didn't know this and it has caused a great deal of change in my view of some things. I am blanking on the academic source where I read this sorry.

2. Native Americans in Canada during the French and Indian war and in those times used slavery a good deal. This seems to make sense, but I actually didn't know how precarious life was in the Canada in the 18th century.
What were Native Americans doing in Canada? Just kidding. In fact, indigenous peoples all through the Americas used slavery a good deal.
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I don't know exactly why but some of them went to Canada in the 1800s. I know a gal from Mississauga, Ontario who claims Pottawatomie heritage from Kansas. So depending on the way she's feeling each day she'll play the Native American card or the Canadian card - as to the reason why regular American rules don't apply to her.
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HollywoodBQ said:

I don't know exactly why but some of them went to Canada in the 1800s. I know a gal from Mississauga, Ontario who claims Pottawatomie heritage from Kansas. So depending on the way she's feeling each day she'll play the Native American card or the Canadian card - as to the reason why regular American rules don't apply to her.
You missed my joke - sorry, it was a bad one. The American Indigenous peoples recognized no borders until it became necessary for them to to use them to their advantage. While they may have had what we would call "home territory", the northern tribes migrated freely back and forth. For example, Sitting Bull and his band of Hunkpapa Sious spent some time in what is now Saskatchewan to avoid the US Army, which was bent on revenge for the Little Big Horn. They remained there until 1881.

I have several Assiniboine friends who have relatives on both sides of the border and travel freely between Fort Peck and Fort Belknap reservations in Montana and several reserves in Canada. North of the border they are referred to as Stoney. The same is true of the Cree people of Montana, Alberta, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan.

I'm sure it was true of many of the eastern tribes as well. Many went to Canada because they felt that Canada treated them better than the United States.
BQ78
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Charley Weaver, who most younger folks know as the guy in the lower left square of the Hollywood Squares and whose real name was Cliff Arquette is the patriarch of the Arquette family of thespians. His famous Civil War museum, that closed a few years ago at Gettysburg, started as part of the history themed Freedomland, USA in the Bronx.

The Texan who came up with that park, CV (Cornelius Vanderbilt) Wood was the chief developer of Disneyland for Disney and actually had animatronic characters in this park before Disney. My wife went to Freedomland as a child before it closed after only four years of operation. It just couldn't turn a profit due to huge expense building it. It looked a lot like Frontierland at Disneyland with better history and the park land-wise was bigger than the entire Disneyland. They had the original pirate ride, reenacted the Chicago fire and had a Civil War encampment and battle. It was built on an old land fill like much of the old suburbs of New York are. I would have loved to have gone.
BQ78
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ha ha, they aren't called Native-Americans in Canada, they are known as First Nation People, so when they cross the northern border, their name changes.
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BQ78 said:

Ha ha, they aren't called Native-Americans in Canada, they are known as First Nation People, so when they cross the northern border, their name changes.
No kidding? Really? Tell me something I don't already know
BQ78
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sorry, didn't know Goggle posted as user name JR69.
VanZandt92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The large number of captives taken were not necessarily made slaves in many areas south of Canada. The source I was reading seemed to indicate a higher incidence in Canada. If you believe otherwise then give some sources.

I'd again note that regardless of moniker, native Americans aren't homogeneous as we'd like. My best familiarity is with publications and documents associated with Cherokee, Wampanoag, Mohicans, Tuscarora and Shawnee. Im pretty familiar with Pueblo, Navajo, Zuni and other SW tribes. No idea about Plains Indians.
DartAg1970
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I didn't know that the British fired on and attacked French battleships during WW2. Evidently, after the surrender of the French there were several battleships in the Mediterranean and once the French declined to give the battleships to the British, they decided to sink them rather than risk them falling into the hands of the Nazis.
AtlAg05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think they even killed some French sailors in the process.
AirplaneAg09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AtlAg05 said:

I think they even killed some French sailors in the process.
Sank a few ships(battleship Bretagne) and killed ~1300 French sailors and marines at Mers-el-Kebir.
JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
VanZandt92 said:

The large number of captives taken were not necessarily made slaves in many areas south of Canada. The source I was reading seemed to indicate a higher incidence in Canada. If you believe otherwise then give some sources.

I'd again note that regardless of moniker, native Americans aren't homogeneous as we'd like. My best familiarity is with publications and documents associated with Cherokee, Wampanoag, Mohicans, Tuscarora and Shawnee. Im pretty familiar with Pueblo, Navajo, Zuni and other SW tribes. No idea about Plains Indians.
Perhaps that's true - I don't recall arguing to the contrary. And I certainly agree that the various tribes are not as homogeneous "as we'd like". That's why I used the term Indigenous People. The term "Native American" doesn't fit the tribes of Canada or Mexico or South America. As someone else remarked, in Canada they are called People of the First Nations - a term they themselves chose. Similarities in customs and culture exist more on a regional basis than anything else, thus we tend to refer to them as SW or Pueblo tribes, Plains, NW Coast, etc.


VanZandt92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DartAg1970 said:

I didn't know that the British fired on and attacked French battleships during WW2. Evidently, after the surrender of the French there were several battleships in the Mediterranean and once the French declined to give the battleships to the British, they decided to sink them rather than risk them falling into the hands of the Nazis.
Oh I remember reading about this but damn no idea where I read it. It surprised me also, but man I guess war is war.
BigJim49 AustinNowDallas
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
George the Third and wife had 15 kids !

Benjamin Franklin had a common law marriage !

O'reilly book . "Killing England "
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yeah, I missed your joke, sorry. It was strange to me to find out that there were Indians from the Lower 48 who went to Canada. They didn't cover that in my 8th Grade US History class in Saudi Arabia

Anyway, this friend of mine did make the distinction that she was not a First Nation person. But she definitely played up the Native American card whenever it would benefit her and switch to Canadian when that offered more benefit for the situation.

Don't want to pay certain fees/taxes/etc. - Oh, I'm Native American. Want to bag out the President or the healthcare system - Oh, I'm Canadian. Just kind of rubbed me the wrong way.
VanZandt92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
JR69 said:

VanZandt92 said:

The large number of captives taken were not necessarily made slaves in many areas south of Canada. The source I was reading seemed to indicate a higher incidence in Canada. If you believe otherwise then give some sources.

I'd again note that regardless of moniker, native Americans aren't homogeneous as we'd like. My best familiarity is with publications and documents associated with Cherokee, Wampanoag, Mohicans, Tuscarora and Shawnee. Im pretty familiar with Pueblo, Navajo, Zuni and other SW tribes. No idea about Plains Indians.
Perhaps that's true - I don't recall arguing to the contrary. And I certainly agree that the various tribes are not as homogeneous "as we'd like". That's why I used the term Indigenous People. The term "Native American" doesn't fit the tribes of Canada or Mexico or South America. As someone else remarked, in Canada they are called People of the First Nations - a term they themselves chose. Similarities in customs and culture exist more on a regional basis than anything else, thus we tend to refer to them as SW or Pueblo tribes, Plains, NW Coast, etc.



Who are you telling this to? Do you think we are hayseeds here? I've spent a good deal of my life working in Indian country. I listen to the Canadian Broadcast system so I know what First Nations and indigenous peoples are. Hell I can tell you the major linguistic families of Native Americans.

I've never used the ignore function before, but this will be a good start. Your tone is condescending and you have distracted from the intent of the thread. If you have something to contribute, then do so. If you think you have more knowledge than the rest of us in regard to Indian history or any other history topic, then step up to the plate. You point it out and I'll throw rocks at it.

Looking at my source, which is a book out of the dept of history at Johns Hopkins, now here are the terms:

Natives
Ottawa
Native trappers
Nippising
Iroquois
Algonquin
Native trading partners


Huh. No mention of First Nations in this academic work. Reckon Indians in the 18th century called themselves First Nations? Hey I'll see if I can find some primary sources.



JR69
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
VanZandt92 said:

JR69 said:

VanZandt92 said:

The large number of captives taken were not necessarily made slaves in many areas south of Canada. The source I was reading seemed to indicate a higher incidence in Canada. If you believe otherwise then give some sources.

I'd again note that regardless of moniker, native Americans aren't homogeneous as we'd like. My best familiarity is with publications and documents associated with Cherokee, Wampanoag, Mohicans, Tuscarora and Shawnee. Im pretty familiar with Pueblo, Navajo, Zuni and other SW tribes. No idea about Plains Indians.
Perhaps that's true - I don't recall arguing to the contrary. And I certainly agree that the various tribes are not as homogeneous "as we'd like". That's why I used the term Indigenous People. The term "Native American" doesn't fit the tribes of Canada or Mexico or South America. As someone else remarked, in Canada they are called People of the First Nations - a term they themselves chose. Similarities in customs and culture exist more on a regional basis than anything else, thus we tend to refer to them as SW or Pueblo tribes, Plains, NW Coast, etc.



Who are you telling this to? Do you think we are hayseeds here? I've spent a good deal of my life working in Indian country. I listen to the Canadian Broadcast system so I know what First Nations and indigenous peoples are. Hell I can tell you the major linguistic families of Native Americans.

I've never used the ignore function before, but this will be a good start. Your tone is condescending and you have distracted from the intent of the thread. If you have something to contribute, then do so. If you think you have more knowledge than the rest of us in regard to Indian history or any other history topic, then step up to the plate. You point it out and I'll throw rocks at it.
Well first of all I apologize if I offended you by what I posted. I intended no offense, and I had no intention to come across as superior. Frankly, I see a lot of similarity to your second paragraph and essentially agreement with what you posted.

However, I do, like you, have a fair bit of knowledge of the Native Americans - primarily the tribes of Oklahoma and the Plains tribes, as that is where my interest has been for about 60 years. I won't go into it any further lest I offend you more, other than to say it doesn't all come from books. Peace and Gig 'Em.

Edit to answer your edit:
Quote:

Huh. No mention of First Nations in this academic work. Reckon Indians in the 18th century called themselves First Nations? Hey I'll see if I can find some primary sources.

I reckon that's because it's a 20th century term. But I reckon they didn't call themselves Native Americans in the 18th century either (especially if they were in Canada) because it also is a 20th century term. Primary sources? What is your idea of a primary source?
Guitarsoup
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AirplaneAg09 said:

AtlAg05 said:

I think they even killed some French sailors in the process.
Sank a few ships(battleship Bretagne) and killed ~1300 French sailors and marines at Mers-el-Kebir.


It's difficult to tread water with both hands in the air
Corporal Punishment
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Poland annexed a portion of Czechoslovakia in 1938 the same year Hitler did the same.

Wiki:
Quote:

The Germans were delighted with this outcome. They were happy to give up a provincial rail centre to Poland; it was a small sacrifice indeed. It spread the blame of the partition of Czechoslovakia, made Poland an accomplice in the process and confused the issue as well as political expectations. Poland was accused of being an accomplice of Nazi Germany a charge that Warsaw was hard put to deny.
IDAGG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Something I read just recently. James Wilkinson who at one time was General of the Army in the early 1800s was a traitor who sold secrets to Spain. In addition he tried to pull the Kentucky area into alliance with Spain. He even signed a document declaring his allegiance to Spain.

And maybe worst of all, he tipped off Spain to the Lewis and Clark expedition and suggested they send a small force of Calvary to intercept Lewis and Clark's expedition and dispose of them.

I had no freakin idea we had such a traitor that was at such a high level for so many years.


Quote:

Soon enough, though, Wilkinson had found another, more lucrative form of survival: selling American secrets to the Spanish empire.

"As a spy, his tradecraft was excellent. Wilkinson sent his information in a code just rows of numbers in groups of four," Linklater says. "It was never broken."

Through these coded messages, Wilkinson informed the Spanish of the Lewis and Clark expedition and its secret goal of finding a land route through the Western mountains and to the Pacific Ocean. He suggested that his paymasters send armed patrols to intercept the expedition which the Spanish did.
"Only by the grace of God did they fail to find them," Linklater says. If the Spanish patrols had been luckier or more skillful, we might remember Lewis and Clark if we remembered them at all as two explorers who vanished in the West. And the course of American history might well have been dramatically altered.

Quote:

The real problem for Wilkinson was getting paid for his intelligence, which was the only reason he had become a spy in the first place. Wilkinson was hard pressed to find a way of secretly transporting the loud, unwieldy payments the Spanish sent him thousands of silver dollars at a time.


Quote:

During the winter of 1804/1805, Wilkinson began his fateful relationship with Aaron Burr. His actual involvement in the Burr conspiracy to separate western lands from the Union remains somewhat unclear. It is known that he corresponded frequently with Burr and was privy to the vice president's plans. In 1805 he furnished Burr with a barge, escort, and letter of introduction to the Spanish officials at New Orleans. Later, in his position in St. Louis as governor of the upper Louisiana Territory, Wilkinson was visited by Burr and then kept in regular communication with him.

Quote:

Wilkinson has been one of the most elusive characters in the history of the American west. His subsequent career in the military, despite the fact that he reached the rank of major-generaL was marred by numerous accusations of impropriety. His activities, at various times after 1790, were the subject of more than one formal inquiry, including a court-martial in 1811. On Christmas Day of that year, the court-martial found him not guilty. During the War of 1812 Wilkinson was relieved of his command and ordered to Washington, where he remained a critic of the wartime policies of the Madison administration. He died in 1825 while in pursuit of a Spanish land grant in Texas. Historian of the American west Frederick Jackson Turner called Wilkinson "'the most consummate artist in treason that the nation ever possessed


He apparently was quite the charmer. He charmed Washington, Jefferson and many others. Unbelievable.

http://biography.yourdictionary.com/james-wilkinson

https://www.npr.org/2010/04/28/126363998/the-man-who-double-crossed-the-founders

https://history.hanover.edu/hhr/98/hhr98_1.html
RPag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Very interesting piece of history. Nazi Germany tried for many years to form an alliance with Poland in a war against the Soviet Union. Both the Nazis and Polish authorities wanted their jews gone (of course this did not yet mean genocide). The land was given to Slovakia after their support for the German invasion of Poland. Since these citizens were newly acquired, the Slovak state did not extend citizenship or rights to the jews or their property. Synogogues were almost immediately burned and virtually all the jews in these communities were murdered.
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So I knew that the Germans burned books back in 1933. I also know they stole art work from conquered territory. I didn't know that they burned books and emptied libraries in the occupied territories after 1939.

I find it amazing how hard the Nazis worked at stuff that gave them no tactical advantage.
Rabid Cougar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
IDAGG said:

Something I read just recently. James Wilkinson who at one time was General of the Army in the early 1800s was a traitor who sold secrets to Spain. In addition he tried to pull the Kentucky area into alliance with Spain. He even signed a document declaring his allegiance to Spain.

And maybe worst of all, he tipped off Spain to the Lewis and Clark expedition and suggested they send a small force of Calvary to intercept Lewis and Clark's expedition and dispose of them.

I had no freakin idea we had such a traitor that was at such a high level for so many years.


Quote:

Soon enough, though, Wilkinson had found another, more lucrative form of survival: selling American secrets to the Spanish empire.

"As a spy, his tradecraft was excellent. Wilkinson sent his information in a code just rows of numbers in groups of four," Linklater says. "It was never broken."

Through these coded messages, Wilkinson informed the Spanish of the Lewis and Clark expedition and its secret goal of finding a land route through the Western mountains and to the Pacific Ocean. He suggested that his paymasters send armed patrols to intercept the expedition which the Spanish did.
"Only by the grace of God did they fail to find them," Linklater says. If the Spanish patrols had been luckier or more skillful, we might remember Lewis and Clark if we remembered them at all as two explorers who vanished in the West. And the course of American history might well have been dramatically altered.

Quote:

The real problem for Wilkinson was getting paid for his intelligence, which was the only reason he had become a spy in the first place. Wilkinson was hard pressed to find a way of secretly transporting the loud, unwieldy payments the Spanish sent him thousands of silver dollars at a time.


Quote:

During the winter of 1804/1805, Wilkinson began his fateful relationship with Aaron Burr. His actual involvement in the Burr conspiracy to separate western lands from the Union remains somewhat unclear. It is known that he corresponded frequently with Burr and was privy to the vice president's plans. In 1805 he furnished Burr with a barge, escort, and letter of introduction to the Spanish officials at New Orleans. Later, in his position in St. Louis as governor of the upper Louisiana Territory, Wilkinson was visited by Burr and then kept in regular communication with him.

Quote:

Wilkinson has been one of the most elusive characters in the history of the American west. His subsequent career in the military, despite the fact that he reached the rank of major-generaL was marred by numerous accusations of impropriety. His activities, at various times after 1790, were the subject of more than one formal inquiry, including a court-martial in 1811. On Christmas Day of that year, the court-martial found him not guilty. During the War of 1812 Wilkinson was relieved of his command and ordered to Washington, where he remained a critic of the wartime policies of the Madison administration. He died in 1825 while in pursuit of a Spanish land grant in Texas. Historian of the American west Frederick Jackson Turner called Wilkinson "'the most consummate artist in treason that the nation ever possessed


He apparently was quite the charmer. He charmed Washington, Jefferson and many others. Unbelievable.

http://biography.yourdictionary.com/james-wilkinson

https://www.npr.org/2010/04/28/126363998/the-man-who-double-crossed-the-founders

https://history.hanover.edu/hhr/98/hhr98_1.html
Read up on Phillip Nolan and his trips into Texas in 1800 and 1801 prior to Lewis and Clark. He is also "influenced" by Wilkinson.
RPag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
And not just destroy. The Nazis also collected documents and artifacts that were to be placed in museums to show the history of these vanquished races. Racism is synomous with obsession.
JaneDoe02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Aberfan Disaster

I'd never heard of it until a few weeks ago.

So horrible and so easily prevented.
Cen-Tex
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Learned that one of Amanda Blake's ancestors, Catherine (Kate) Moore Barry was a heroine of the American Revolutionary War. She warned the militia of Sir Banastre Tarleton's approach, giving them time to group and prepare for the Battle of Cowpens in 1781.

Amanda Blake played the role of Miss Kitty Russell, owner of the Longbranch Saloon, on the Gunsmoke tv series from 1955-1974.
Nagler
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

The majority of Confederate soldiers were married and / or had families.

What does this mean? They were more married than the Yankees? or you just thought they were all single dudes?
VanZandt92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nagler said:

Quote:

The majority of Confederate soldiers were married and / or had families.

What does this mean? They were more married than the Yankees? or you just thought they were all single dudes?
I thought many more were single dudes, such as one might see in the rolls of the Continental Line or many later wars. The comparison to Yankees is a valid discussion and yes I have thought some on that, but I don't know how to give a summary of what I read here as it isn't in the forefront of my mind.

I probably should have known this data, as at least two of my forbears had families and both were killed or died of disease in the war, yet they are still my grandfathers, ergo..
Cen-Tex
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Didn't know that Charles Lindbergh was:
1. Time Magazines 1st Man of The Year
2. That he fathered 6 children w/his wife; 2 with his personal secretary; 3 children w/Brigitte Hesshaimer in Germany, as well as 2 children by Brigitte's sister Marietta Hesshaimer...for a total of 13
CanyonAg77
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yeah, Lucky Lindy REALLY loved the Germans

Did you know he flew WWII combat missions, but only against the Japanese
IDAGG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
CanyonAg77 said:

Yeah, Lucky Lindy REALLY loved the Germans

Did you know he flew WWII combat missions, but only against the Japanese
Yeah wasn't he a borderline Nazi sympathizer?
VanZandt92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jaydoug said:

Kennedy knew the Vietnam War was unwinnable but felt he could not get re-elected if it seemed he was soft on communism if he shut down the war
Yeah I keep approaching my knowledge of the Pentagon Papers in light of recent attention and it is so revealing.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.