NavasotaAg said:
Spent the day with SAR on the river west of Center Point. 7 deceased found within a 3 mile stretch of the river today as of 6 PM. It's sobering.
agsalaska said:
What happened to the thread on the OB??
agsalaska said:
What happened to the thread on the OB??SwigAg11 said:
It looks like it is stickied at the top of the forum.
is there anyway I can get in contact with you? A group of guys from Bellville want to come help. Our friends are there now waiting for their daughter who is still missing from mystic.NavasotaAg said:
Spent the day with SAR on the river west of Center Point. 7 deceased found within a 3 mile stretch of the river today as of 6 PM. It's sobering.
It's great for mental health, imoagsalaska said:
Stop reading them.
I used to read them too. Life is better when you don't read that nonsense.
agsalaska said:
Stop reading them.
I used to read them too. Life is better when you don't read that nonsense.Cyprian said:It's great for mental health, imo
This needs to be passed on to an investigative reporter ASAP, and put out there.Pinochet said:
Debated whether or not to post this but please stay AWAY from supporting Operation Airdrop in this. I worked with them in NC after Helene and they received so much money that they had leftover cash at the end of the week where they were needed. Instead of passing it to a group that could use it, they started buying and distributing propane and RVs. They brought on a new executive director at that point who has quietly changed the mission to try to grift off any disaster he can and this is no different. They have been repeating Kerr County updates in the first person as though they are deploying their own air assets and making rescues themselves, but they are not. They are also asking for donations. Do not give to them.
If you feel compelled to give, please give to a local organization in one of the impacted counties. Comanche Trace is coordinating a large supply drive, but there are others too. I just don't want people wasting time and money to help prop up someone's ego in North Texas.
Both warnings posted by NWS were clear cut and bold about this being life threatening, and location, even mentioning "campers" and "Kerrville". The flash flood emergency issued at 5:34 am on July 4th. "AUTOMATED RAIN GAUGES A LARGE AND DEADLY WAVE IS MOVING DOWN THE GUADALUPE… pic.twitter.com/5Om57xffu9
— Rosievortwx🌩️ (@Rosievortwx) July 5, 2025
More:Quote:
Both warnings posted by NWS were clear cut and bold about this being life threatening, and location, even mentioning "campers" and "Kerrville". The flash flood emergency issued at 5:34 am on July 4th. "AUTOMATED RAIN GAUGES A LARGE AND DEADLY WAVE IS MOVING DOWN THE GUADALUPE RIVER". The first warning was issued at 1:14 am. There were already 5 warnings/advisories issued by NWS by 2 am. Kerr County and the surrounding regions were put under a flood watch on July 3rd. I don't feel natural disaster needs blamed on anyone, but as someone who watched these warnings being issued. The NWS couldn't have done better in this one.
Every source I have read says yes. pic.twitter.com/LrXfXO4Gzk
— Rosievortwx🌩️ (@Rosievortwx) July 6, 2025
NEW: Two brothers explain their terrifying night and how they survived the Kerr County floodwaters.
— Collin Rugg (@CollinRugg) July 5, 2025
The brothers were sleeping at Camp La Junta when they started floating.
At least 24 people have lost their lives in the flood.
Authorities say more than 20 girls are… pic.twitter.com/T1yhLNmbU1
DannyDuberstein said:
Noem doing much better than Abbott. Offering actual actions they are taking vs generalities and performative signing papers he could have just said he did while giving actual infoIslanderAg04 said:
That's her job, she's head of DHS.
nortex97 said:
Good post. And as we get more details, note that there were serious warnings in the 1-2am timeframe.Both warnings posted by NWS were clear cut and bold about this being life threatening, and location, even mentioning "campers" and "Kerrville". The flash flood emergency issued at 5:34 am on July 4th. "AUTOMATED RAIN GAUGES A LARGE AND DEADLY WAVE IS MOVING DOWN THE GUADALUPE… pic.twitter.com/5Om57xffu9
— Rosievortwx🌩️ (@Rosievortwx) July 5, 2025More:Quote:
Both warnings posted by NWS were clear cut and bold about this being life threatening, and location, even mentioning "campers" and "Kerrville". The flash flood emergency issued at 5:34 am on July 4th. "AUTOMATED RAIN GAUGES A LARGE AND DEADLY WAVE IS MOVING DOWN THE GUADALUPE RIVER". The first warning was issued at 1:14 am. There were already 5 warnings/advisories issued by NWS by 2 am. Kerr County and the surrounding regions were put under a flood watch on July 3rd. I don't feel natural disaster needs blamed on anyone, but as someone who watched these warnings being issued. The NWS couldn't have done better in this one.Every source I have read says yes. pic.twitter.com/LrXfXO4Gzk
— Rosievortwx🌩️ (@Rosievortwx) July 6, 2025
The warnings were tragically not processed in time, at the key campsites. Why and who is 'to blame?' I don't know. This should never happen again.
No words. This young girl was rescued, many will not. pic.twitter.com/O4DOLii84O
— ✪ Evil Te𝕏an ✪ (@vileTexan) July 5, 2025
Storm's mostly broken up, but it's still gathering in a few spots, those areas could several inches of rain.
— ✪ Evil Te𝕏an ✪ (@vileTexan) July 6, 2025
Flood watch in the Hill Country until 1pm.
51 confirmed deaths.
Lots still missing, including 20 young girls. pic.twitter.com/ecaMI0cG95
Georgetown RV park on the San Gabriel River.
— ✪ Evil Te𝕏an ✪ (@vileTexan) July 5, 2025
Source: @storm_serenader pic.twitter.com/Na8g2t4IDL
Timelapse flooding of the Llano River on July 4th pic.twitter.com/59Tnn6NZG7
— Rob Dew (@DewsNewz) July 5, 2025
robdoubleu said:
Long time reader, first time poster.
After my folks were evacuated by USCG small boat and their house was under 6 feet of water for weeks after Harvey, and personally being evacuated for wildfires several times in the past few years, I've spent an unhealthy amount of time reading emergency plans, evacuation modeling, etc.
I find the phrases "this was unprecedented" or "this couldn't have been predicted" quite frustrating, because imagining the unprecedented and unpredictable is kind of the point of emergency planning.
There's a very shallow outline of the proper Kerr County Emergency Management Plan online but nothing with any detail I have tracked down.
Kerr County published a hazard mitigation plan in 2024 - it's both specific and generic, but it's available on the web here: https://legacy.co.kerr.tx.us/notices/docs/10-2024-KerrCountyHazardMitigationActionPlan.pdf
Some observations:
Kerr County's primary emergency notification mechanism is CodeRed, which generally requires sign up (and generally doesn't help tourists / non-local population). I'd be very interested to know if any CodeRed notices were sent by county management via text or phone.
NWS Flash Flood warnings should trigger emergency alerts to mobile devices, but these and CodeRed are both dependent on having a cell signal.
Also notable is Kerr County's existing flood gauge system which provides no useful data on flow rates, only a warning that the river has risen to some degree.
There has been discussion of replacing this with an early warning system (including sirens) as far back as 2016, when a study was commissioned to evaluate this upgrade. Seems to have died on the vine and comes back up in 2020 with no apparent progress since.
Comal county has a siren based early warning system linked to flood gauges as do plenty of other high risk areas.
One thing that is conspicuously absent from the doc is any mention of the fact that during the summer there must be thousands? of additional kids dotted around in all the summer camps, all with minimal ability to support or self-evacuate.
Perhaps this exists in the emergency management plan but all indications from the press conference is that there was no specific plan for this eventuality.
I am trying quite hard to not veer into Monday morning quarterbacking, and to draw a clear distinction between planning and response. I have no doubt that once things went south, everyone involved did their utmost to help as conditions allowed and continue to do so.
On the other hand, there are accounts of campers "waking up with water to their necks" and I have a very hard time believing that even a few minutes of early warning via sirens would not have made a difference.
I found the responses from county officials to questions about warnings of *any* kind completely lacking, and I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt until they start passing the buck to the NWS.The uploaded image is unavailable
TEXAS FLOOD: There are many questions about the tragic flash flood on the Guadalupe River late Thursday night and early Friday morning. The death toll is now over 50, including some children who were at Camp Mystic.
— James Spann (@spann) July 6, 2025
Here are some key points about the warning process...
*A flash… pic.twitter.com/fTMJHvqssG
Quote:
Comal county has a siren based early warning system linked to flood gauges as do plenty of other high risk areas.
robdoubleu said:
Long time reader, first time poster.
After my folks were evacuated by USCG small boat and their house was under 6 feet of water for weeks after Harvey, and personally being evacuated for wildfires several times in the past few years, I've spent an unhealthy amount of time reading emergency plans, evacuation modeling, etc.
I find the phrases "this was unprecedented" or "this couldn't have been predicted" quite frustrating, because imagining the unprecedented and unpredictable is kind of the point of emergency planning.
There's a very shallow outline of the proper Kerr County Emergency Management Plan online but nothing with any detail I have tracked down.
Kerr County published a hazard mitigation plan in 2024 - it's both specific and generic, but it's available on the web here: https://legacy.co.kerr.tx.us/notices/docs/10-2024-KerrCountyHazardMitigationActionPlan.pdf
Some observations:
Kerr County's primary emergency notification mechanism is CodeRed, which generally requires sign up (and generally doesn't help tourists / non-local population). I'd be very interested to know if any CodeRed notices were sent by county management via text or phone.
NWS Flash Flood warnings should trigger emergency alerts to mobile devices, but these and CodeRed are both dependent on having a cell signal.
Also notable is Kerr County's existing flood gauge system which provides no useful data on flow rates, only a warning that the river has risen to some degree.
There has been discussion of replacing this with an early warning system (including sirens) as far back as 2016, when a study was commissioned to evaluate this upgrade. Seems to have died on the vine and comes back up in 2020 with no apparent progress since.
Comal county has a siren based early warning system linked to flood gauges as do plenty of other high risk areas.
One thing that is conspicuously absent from the doc is any mention of the fact that during the summer there must be thousands? of additional kids dotted around in all the summer camps, all with minimal ability to support or self-evacuate.
Perhaps this exists in the emergency management plan but all indications from the press conference is that there was no specific plan for this eventuality.
I am trying quite hard to not veer into Monday morning quarterbacking, and to draw a clear distinction between planning and response. I have no doubt that once things went south, everyone involved did their utmost to help as conditions allowed and continue to do so.
On the other hand, there are accounts of campers "waking up with water to their necks" and I have a very hard time believing that even a few minutes of early warning via sirens would not have made a difference.
I found the responses from county officials to questions about warnings of *any* kind completely lacking, and I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt until they start passing the buck to the NWS.The uploaded image is unavailableitsyourboypookie said:
NOAA Weather radio solves most of this. The warnings were there, does no good if no one can hear them.TEXAS FLOOD: There are many questions about the tragic flash flood on the Guadalupe River late Thursday night and early Friday morning. The death toll is now over 50, including some children who were at Camp Mystic.
— James Spann (@spann) July 6, 2025
Here are some key points about the warning process...
*A flash… pic.twitter.com/fTMJHvqssG
Troy91 said:
It helps to realize that our university graduates a number of people who have to pull out a spreadsheet to analyze anything. In the face of an overwhelming human tragedy, their response is to start pivot tables and data analysis in lieu of an actual human emotion.
Instead of waiting for the data to be collected, they start producing hunches and plans to prevent the last thing that happened.
It is how they cope. Unfortunately, many of them cannot complete their uniquely personal coping mechanism without advertising how the last thing could be prevented.
You can look at any latest thing thread and identify them quickly.
This is a human tragedy and, sometimes, spreadsheets cannot predict the future. I remain hopeful that these individuals will eventually learn to read the room and do their "data analysis" in private.
Troy91 said:
It helps to realize that our university graduates a number of people who have to pull out a spreadsheet to analyze anything. In the face of an overwhelming human tragedy, their response is to start pivot tables and data analysis in lieu of an actual human emotion.
Instead of waiting for the data to be collected, they start producing hunches and plans to prevent the last thing that happened.
It is how they cope. Unfortunately, many of them cannot complete their uniquely personal coping mechanism without advertising how the last thing could be prevented.
You can look at any latest thing thread and identify them quickly.
This is a human tragedy and, sometimes, spreadsheets cannot predict the future. I remain hopeful that these individuals will eventually learn to read the room and do their "data analysis" in private.