John Stockton's game winner for game 6 of the WC finals still makes me depressed. I doubt we would have beaten the Bulls but we all wanted Hakeem vs Jordan.
Sea Speed said:schmellba99 said:chlavinka said:
They won the division his first year … but not because of Nolan. He was a very average pitcher as an Astro and never won a big game for them.
Insert laughing emoticon here.
Sure buddy, you do you I guess. Apparently being contraian is your thing sor something.
First ballot entrant in to the hall of average
Scientific said:
John Stockton's game winner for game 6 of the WC finals still makes me depressed. I doubt we would have beaten the Bulls but we all wanted Hakeem vs Jordan.
I'm going off sketchy memory on some pretty obscure and old baseball stats. Sue me. You got the point, and it is still a very valid point. Quit being hard headed for the sake of being hard headed, it's dumb.Farmer1906 said:schmellba99 said:Farmer1906 said:
He also leads all-time in walks given up and hits given up per 9 innings.
0 MVPs
0 Cy Youngs
2 AS as an Astro
58.2 IP (31.1 in HOU) in the postseason or about 14 innings fewer than Lance McCullers.
I know he probably deserved some awards. I know the playoffs were different back then. But my point still stands, there are plenty of glaring flaws on his resume.
For me, Dream is a lock. He won titles. He won MVPs. He now has an award named after him. Altuve is a lock. He won titles. He won an MVP. He's got a boatload of battling titles, ASs, SS, a GG, & now makes the All MLB team. He's got a good shot at becoming the all-time postseason HR king at 5'5". JJ would be my 3rd because of his mix of peak greatness and more longevity than Earl. He also was in Houston longer, played on the team currently in Houston, and took the team to its highest heights thus far.
.....and Babe Ruth had the most srikeouts as a player forever (may still hold it, I dont know). Nolan has those because he played for 20 something years, and played in a much different time than what the game is now. He was also i think the closest to a unanimous first vote to the Hall ever.
He also holds the record for most 1 hitters, 2 hitters and 3 hitters. The closest person to him in strikeouts is 1200 something behind. The closest active player is i believe Verlander, who is 2000 or so behind and near the end of his career.
He was shafted out of the Cy Young in 72 (i think) when he broke the single season strikeout record, had the most wins and second best ERA.
"Deserved some awards" indeed.
At least try to be accurate. Babe Ruth ranks 142nd all time in strikeouts.
I still contend that ball is orbiting the earthHtownAg92 said:Sheeet moments in Tine Sports:Microwave Onions said:
It's fascinating how much of an emotional flashpoint the Nolan departure still is. Should we do the Bills comeback next?
Renfro's no catch
1980 NLCS
Lorenzo Charles dunk
Bills comeback
Oilers leave, Titans make Super Bowl
Kevin Brown
Albert Pujols
WS Sweep
Tony Boselli pick
Hopkins leaves
Watt leaves
Cal McNair inherits team
Nope, it got knocked out of the atmosphere by Yordan's blast this year.schmellba99 said:I still contend that ball is orbiting the earthHtownAg92 said:Sheeet moments in Tine Sports:Microwave Onions said:
It's fascinating how much of an emotional flashpoint the Nolan departure still is. Should we do the Bills comeback next?
Renfro's no catch
1980 NLCS
Lorenzo Charles dunk
Bills comeback
Oilers leave, Titans make Super Bowl
Kevin Brown
Albert Pujols
WS Sweep
Tony Boselli pick
Hopkins leaves
Watt leaves
Cal McNair inherits team
Here is one that fits better and its accurate to satisfy you:Farmer1906 said:schmellba99 said:Farmer1906 said:
He also leads all-time in walks given up and hits given up per 9 innings.
0 MVPs
0 Cy Youngs
2 AS as an Astro
58.2 IP (31.1 in HOU) in the postseason or about 14 innings fewer than Lance McCullers.
I know he probably deserved some awards. I know the playoffs were different back then. But my point still stands, there are plenty of glaring flaws on his resume.
For me, Dream is a lock. He won titles. He won MVPs. He now has an award named after him. Altuve is a lock. He won titles. He won an MVP. He's got a boatload of battling titles, ASs, SS, a GG, & now makes the All MLB team. He's got a good shot at becoming the all-time postseason HR king at 5'5". JJ would be my 3rd because of his mix of peak greatness and more longevity than Earl. He also was in Houston longer, played on the team currently in Houston, and took the team to its highest heights thus far.
.....and Babe Ruth had the most srikeouts as a player forever (may still hold it, I dont know). Nolan has those because he played for 20 something years, and played in a much different time than what the game is now. He was also i think the closest to a unanimous first vote to the Hall ever.
He also holds the record for most 1 hitters, 2 hitters and 3 hitters. The closest person to him in strikeouts is 1200 something behind. The closest active player is i believe Verlander, who is 2000 or so behind and near the end of his career.
He was shafted out of the Cy Young in 72 (i think) when he broke the single season strikeout record, had the most wins and second best ERA.
"Deserved some awards" indeed.
At least try to be accurate. Babe Ruth ranks 142nd all time in strikeouts.
schmellba99 said:Here is one that fits better and its accurate to satisfy you:Farmer1906 said:schmellba99 said:Farmer1906 said:
He also leads all-time in walks given up and hits given up per 9 innings.
0 MVPs
0 Cy Youngs
2 AS as an Astro
58.2 IP (31.1 in HOU) in the postseason or about 14 innings fewer than Lance McCullers.
I know he probably deserved some awards. I know the playoffs were different back then. But my point still stands, there are plenty of glaring flaws on his resume.
For me, Dream is a lock. He won titles. He won MVPs. He now has an award named after him. Altuve is a lock. He won titles. He won an MVP. He's got a boatload of battling titles, ASs, SS, a GG, & now makes the All MLB team. He's got a good shot at becoming the all-time postseason HR king at 5'5". JJ would be my 3rd because of his mix of peak greatness and more longevity than Earl. He also was in Houston longer, played on the team currently in Houston, and took the team to its highest heights thus far.
.....and Babe Ruth had the most srikeouts as a player forever (may still hold it, I dont know). Nolan has those because he played for 20 something years, and played in a much different time than what the game is now. He was also i think the closest to a unanimous first vote to the Hall ever.
He also holds the record for most 1 hitters, 2 hitters and 3 hitters. The closest person to him in strikeouts is 1200 something behind. The closest active player is i believe Verlander, who is 2000 or so behind and near the end of his career.
He was shafted out of the Cy Young in 72 (i think) when he broke the single season strikeout record, had the most wins and second best ERA.
"Deserved some awards" indeed.
At least try to be accurate. Babe Ruth ranks 142nd all time in strikeouts.
Replace "Babe Ruth" with "Cy Young" and replace "strikeouts" with "losses"
Cy Young has the most wins of all time as a pitcher. He also has the most losses of all time as a pitcher. I hope that smooths your ruffled feathers.
schmellba99 said:I'm going off sketchy memory on some pretty obscure and old baseball stats. Sue me. You got the point, and it is still a very valid point. Quit being hard headed for the sake of being hard headed, it's dumb.Farmer1906 said:schmellba99 said:Farmer1906 said:
He also leads all-time in walks given up and hits given up per 9 innings.
0 MVPs
0 Cy Youngs
2 AS as an Astro
58.2 IP (31.1 in HOU) in the postseason or about 14 innings fewer than Lance McCullers.
I know he probably deserved some awards. I know the playoffs were different back then. But my point still stands, there are plenty of glaring flaws on his resume.
For me, Dream is a lock. He won titles. He won MVPs. He now has an award named after him. Altuve is a lock. He won titles. He won an MVP. He's got a boatload of battling titles, ASs, SS, a GG, & now makes the All MLB team. He's got a good shot at becoming the all-time postseason HR king at 5'5". JJ would be my 3rd because of his mix of peak greatness and more longevity than Earl. He also was in Houston longer, played on the team currently in Houston, and took the team to its highest heights thus far.
.....and Babe Ruth had the most srikeouts as a player forever (may still hold it, I dont know). Nolan has those because he played for 20 something years, and played in a much different time than what the game is now. He was also i think the closest to a unanimous first vote to the Hall ever.
He also holds the record for most 1 hitters, 2 hitters and 3 hitters. The closest person to him in strikeouts is 1200 something behind. The closest active player is i believe Verlander, who is 2000 or so behind and near the end of his career.
He was shafted out of the Cy Young in 72 (i think) when he broke the single season strikeout record, had the most wins and second best ERA.
"Deserved some awards" indeed.
At least try to be accurate. Babe Ruth ranks 142nd all time in strikeouts.
LOL look at any baseball site that does historical comparisons. I doubt you can find one that ranks Ryan better than Clemens.txags92 said:If Nolan had pitched for the teams Roger pitched for, he would have had 400+ wins. His opponent batting average was nearly 30 points lower than Clemens, he averaged about 1 strikeout per 9 innings more than Clemens, Clemens never threw a no-hitter, while Ryan threw 7, Ryan also holds the records for most 1-hitters and most 2-hitters. Ryan played 3 more seasons than Clemens but gave up 42 fewer home runs. The Cy Young, like it or not has been given to the best pitcher on the best team for the last 5 decades. Ryan was never close to being on the best team and Clemens played for a perennial playoff team. I bet if you surveyed the hitters who faced both of them, they would tell you almost to a man that they feared facing Ryan more than they feared facing Clemens.bularry said:what "stats" does he not come close to Ryan in? Because I think he's regarded by most as a better pitchertxags92 said:No. He doesn't come close to Ryan in stats and his PED use puts an asterisk by his name in the stat line for me.LPHA said:
So do we have to consider Roger Clemens now?
The first two are good Texas Aggies. I could get behind Guy V in the second tier!BillYeoman said:
Bill Yeoman, Jack Pardee and Guy V Lewis. All transformed their respective sports.
Pardee Time in the Dome!
I didn't say he didn't earn them, I said they don't give the Cy Young to guys who play on crappy teams. So comparing Clemens who played for perennial playoff contenders to Ryan, who didn't on the basis of # of Cy Young's is apples to oranges. Nolan threw two no hitters in a season and set the all time single season strikeout record and nearly had several more no hitters in the same season. And he didn't win the Cy Young because he played for a basement dwelling Angels team that couldn't hit their way out of a paper bag.bularry said:LOL look at any baseball site that does historical comparisons. I doubt you can find one that ranks Ryan better than Clemens.txags92 said:If Nolan had pitched for the teams Roger pitched for, he would have had 400+ wins. His opponent batting average was nearly 30 points lower than Clemens, he averaged about 1 strikeout per 9 innings more than Clemens, Clemens never threw a no-hitter, while Ryan threw 7, Ryan also holds the records for most 1-hitters and most 2-hitters. Ryan played 3 more seasons than Clemens but gave up 42 fewer home runs. The Cy Young, like it or not has been given to the best pitcher on the best team for the last 5 decades. Ryan was never close to being on the best team and Clemens played for a perennial playoff team. I bet if you surveyed the hitters who faced both of them, they would tell you almost to a man that they feared facing Ryan more than they feared facing Clemens.bularry said:what "stats" does he not come close to Ryan in? Because I think he's regarded by most as a better pitchertxags92 said:No. He doesn't come close to Ryan in stats and his PED use puts an asterisk by his name in the stat line for me.LPHA said:
So do we have to consider Roger Clemens now?
and right, he didn't earn those 7 trophies, just handed it to the best pitcher on the best team..... LOLOLOLOLOLOL
did you even read what you typed before you posted?
Nolan is a legend, no doubt, and if he'd pitched his whole career in Houston it would be a no-brainer for Houston Mt Rushmore. But he didn't and to try to say he is one of the top 3 pitchers of all time... I mean, come on, no one thinks that.
I'm old enough to have friends who knew him at Westchester or Spring Woods, whichever high school he ostensibly attended. I have never heard anyone say a good word about him, even from people who had known him since kindergarten. Too stupid to get a scholarship to Texas, even as the best pitcher in the country, went to San Jacinto and was a bit white trash for even Pasadena. Spent a semester in Austin and claims he's a Longhorn. Clemens has been a miserable human since he was born, hasn't changed a bit, and his family is almost as bad. And he HATES A&M, despite the fact that he can't spell.txags92 said:I didn't say he didn't earn them, I said they don't give the Cy Young to guys who play on crappy teams. So comparing Clemens who played for perennial playoff contenders to Ryan, who didn't on the basis of # of Cy Young's is apples to oranges. Nolan threw two no hitters in a season and set the all time single season strikeout record and nearly had several more no hitters in the same season. And he didn't win the Cy Young because he played for a basement dwelling Angels team that couldn't hit their way out of a paper bag.bularry said:LOL look at any baseball site that does historical comparisons. I doubt you can find one that ranks Ryan better than Clemens.txags92 said:If Nolan had pitched for the teams Roger pitched for, he would have had 400+ wins. His opponent batting average was nearly 30 points lower than Clemens, he averaged about 1 strikeout per 9 innings more than Clemens, Clemens never threw a no-hitter, while Ryan threw 7, Ryan also holds the records for most 1-hitters and most 2-hitters. Ryan played 3 more seasons than Clemens but gave up 42 fewer home runs. The Cy Young, like it or not has been given to the best pitcher on the best team for the last 5 decades. Ryan was never close to being on the best team and Clemens played for a perennial playoff team. I bet if you surveyed the hitters who faced both of them, they would tell you almost to a man that they feared facing Ryan more than they feared facing Clemens.bularry said:what "stats" does he not come close to Ryan in? Because I think he's regarded by most as a better pitchertxags92 said:No. He doesn't come close to Ryan in stats and his PED use puts an asterisk by his name in the stat line for me.LPHA said:
So do we have to consider Roger Clemens now?
and right, he didn't earn those 7 trophies, just handed it to the best pitcher on the best team..... LOLOLOLOLOLOL
did you even read what you typed before you posted?
Nolan is a legend, no doubt, and if he'd pitched his whole career in Houston it would be a no-brainer for Houston Mt Rushmore. But he didn't and to try to say he is one of the top 3 pitchers of all time... I mean, come on, no one thinks that.
There is no question that he was far and away the most feared and dominant pitcher in baseball for nearly a decade, but because he wasn't on teams going to the playoffs and wasn't winning 20+ every season because he rarely got more than 2 runs to work with from his team, people think he was a mediocre power pitcher. He probably isn't in the top 3 all time, but if I am putting together a five man rotation from 1970-present players, he is in it. And I would take Nolan in his prime over Clemens if for no other reason because of the PED issues with Clemens.
He and his D-Bag brother jumped a cop at Bayou Mama's back in the day.Bibendum 86 said:I'm old enough to have friends who knew him at Westchester or Spring Woods, whichever high school he ostensibly attended. I have never heard anyone say a good word about him, even from people who had known him since kindergarten. Too stupid to get a scholarship to Texas, even as the best pitcher in the country, went to San Jacinto and was a bit white trash for even Pasadena. Spent a semester in Austin and claims he's a Longhorn. Clemens has been a miserable human since he was born, hasn't changed a bit, and his family is almost as bad. And he HATES A&M, despite the fact that he can't spell.txags92 said:I didn't say he didn't earn them, I said they don't give the Cy Young to guys who play on crappy teams. So comparing Clemens who played for perennial playoff contenders to Ryan, who didn't on the basis of # of Cy Young's is apples to oranges. Nolan threw two no hitters in a season and set the all time single season strikeout record and nearly had several more no hitters in the same season. And he didn't win the Cy Young because he played for a basement dwelling Angels team that couldn't hit their way out of a paper bag.bularry said:LOL look at any baseball site that does historical comparisons. I doubt you can find one that ranks Ryan better than Clemens.txags92 said:If Nolan had pitched for the teams Roger pitched for, he would have had 400+ wins. His opponent batting average was nearly 30 points lower than Clemens, he averaged about 1 strikeout per 9 innings more than Clemens, Clemens never threw a no-hitter, while Ryan threw 7, Ryan also holds the records for most 1-hitters and most 2-hitters. Ryan played 3 more seasons than Clemens but gave up 42 fewer home runs. The Cy Young, like it or not has been given to the best pitcher on the best team for the last 5 decades. Ryan was never close to being on the best team and Clemens played for a perennial playoff team. I bet if you surveyed the hitters who faced both of them, they would tell you almost to a man that they feared facing Ryan more than they feared facing Clemens.bularry said:what "stats" does he not come close to Ryan in? Because I think he's regarded by most as a better pitchertxags92 said:No. He doesn't come close to Ryan in stats and his PED use puts an asterisk by his name in the stat line for me.LPHA said:
So do we have to consider Roger Clemens now?
and right, he didn't earn those 7 trophies, just handed it to the best pitcher on the best team..... LOLOLOLOLOLOL
did you even read what you typed before you posted?
Nolan is a legend, no doubt, and if he'd pitched his whole career in Houston it would be a no-brainer for Houston Mt Rushmore. But he didn't and to try to say he is one of the top 3 pitchers of all time... I mean, come on, no one thinks that.
There is no question that he was far and away the most feared and dominant pitcher in baseball for nearly a decade, but because he wasn't on teams going to the playoffs and wasn't winning 20+ every season because he rarely got more than 2 runs to work with from his team, people think he was a mediocre power pitcher. He probably isn't in the top 3 all time, but if I am putting together a five man rotation from 1970-present players, he is in it. And I would take Nolan in his prime over Clemens if for no other reason because of the PED issues with Clemens.
Bibendum 86 said:I'm old enough to have friends who knew him at Westchester or Spring Woods, whichever high school he ostensibly attended. I have never heard anyone say a good word about him, even from people who had known him since kindergarten. Too stupid to get a scholarship to Texas, even as the best pitcher in the country, went to San Jacinto and was a bit white trash for even Pasadena. Spent a semester in Austin and claims he's a Longhorn. Clemens has been a miserable human since he was born, hasn't changed a bit, and his family is almost as bad. And he HATES A&M, despite the fact that he can't spell.txags92 said:I didn't say he didn't earn them, I said they don't give the Cy Young to guys who play on crappy teams. So comparing Clemens who played for perennial playoff contenders to Ryan, who didn't on the basis of # of Cy Young's is apples to oranges. Nolan threw two no hitters in a season and set the all time single season strikeout record and nearly had several more no hitters in the same season. And he didn't win the Cy Young because he played for a basement dwelling Angels team that couldn't hit their way out of a paper bag.bularry said:LOL look at any baseball site that does historical comparisons. I doubt you can find one that ranks Ryan better than Clemens.txags92 said:If Nolan had pitched for the teams Roger pitched for, he would have had 400+ wins. His opponent batting average was nearly 30 points lower than Clemens, he averaged about 1 strikeout per 9 innings more than Clemens, Clemens never threw a no-hitter, while Ryan threw 7, Ryan also holds the records for most 1-hitters and most 2-hitters. Ryan played 3 more seasons than Clemens but gave up 42 fewer home runs. The Cy Young, like it or not has been given to the best pitcher on the best team for the last 5 decades. Ryan was never close to being on the best team and Clemens played for a perennial playoff team. I bet if you surveyed the hitters who faced both of them, they would tell you almost to a man that they feared facing Ryan more than they feared facing Clemens.bularry said:what "stats" does he not come close to Ryan in? Because I think he's regarded by most as a better pitchertxags92 said:No. He doesn't come close to Ryan in stats and his PED use puts an asterisk by his name in the stat line for me.LPHA said:
So do we have to consider Roger Clemens now?
and right, he didn't earn those 7 trophies, just handed it to the best pitcher on the best team..... LOLOLOLOLOLOL
did you even read what you typed before you posted?
Nolan is a legend, no doubt, and if he'd pitched his whole career in Houston it would be a no-brainer for Houston Mt Rushmore. But he didn't and to try to say he is one of the top 3 pitchers of all time... I mean, come on, no one thinks that.
There is no question that he was far and away the most feared and dominant pitcher in baseball for nearly a decade, but because he wasn't on teams going to the playoffs and wasn't winning 20+ every season because he rarely got more than 2 runs to work with from his team, people think he was a mediocre power pitcher. He probably isn't in the top 3 all time, but if I am putting together a five man rotation from 1970-present players, he is in it. And I would take Nolan in his prime over Clemens if for no other reason because of the PED issues with Clemens.
Diggity said:
on the other hand, he was known to be a lousy tipper when he played at Falcon Point.
bularry said:LOL look at any baseball site that does historical comparisons. I doubt you can find one that ranks Ryan better than Clemens.txags92 said:If Nolan had pitched for the teams Roger pitched for, he would have had 400+ wins. His opponent batting average was nearly 30 points lower than Clemens, he averaged about 1 strikeout per 9 innings more than Clemens, Clemens never threw a no-hitter, while Ryan threw 7, Ryan also holds the records for most 1-hitters and most 2-hitters. Ryan played 3 more seasons than Clemens but gave up 42 fewer home runs. The Cy Young, like it or not has been given to the best pitcher on the best team for the last 5 decades. Ryan was never close to being on the best team and Clemens played for a perennial playoff team. I bet if you surveyed the hitters who faced both of them, they would tell you almost to a man that they feared facing Ryan more than they feared facing Clemens.bularry said:what "stats" does he not come close to Ryan in? Because I think he's regarded by most as a better pitchertxags92 said:No. He doesn't come close to Ryan in stats and his PED use puts an asterisk by his name in the stat line for me.LPHA said:
So do we have to consider Roger Clemens now?
and right, he didn't earn those 7 trophies, just handed it to the best pitcher on the best team..... LOLOLOLOLOLOL
did you even read what you typed before you posted?
Nolan is a legend, no doubt, and if he'd pitched his whole career in Houston it would be a no-brainer for Houston Mt Rushmore. But he didn't and to try to say he is one of the top 3 pitchers of all time... I mean, come on, no one thinks that.
I can't believe that suggestion was taken down. I bet by now it would have a stiff lead over all the competition.jetch17 said:
JAW still in the lead with 28 blue stars
It was something like that. He also has "86 Cy & MVP" etched on the bumper.Chewy said:
Was his car black and had "Super K" or something on the license plates?
I went to a card show in the late 80s at the Marriott by Hobby he was signing at. When we left there was a black Porsche 928 with "Super K" or something like that on the plates parked right in front on the curb. I assumed it was his.
Funny he thought his car should get special treatment but not surprising based on stories.
Chewy said:
Just remembered some recent Clemens nonsense.
He threw out the first pitch for Game 2 of the WS. Seemed like an odd choice as he hasn't been around much and I feel most Astros fans are indifferent to him.
He goes out to the mound with a black glove. It struck me as odd he went out there with a glove but he's Roger Clemens.
He throws it to LMJ and they meet up for a picture. LMJ is walking off and Clemens grabs him. Clemens is making him take the glove. LMJ seemed uncertain about it but Clemens is acting like it was a big gesture and he needed to take it.
LMJ later posted a pic and it had Clemens name and all his major accomplishments on it.
Roger always about Roger.