Outdoors
Sponsored by

Metal Vs. Masonry Grills/Smokers

18,897 Views | 13 Replies | Last: 9 yr ago by HarleySpoon
MorgansPoint
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Anyone have experience with a smoker made from stone? Recently expanded my back yard and will be building a deck and putting in a pool and garden. My old grill is getting long in the tooth, and I'm looking for a smoker.

Found some builds for permanent (immobile) smokers made from stone, and I figure it'll outlive me if made correctly. Price wise, it'd be about the same as a medium level metal smoker.

Just asking if anyone has used one made from stone and would be able to give a review on it. Any advice is helpful. Thanks!
EFE
How long do you want to ignore this user?
if I was building a pit for smoking and it was going to be on my permanent homestead, I'd build it out of stone/brick.
maverick2076
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Not sure how much money you are looking to spend, but I would go a little different direction and buy two different sized Kamado Joe/BGEs and put them in a nice table. With an XL and a Mini, you'd be able to cook dang near anything, from smoking a couple briskest/butts on the XL to doing a couple of steaks after work on the mini.
Post removed:
by user
MorgansPoint
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This is what I'm shooting for

http://www.instructables.com/id/All-in-One-Outdoor-Oven-Stove-Grill-and-Smoker/?ALLSTEPS

Plan on building it into my deck.
JYDog90
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ok, I read that whole thing. Don't you end up grilling your briskets? How do you get them away from the fire? It looks like it's less than 8" above the coals.
California Ag 90
How long do you want to ignore this user?
going to build a masonry smoker with stone facade as the fall project once the temperatures drop later in the year.

not clear if you are looking for a grilling and smoking capability, i'm simply going to build a legit smoking pit with offset firebrick box and enough capacity for 6 shoulders or briskets. have a decent grill already and a metal smoker (new braunfels) that I'm ready to replace, so going to build something.

was a bit disappointed in the availability of online designs when I posted about this here earlier in the spring, but have come up with a design based on recommended dimensions.

http://www.smokerbuilder.com/pitcalc/

will post pictures once the build starts and when its finished.

BringJackieBack89
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'll respond to this with a few emails, even try and post some pictures. I am copying this text description from a post of mine on the amazing ribs website in the Pit forum. The thread title is "Build Your Own (BYO) Brick or Cement Fire Pit". There are several good posts in there if you are interested. In my post, I have also put in several progress photos from the build.

From the original post on amazing ribs:

The set up is all cinder block and fire brick. The stone was something to appease the homeowners assoc. Did dress it up nicely but cost a fortune!

This has an indirect smoker chamber with 3 levels and 20 sq ft of cooking surface; a cold smoker with 2 levels, a sausage hanger and 12.44 sq ft of cooking surface; and a 2 ft x 4 ft charcoal bed direct grill. On and off weekends, it took several months to complete (still have the top of the cold smoker to tile). There have been many lessons learned which I will be happy to share.

It is more of a vertical smoker and I call it an indirect smoker because I have a couple of pieces of concrete which I place between the firebox and meat, sized to allow more or less heat, but also to deflect some heat into the area of the cold smoker.

The whole thing sits on a 4" concerete, reinforced slab. My firebox is lined (bottom) with firebrick, as is the first 2 ft from the firebox to cold smoker chamber. LL#1 - use more firebrick to line the sides of the firebox. LL#2 - shorter distance between firebox and cold smoker - after the firebrick, there is another 4 ft to the cold smoker chamber.

I ordered my firebox doors (1 in front, 1 in back) online, same with the 2 smoking chamber doors. LL#3 - would like more of an offset set up instead of the vertical and position such that I can take advantage of the more often southeasterly winds (varies by location, of course). I placed vent pipes out the back and at the top of both chambers. Provides good airflow but could be a little better. LL#5 - larger vent pipes...currently 3", should have gone about 5".

The direct grill is lined with firebrick and near perfect. LL#4 - figure a way to get a little airflow when the stainless top is on. One half has the bottom 8" below the grating surface and the other side is 14" below the grate.

Now, all said, I love the set up. I maintain a very nice fire by opening one of the doors. Depending on which block I place in the smoker, I maintain a 225F - 250F in the smoke chamber, or 250F to 275F in the chamber. I can, and have, maintained a 350F fire by removing the block, but typically don't try.

I'll try in a different post to insert some pictures.
BringJackieBack89
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Trying to post some pictures...sorry about the size!

This one shows the main smoking chamber and the direct grill (with 2 ea 2' x 2' stainless gratings).



Here is an overview. You can see the cold smoker to the far left. Note the top is still not quite finished. Just ended up putting more cement board there.



I typically start my fire around midnight and put meats on around 0200. Fire getting going pretty good here - and I always just leave the windward side cleanout door open to get good air flow.



And here is a recent photo, after I put in a stone patio. Sure helps after it rains!


Dirty-8-thirty Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
Trying to post some pictures...sorry about the size!

This one shows the main smoking chamber and the direct grill (with 2 ea 2' x 2' stainless gratings).



Here is an overview. You can see the cold smoker to the far left. Note the top is still not quite finished. Just ended up putting more cement board there.



I typically start my fire around midnight and put meats on around 0200. Fire getting going pretty good here - and I always just leave the windward side cleanout door open to get good air flow.



And here is a recent photo, after I put in a stone patio. Sure helps after it rains!





This is awesome work. I want something like this in my back yard one day.
Aggielandma12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Where are the dampers located?
California Ag 90
How long do you want to ignore this user?
quote:
Trying to post some pictures...sorry about the size!

This one shows the main smoking chamber and the direct grill (with 2 ea 2' x 2' stainless gratings).



Here is an overview. You can see the cold smoker to the far left. Note the top is still not quite finished. Just ended up putting more cement board there.



I typically start my fire around midnight and put meats on around 0200. Fire getting going pretty good here - and I always just leave the windward side cleanout door open to get good air flow.



And here is a recent photo, after I put in a stone patio. Sure helps after it rains!



that is awesome!
MROD92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HarleySpoon
How long do you want to ignore this user?

HarleySpoon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sorry guys....I've tried three times to fix that above.....I cannot seem to get it to erase. Moderator please help????
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.