Data Centers…

9,074 Views | 188 Replies | Last: 11 days ago by GaryClare
Drip99
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ag87H2O said:

Drip99 said:

Why build data centers in the suburbs of a major city when u can build them in the vast wastelands of west Texas or any of the millions of acres of middle of nowhere land across the country? That's why this stuff started…people having a data center built next to an existing neighborhood. Regardless of how beautiful trump says they are, there is nobody that wants one right next to their hood.

There are multiple data centers all around Houston, and you wouldn't even know because they look just like any other large office warehouse type complex, other than the big bank of backup generators behind the building.

Data centers are good and needed in this day and age. They are good for the economy. People, especially the Karens and the useful idiots on the left, like to bandwagon gripe about things they have no knowledge of because it makes them feel morally superior.


Need or economical reasons were not brought up here. There is plenty of footage out there of them close to neighborhoods and unlike ur avg office building, they produce noise. Point was not good or bad, point was build them where they bother nobody and nobody would care. People only care when it impacts their life. If it's in an industrial park in Houston that's great but I have seen footage of Memphis and dc and they were dropped next to peoples homes and directly impacted their life and home value. That's the issue that started all the hate. Was not an anti data center post…just a placement issue. They are building them outside of abilene and Amarillo which is a good place.
mm98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
CascadiaAg said:

AxelFoley85 said:

I agree. I'm sure there are people in those towns who could use those jobs.


The construction employment boost is only for a short period of time. And actual people who staff the data centers is much less than what you apparently think it is. We're not talking thousands of jobs here. We're talking a few hundred at best.

And they're not going to be hiring from the locals to staff the data center in any of the significant positions.


This is true. It's not like a refinery or chemical plant

Once the job is done they have relatively low staff compared to the size and there is very little equipment MRO opportunity…so it's not like secondary businesses will pop up all over the place to support them. Maybe some electrical and instrumentation businesses could survive nearby
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I am nearly complete with the solution to the data center thing. My new design will require no electrical usage; power will be supplied by small turbines connected to bicycles and the bicycles powered by the pedaling of the 40 something percent of people who pay no income tax. No water will be used to cool them, these folks that don't pay tax will be waving half sheets of plywood to create breezes to help cool things down. Elon better watch out; I am going to get rich.
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CascadiaAg said:

AxelFoley85 said:

I agree. I'm sure there are people in those towns who could use those jobs.


The construction employment boost is only for a short period of time. And actual people who staff the data centers is much less than what you apparently think it is. We're not talking thousands of jobs here. We're talking a few hundred at best.

And they're not going to be hiring from the locals to staff the data center in any of the significant positions.

Hundred? I would say 20 tops, and this a massive one.
Featured Video Previews
jagged
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
3rd Coast said:

Data center is a data center bud
not remotely accurate.

And yes dcs CAN be water efficient if they have closed loop chip level cooling and dry cooling for the heat rejection. But many use some form of evaporative cooling.

Public definitely needs some education on this b/c each side has an angle or agenda to push. This thread further emphasizes that.
MelvinUdall
How long do you want to ignore this user?
jagged said:

3rd Coast said:

Data center is a data center bud
not remotely accurate.

And yes dcs CAN be water efficient if they have closed loop chip level cooling and dry cooling for the heat rejection. But many use some form of evaporative cooling.

Public definitely needs some education on this b/c each side has an angle or agenda to push. This thread further emphasizes that.


I agree, but I certainly wouldn't get in the way if I were a politician to stop development…I would however make sure that the economic impact to the community would be none, ie depetion of water resources or increase in energy costs. I am all in for Data Centers and the AI that is coming with it all.
SunrayAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TarponChaser said:

Anti-data center sentiment is mostly parroting ChiCom and Russian psy-ops/propaganda.


Moronic statements like this helped the dimtards take power.

All over Texas, there have been crowded commissioners court meetings and crowded public forums in over 200 counties filled with rural conservatives angrily fighting back against data centers.

People who have seen the power grid crash because of a cold front, and are concerned about doubling or tripling demand on it.

People who are concerned about their local water resources.

People who don't want the noise pollution, light pollution, and destruction of agricultural land and wildlife habitat.

And the republican response was insulting, condescending, and dismissive. Even Trump opened his yap and declared that the only people opposed to data centers are people too dumb and backwards to know any better.

And it appears that message didn't resonate.
RED AG 98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Data centers are here to stay, whether you want them or not. The only serious questions are:
where they will be built?
where will the chips they require be built?

If not in the US, you can guar-an-damn-tee it will be China (including Taiwan, because all the RFIs already consider them as Chinese...)

We need US capacity such as Terafab and all the data centers we can build.

This isn't just for stupid memes. 25 yr semi guy here at a Fortune 100 company -- we've just completed our first full design front to back with full AI workflow -- design, verification, layout, tapeout, validation -- for an extremely complex Arm SoC.

If you don't think this is changing nearly every facet of your life, you are sorely mistaken. We have to be leaders here.
jagged
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Totally agree. Didn't like that that was Hinojosa's position. Didn't like when Abbott capitulated. But obviously the issue played. Government needs to help with a framework to find ways to make it win-win. But things are moving fast and they move slow.

For instance, utilities are getting barraged with interconnect requests and don't know which are real or speculative or tire kickers. They will now charge you $100k just to review your app and do some initial planning.
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RED AG 98 said:

Data centers are here to stay, whether you want them or not. The only serious questions are:
where they will be built?
where will the chips they require be built?

If not in the US, you can guar-an-damn-tee it will be China (including Taiwan, because all the RFIs already consider them as Chinese...)

We need Terafab and all the data centers we can build.

This isn't just for stupid memes. 25 yr semi guy here at a Fortune 100 company -- we've just completed our first full design front to back with full AI workflow -- design, verification, layout, tapeout, validation -- for an extremely complex Arm SoC.

If you don't think this is changing nearly every facet of your life, you are sorely mistaken. We have to be leaders here.


Well the democrats are in full bloom populism mode
riverrataggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Data centers are what plants crave.
javajaws
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Garrelli 5000 said:

It hilariously shows the average liberal is wildly mindless.

They congregate to big cities, while data centers can be built in the middle of red voting nowhere.

If anyone should be against data centers it would make sense that people living near them in the middle nowhere would complain.

Liberals complain about something that truly has ZERO impact on anything with their lives. DC's aren't using land by their homes, water for their homes or crops, electricity for their homes, blocking their views, etc. They're actually impacting people the left despises.

Nope. Liberals are too stupid to realize they have zero reason to be against a DC other than the MSM tells them they should. The MSM is controlled by liberals, who are controlled by communists and marxists.


They aren't stupid - they just aren't being genuine about what they don't like. It's not really the data centers they have an issue with (at least not most people). It's what they represent that they don't like. And that something they don't like is AI replacing their jobs.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Ben Franklin
RED AG 98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I am missing your point.
Ragoo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
If AI can increase productivity 10x, democrats will scream that AI is going to replace 9 people. However a business will say those 10 people can 100x productivity.

AI isn't a job replacement tool, it's a leverage tool for outsized growth.
Ragoo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
SunrayAg said:

TarponChaser said:

Anti-data center sentiment is mostly parroting ChiCom and Russian psy-ops/propaganda.


Moronic statements like this helped the dimtards take power.

All over Texas, there have been crowded commissioners court meetings and crowded public forums in over 200 counties filled with rural conservatives angrily fighting back against data centers.

People who have seen the power grid crash because of a cold front, and are concerned about doubling or tripling demand on it.

People who are concerned about their local water resources.

People who don't want the noise pollution, light pollution, and destruction of agricultural land and wildlife habitat.

And the republican response was insulting, condescending, and dismissive. Even Trump opened his yap and declared that the only people opposed to data centers are people too dumb and backwards to know any better.

And it appears that message didn't resonate.
the power grid is a boogeyman. These guys aren't stupid. They are installing behind the meter power generation.

Heck I am installing behind the meter power generation at my facilities to meet power demand that won't be available for 4-6 years.

There is tremendous opportunity out there and we are foolishly pushing it away.
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SunrayAg said:

TarponChaser said:

Anti-data center sentiment is mostly parroting ChiCom and Russian psy-ops/propaganda.


Moronic statements like this helped the dimtards take power.

All over Texas, there have been crowded commissioners court meetings and crowded public forums in over 200 counties filled with rural conservatives angrily fighting back against data centers.

People who have seen the power grid crash because of a cold front, and are concerned about doubling or tripling demand on it.

People who are concerned about their local water resources.

People who don't want the noise pollution, light pollution, and destruction of agricultural land and wildlife habitat.

And the republican response was insulting, condescending, and dismissive. Even Trump opened his yap and declared that the only people opposed to data centers are people too dumb and backwards to know any better.

And it appears that message didn't resonate.


So the anti data center stuff is based mostly on uninformed fears and false or outdated information. Thanks for confirming
Concerned Moderate Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ragoo said:

If AI can increase productivity 10x, democrats will scream that AI is going to replace 9 people. However a business will say those 10 people can 100x productivity.

AI isn't a job replacement tool, it's a leverage tool for outsized growth.


Not sure if this resonates with the people that have already lost their jobs.
jagged
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Running out of power is not outdated, it's very real concern. They are also competing with EVs and other things being more electricity dependent. Electric utilities don't move that quickly.

And behind the meter means turbines, some of which are retrofitted jet engines.

I bet you can envision people not wanting that next to their neighborhoods.

Again I am pro-DC and AI leadership, but it's not going to work to just railroad communities with them.
Ragoo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
jagged said:

Running out of power is not outdated, it's very real concern. They are also competing with EVs and other things being more electricity dependent. Electric utilities don't move that quickly.

And behind the meter means turbines, some of which are retrofitted jet engines.

I bet you can envision people not wanting that next to their neighborhoods.

Again I am pro-DC and AI leadership, but it's not going to work to just railroad communities with them.
there are noise abatement technologies.
SunrayAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
samurai_science said:

SunrayAg said:

TarponChaser said:

Anti-data center sentiment is mostly parroting ChiCom and Russian psy-ops/propaganda.


Moronic statements like this helped the dimtards take power.

All over Texas, there have been crowded commissioners court meetings and crowded public forums in over 200 counties filled with rural conservatives angrily fighting back against data centers.

People who have seen the power grid crash because of a cold front, and are concerned about doubling or tripling demand on it.

People who are concerned about their local water resources.

People who don't want the noise pollution, light pollution, and destruction of agricultural land and wildlife habitat.

And the republican response was insulting, condescending, and dismissive. Even Trump opened his yap and declared that the only people opposed to data centers are people too dumb and backwards to know any better.

And it appears that message didn't resonate.


So the anti data center stuff is based mostly on uninformed fears and false or outdated information. Thanks for confirming


Not at all. But condescending morons keep spewing the same BS.

And the mega data centers are still using electricity resources. And they are still using water. And they are still destroying agricultural land and wildlife habitat. And the data bros can stomp their feet and say unnnh unnh like a petulant child, but that doesn't change the facts.

And the completely clueless can keep peddling the bs lines about Chinese propaganda and liberals… and conservative rural Texans are still the most opposed to data centers of any people I have encountered.
Jbob04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Easy to see who owns rural land and who doesn't on these threads. City slickers on quarter acre lots need to stfu.
Fran > Elko
Psycho Bunny
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jbob04 said:

Easy to see who owns rural land and who doesn't on these threads. City slickers on quarter acre lots need to stfu.

Show me on the doll where the data center hurt you.
My demon woke up this morning telling me he was tired. I handed him a red bull & said "come on little buddy, we've got chaos to spread"
pfo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The data centers are going to get built because the future of the richest companies in the world depends on them. Data centers run the cloud and AI for MSFT META GOOG AMZN SPCX. If blue states like Texas, California and Massachusetts etc. don't want data centers, then they will get built in Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Florida, Tennessee, Asia, the Middle East, South America and outer space. But they will get built because that's where the money is and the future is.,
jja79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I live in suburban Phoenix and they're pretty common here. You wouldn't know what they are if someone didn't tell you. Some are very near residential. From what people that seem to know they've built and upgraded the power grid at their expense to the benefit of the area.
Dave Robicheaux
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My daughter came home from school saying that they want politicians that are against data centers as they are harmful to the environment. I have some work to do. What should I tell her?
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ErnestEndeavor said:

No, that's just reality. The AI focused data centers are just fundamentally different than the cloud infrastructure built out during the 2010s into the early 2020s. The cloud data centers were built in that area in part because of latency and the need to have data centers closer to DC and NY. They also draw less power, less need for water, and are far less noisy.


That's just plain false. Northern Virginia has the highest concentration of data centers in the United States, new ones and slightly older ones, and the older ones are much less efficient.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
They are built where they are solely based on availability of power. You're idea may be true in the future if they start building them with in site power generation.
MelvinUdall
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SunrayAg said:

samurai_science said:

SunrayAg said:

TarponChaser said:

Anti-data center sentiment is mostly parroting ChiCom and Russian psy-ops/propaganda.


Moronic statements like this helped the dimtards take power.

All over Texas, there have been crowded commissioners court meetings and crowded public forums in over 200 counties filled with rural conservatives angrily fighting back against data centers.

People who have seen the power grid crash because of a cold front, and are concerned about doubling or tripling demand on it.

People who are concerned about their local water resources.

People who don't want the noise pollution, light pollution, and destruction of agricultural land and wildlife habitat.

And the republican response was insulting, condescending, and dismissive. Even Trump opened his yap and declared that the only people opposed to data centers are people too dumb and backwards to know any better.

And it appears that message didn't resonate.


So the anti data center stuff is based mostly on uninformed fears and false or outdated information. Thanks for confirming


Not at all. But condescending morons keep spewing the same BS.

And the mega data centers are still using electricity resources. And they are still using water. And they are still destroying agricultural land and wildlife habitat. And the data bros can stomp their feet and say unnnh unnh like a petulant child, but that doesn't change the facts.

And the completely clueless can keep peddling the bs lines about Chinese propaganda and liberals… and conservative rural Texans are still the most opposed to data centers of any people I have encountered.


Siiggghhh…talk about condescending.
1939
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jbob04 said:

Easy to see who owns rural land and who doesn't on these threads. City slickers on quarter acre lots need to stfu.


Not true. First off it's rural landowners that are selling the land to build these things. I wish people would just admit that the reason they don't like them is because they are ugly and people don't like change, or seeing rural land be developed. I get that, but the rest of the upheaval is most caused by fear and false rumors and disinformation.

There isn't a single example of data centers drying up water sources or sending electric rates through the roof.
MelvinUdall
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1939 said:

Jbob04 said:

Easy to see who owns rural land and who doesn't on these threads. City slickers on quarter acre lots need to stfu.


Not true. First off it's rural landowners that are selling the land to build these things. I wish people would just admit that the reason they don't like them is because they are ugly and people don't like change, or seeing rural land be developed. I get that, but the rest of the upheaval is most caused by fear and false rumors and disinformation.

There isn't a single example of data centers drying up water sources or sending electric rates through the roof.


They won't listen, it is the end of the world for them.
RED AG 98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jbob04 said:

Easy to see who owns rural land and who doesn't on these threads. City slickers on quarter acre lots need to stfu.

I understand your point and as the product of a rural town with a class of 43 kids believe me I get it. I am not saying it isn't a tough or divisive issue, but the answer cannot be "don't build them." I'm telling you, this is Cold War era arms race on steroids. We must win. Or our way of life dies.
PeekingDuck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It's just NIMBY folks. Same as California.
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You can't eat a data center.
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dave Robicheaux said:

My daughter came home from school saying that they want politicians that are against data centers as they are harmful to the environment. I have some work to do. What should I tell her?
ask her to quantify the level of harm
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Jbob04 said:

Easy to see who owns rural land and who doesn't on these threads. City slickers on quarter acre lots need to stfu.

I live on 1/5th of an acre but I own a wooded 15 acres off grid on the side of a mountain in a county that has a gigantic data center.

Imagine my internal conflict about data centers.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.