oh no said:

---

is Najee Harris for Ken Walker straight up a fair deal?

---

I dont know why Ken Walker person would make this trade. Short term schedule suggests you can get Najee for way less in 2 weeks. Walker is explosive and plays on a deep ball throwing offense (so deep safeties).

oh no said:

---

is Freiermuth + JuJu for Ertz fair?

---

Yes

W said:

---

so I sold high on Kelce

he got my team is this league to 2-3.

I start with Saquon this week

---

You should try to trade fournette for kelce to get him back!

texagbeliever said:

---

oh no said:

---

is Najee Harris for Ken Walker straight up a fair deal?

---

I dont know why Ken Walker person would make this trade. Short term schedule suggests you can get Najee for way less in 2 weeks. Walker is explosive and plays on a deep ball throwing offense (so deep safeties).

---

true... what if i offered the Walker owner (who also owns Swift and Montgomery and has Cordarrelle in his IR spot) Najee + Jamaal or Khalil so they have one of their starters' handcuff?

W said:

---

so I sold high on Kelce

he got my team is this league to 2-3.

I start with Saquon this week

---

I wouldn't trade Kelce for anyone.

oh no said:

---

texagbeliever said:

---

oh no said:

---

is Najee Harris for Ken Walker straight up a fair deal?

---

I dont know why Ken Walker person would make this trade. Short term schedule suggests you can get Najee for way less in 2 weeks. Walker is explosive and plays on a deep ball throwing offense (so deep safeties).

---

true... what if i offered the Walker owner (who also owns Swift and Montgomery and has Cordarrelle in his IR spot) Najee + Jamaal or Khalil so they have one of their starters' handcuff?

---

Najee and Jamaal might be more interesting. I like Khalil's chances of being more of a lead back than jamaals.

The Porkchop Express said:

---

W said:

---

so I sold high on Kelce

he got my team is this league to 2-3.

I start with Saquon this week

---

I wouldn't trade Kelce for anyone.

---

Agreed. Kelce is going to be a league winner for a lot of people.

Chipotlemonger said:

---

EliteZags said:

---

Samuel's best of 6 seasons was marginally more productive than Pitts' 1st and only season(in which he avoided the endzone all year)
even if assume equal production ROS Pitts positional value demands a much higher trade valuation

good for you but garbage trade that wouldn't be considered in any marginally competitive league


Deebo Samuel would be a more fair trade, and Deebo for Curtis would be vetoed anywhere

---

Care to revisit this?

---

Still a garbage trade today

Curtis Samuel is just a waiver add

EliteZags said:

---

Chipotlemonger said:

---

EliteZags said:

---

Samuel's best of 6 seasons was marginally more productive than Pitts' 1st and only season(in which he avoided the endzone all year)
even if assume equal production ROS Pitts positional value demands a much higher trade valuation

good for you but garbage trade that wouldn't be considered in any marginally competitive league


Deebo Samuel would be a more fair trade, and Deebo for Curtis would be vetoed anywhere

---

Care to revisit this?

---

Still a garbage trade today

Curtis Samuel is just a waiver add

---

Kyle Pitts:
18 targets
22 targets
10 receptions
150 receiving yards
0 touchdowns
20 fantasy points in .5 PPR

Curtis Samuel:
45 targets
32 receptions
281 receiving yards
8 carries
51 rushing yards
2 touchdowns
59.2 fantasy points in .5 PPR

Ken Walker is on waivers in a lot of leagues right now...

CEH for Jalen Waddle straight up. .5 PPR

My RBS are Saquon, Michael Carter, Antonio Gibson and Eli Mitchell
Wrs: AJ brown, Evans, chase, waddle, Curtis Samuel, and olave

I might do that. Your WR lineup is stacked and that may be a good to round out the RB room you have.

You have some great trade bait at WR and need a RB, but can you do better than CEH for Waddle?

oh no said:

---

You have some great trade bait at WR and need a RB, but can you do better than CEH for Waddle?

---

Id avoid CEH. Olave/ Samuel for Jeff Wilson would help you weather storm till Mitchell returns. You might ask the Ken Walker owner what WR it would take to get him (i wouldn't give up Chase nor Evans for him but maybe Brown and certainly Waddle).
Pollard should be obtainable pretty easy for olave or Samuel in a pinch. Though that's a high price. Other option would be a trade for swift. May take one of your top 3 WRs. Perhaps even Brown + Olave.
If I had gibson, I'd look to drop him to add Eno/Warren/McKinnon type back.

give Deebo and AGibson for Tyreek

Gibson pretty irrelevant in this close to dropping anyways, think Hill has a slightly higher ceiling(and lower floor w/ qb uncertainty) otherwise comparable value with Deebo, and he's a Niners homer

have Henry/Kamara/Dobbins/Walker/Conner/Gibson/Mattison
Deebo/DK/MThomas/Devonta/Fuller/JamesonW(IR). Josh Allen, Goedart
non PPR start 2rb/3wr/1Flx


just trying to keep pace with the other league juggernaut who just acquired JT and will be starting
Lamar, JT, Dalvin, Diggs, MWilliams, London, Hopkins, Andrews


was also considering rolling the dice with trying to get Pitts for Goedart and (maybe)Conner
think Goedart and Pitts still both endup top 5 but Pitts has better shot to challenge for top 3 ros

sizeable payout for scoring champ and think I have matchup buffer to take on some risk

I think Hill for Deebo is a great deal. Agree Gibson is waiver wire material. Id honestly try to keep working it and maybe look at Hill + Dobbins/Conner for Chase (underperformed so far)

As an aside JT worries me with an ankle injury after bad weeks in a bad offense.

I am being offered Kyle Pitts for Allen Lazard

Here's my current TE situation…….Dalton Schultz. Yep it's that bad. I just used a badly needed bench spot to pick up Dissly

My current WRs…….Mike Evans, Keenan Allen if he ever plays again, Lazard, George Pickens, Isaiah McKenzie and Josh Reynolds.

Would y'all do it?

Pitts is frustrating, but yes. I don't think you'll miss Lazard too much as a flex or WR2 bye week option because you'll still have Pickens.

The more I think about it the less excited I am. I don't think it's a bad trade, I'm just not real excited about sacrificing the depth at WR, and potential of Lazard himself, hoping that Pitts can live up to the hype someday. Which by the way, is difficult to do on a bad team with a bad QB.

Schultz might come back to life when Dak get back, and Dissly, while TD dependent, has actually been scoring TDs and has a higher week to week ceiling than Pitts right now with the same floor. Plays on a better offense with a better QB (can't believe I just said that about Geno).

I get the trade, probably a fair one at this point, just not one I'd do right now.

oh no said:

---

Pitts is frustrating, but yes. I don't think you'll miss Lazard too much as a flex or WR2 bye week option because you'll still have Pickens.

---

I like Pickens as well. My only concern is who knows when Allen is actually healthy and back, Mike tends to get nicked up too. I like Lazards floor the last three weeks and the potential for improvement over the year.

Daddy-O5 said:

---

oh no said:

---

Pitts is frustrating, but yes. I don't think you'll miss Lazard too much as a flex or WR2 bye week option because you'll still have Pickens.

---

I like Pickens as well. My only concern is who knows when Allen is actually healthy and back, Mike tends to get nicked up too. I like Lazards floor the last three weeks and the potential for improvement over the year.

---

That's the thing. I think Josh will crash and burn once Amon Ra is back 100%, not to mention Chark and they're about to get Jameson Williams back as well. Josh may well be back to 2 catches a week. Tough to give up on Lazard knowing that. May just hang on and take my lumps until Dak comes back. Bc Schultz is obviously 100% Dak dependent

10-team, .5 PPR, record is 4-2 after this week, start 1QB/2RB/2WR/1TE/1FLEX
QB: Tom Brady
RBs: Saquon Barkley, Nick Chubb, D'Andre Swift (IR), Kareem Hunt, Brian Robinson, Eno Benjamin, Kyren Williams (IR)
WRs: Justin Jefferson, Mike Evans, Christian Kirk, Brandon Aiyuk, Juju Smith-Schuster, Alec Pierce, Jameson Williams (IR)
TEs: David Njoku and Tyler Higbee

I am thinking about offering Nick Chubb and Christian Kirk for Breece Hall and CeeDee Lamb. Any thoughts? I love Hall's playoff schedule, and I think things get harder for Nick Chubb from here on out with their schedule toughening up after an incredibly easy first five weeks.

I don't know why the Hall/Lamb guy would want that trade. Hall has been on a 3 week tear. Lamb is getting Dak back. Chubb just had a bad week and Kirk has proven over the last 3 weeks he is not a WR1 in terms of target dominance. If he goes for it great news for you.

If it were me I'd think you'd have to do Chubb for Hall straight up. Maybe even Chubb + Juju (5 targets has me not wanting him still).

I'm not much of a trader, but what do you think about this?

I have Hurts, Tyler Bass , J Jefferson, Eagles DEF on bye and Matt Ryan is my backup QB. I don't want to drop Bass and pick up a rando. Thinking if I do a 2 for 3 trade I can create space and get a better backup QB for this week. I also have Diontae Johnson, Drake London and Allen Lazard on my bench. Mostert is my other back up RB outisde Dillon.

I get:
Tom Brady
Brian Robinson

He gets:
Matt Ryan
AJ Dillon
Robert Woods

Both Brady and Robinson are bench guys for him.

Why do you think Brady @ Carolina is better than Matt Ryan @ Tenn? Ryan threw for 350 yards 2 TD & 1 Int 3 weeks ago against Tenn.

E said:

---

I'm not much of a trader, but what do you think about this?

I have Hurts, Tyler Bass , J Jefferson, Eagles DEF on bye and Matt Ryan is my backup QB. I don't want to drop Bass and pick up a rando. Thinking if I do a 2 for 3 trade I can create space and get a better backup QB for this week. I also have Diontae Johnson, Drake London and Allen Lazard on my bench. Mostert is my other back up RB outisde Dillon.

I get:
Tom Brady
Brian Robinson

He gets:
Matt Ryan
AJ Dillon
Robert Woods

Both Brady and Robinson are bench guys for him.

---

What about this deal do you think would interest him?
Offering 3 worthless players for 2 slightly less worthless players?
Do your league reward just having more bodies on the roster or something?


If all those guys were on waiver wire the only one I'd even consider picking up to take up space on my bench would be Robinson

EliteZags said:

---

E said:

---

I'm not much of a trader, but what do you think about this?

I have Hurts, Tyler Bass , J Jefferson, Eagles DEF on bye and Matt Ryan is my backup QB. I don't want to drop Bass and pick up a rando. Thinking if I do a 2 for 3 trade I can create space and get a better backup QB for this week. I also have Diontae Johnson, Drake London and Allen Lazard on my bench. Mostert is my other back up RB outisde Dillon.

I get:
Tom Brady
Brian Robinson

He gets:
Matt Ryan
AJ Dillon
Robert Woods

Both Brady and Robinson are bench guys for him.

---

What about this deal do you think would interest him?
Offering 3 worthless players for 2 slightly less worthless players?
Do your league reward just having more bodies on the roster or something?

---

Come on FantasyBro all-star! Your snide remark has less sting when you can't conjugate your verbs correctly!

Dillion & Robinson are rostered at 100% of decently played 12 team leagues.

10 team league. PPR. My 1-5 last place team (that badly needs RB production the most) was just offered a trade from a 3-3 sixth place team who needs WR help as it seems that he just lost Hollywood for ~6 weeks (possibly the season?). Could be a win-win for us both with a counter-offer here, but I'm not sure if the current proposal helps me much at all. I'm thinking reject or counter.

Current proposal:
GET: Gabe Davis and Kareem Hunt
GIVE: Deebo Samuel

My squad:

QB: Geno (might swap & get Tua back?)
WR: Deebo, ARSB, Olave, London, Jakobi Meyers, Bateman (in IR spot)
RB: Dalvin, Najee, Damien Harris, Brian Robinson, Jamaal Williams
TE: Taysom Hill, Pat Freiermuth
K: Maher
D: MIN

right now I'm over-rostered. I need to drop someone to take Bateman out of the IR spot he's not currently eligible for in order to swap a defense for this week (MIN on bye) and then I'd need to drop a second player to take in two if I accept this trade proposal.

My top 2 picks, Dalvin and Najee, are the main reasons I'm in last place. Kareem Hunt doesn't begin to solve that for me. Kareem is still ranked below Najee in most ROS rankings I see and I don't see Hunt as a regular starter unless Chubb gets hurt. This week, I'm playing the 6-0 first place team and have Dalvin on bye - Will have to start Najee and Brian Robinson most likely. Oof. I still don't think Kareem Hunt is better than the rb1 volume Robinson should get this week or for ROS. ...and while Gabe Davis may blow up with some deep balls in that BUF offense and might be a better weekly flex start than Olave, he'd be my WR2 if I give up Deebo here & i'd still be starting Olave at flex. I don't think I can afford to lose deebo's 7-10 targets plus some handoffs for Gabe's 4-6 targets / game.

His roster:

Q: Kyler, Stafford
W: Tyreek, Hollywood, Diontae Johnson, Gabe Davis
R: Ekeler, Kamara, Hunt, Gibson
T: Hockenson, Hurst
K: Koo
D: LAR, JAX

What's a fair win-win to counter with if he really wants Deebo? He probably wouldn't give up Kamara for anything and all he has that would help me is Kamara or Ekeler.

give: Deebo, Najee
get: Kamara

?

I think your counter makes sense. I don't love it because Kamara is a no TD player and I feel like Pittsburgh can turn it around and Najee is a TD player. You are 1-5 so maybe you can't wait for Najee to turn it around.

Could you maybe target a Etienne for Olave or London if he is a teams RB3/4? Toss in Jamaal in the trade if they want a RB.

Also I'd drop Freiermuth if you could pick up a Kenyon Drake/Mckinnion/Gus Edwards type of player.

Etienne owner is pretty RB poor, especially with Conner out right now, he needs Etienne.

been looking around for similar. The Mostert owner needs him right now.

I proposed Drake London for Devin Singletary. Essentially my 4th WR and I need a RB and his 4th RB and he could use the WR. BUF is on bye this week so i won't even be able to use Singletary, but maybe that will help him with his decision.

I like that trade. Blind to the teams, id say thats a slight over pay, but knowing rosters a value add move for your team. Najee and B Robinson could easily give you 70 yards and a TD for both so its not bad for this week.

You'd also be more likely to flip Singletary for Etienne next week...

Or maybe do Najee for Etienne straight up? I don't love the idea but feel like you might need a hail marry type play. Maybe Najee + Olave for Etienne and a slightly better WR than Olave?

10 team, 1 PPR. 2 QB/2 RB/3 WR/1 FLX/1 D/ST

I'm currently in first place and received a trade request from 2nd place guy:

I lose: Tyreek Hill
I receive: Aman-Ra and James Robinson

Yay or nay?

Now I just got offered Breece Hall for Devonta Smith.

Thoughts?

Allen Gamble said:

---

Now I just got offered Breece Hall for Devonta Smith.

Thoughts?

---

Yes assuming you get hall. The other no.