Major Corps Changes - Political BS

89,717 Views | 842 Replies | Last: 8 mo ago by Tex100
281TexAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HollywoodBQ said:

The Kraken said:

Your daughter went to VMI...how did they train/integrate the rats?
Apologies in advance for the length but there's no way to tell COL Kurtz story without telling my own.

My daughter appears to be the only cadet from Australia to ever sign the Matriculation Book.
Coming from a swanky private girls school in Sydney to VMI was a major shock. She told me later, something to the effect of, one of the reasons she made it was because she didn't know what she was getting in to.

Just like at Texas A&M, they have a non-commission option in the VMI Corps.
Unlike Texas A&M, all of their Division 1 athletes are also cadets. This is one of the primary avenues for recruiting females.

The composition of their Corps is similar to the US Military with 15%-18% females even though the first female wasn't admitted until about 1999. I know they celebrated the 20th anniversary while my daughter was a cadet (her friends are in scenes of the RBG movie).

VMI has a fitness test which all cadets must past so just like Texas A&M, there is a physical fitness aspect as well as the 7-day a week uniformed Corps of Cadets. There is an honor code which they adhere to much more strictly than A&M does the Aggie Code of Honor.

For the integration of the Rat Mass, here's how it works.
  • They usually have about 500 cadets show up in August for Matriculation Day.
  • They get fitted for uniforms, change into PT gear and then have a ceremony where they are taken away for an 8 day long training event called "Hell Week" (far more intense than Aggie FOW).
  • They lose a few cadets during that time which completes prior to the start of classes. At VMI, quitting is called Outprocessing or OP.
  • During "Hell Week" is when some athletes discover that this is a Military themed college (despite the fact it's in the name, you'd be amazed how many athletes don't realize this).
  • After "Hell Week", they start into their academic year, going to class, doing ROTC, etc.
  • They have formations in the morning and evening, just like A&M's Corps.
  • If you think "Whipping Out" is bad, wait until you find out about "Straining" at VMI.
A few major differences between A&M's Corps and the VMI Corps:

Their cadet companies are much larger. They have a small marching band which is its own company. Otherwise, they have about 9-10 companies for a Cadet Corps of around 1,700 cadets on a good day. Each of these companies might have 150 or so cadets. I think they only have two Battalions and one Regimental Commander.

They assign male cadets to companies based on height. Kind of like the Ross Volunteer Platoons, I guess. Alpha and India are the companies where everybody is 6'0" or better and these two companies include most of the athletes. In the middle of the formation, the 5'4" guys are all in Delta or Echo.

Females are assigned to companies more randomly. They don't have that many females to go around so they get scattered across random companies. Especially since a lot of them are in Band Company, each company only gets a few female Rats every year.

They live in bigger rooms on the same floor with their class. Fourth Class cadets on fourth stoop and First Class cadets on the ground floor. The rooms vary in size from as few as 4 Rats per room to as many as 7 in a strangely shaped corner room. Every year they move down a floor so the rooms get mixed up a little as well as friendship groups change so they don't necessarily live with the same people all the time. And there's no outfit per floor concept like at A&M. They only have 3 "barracks" buildings instead of 10-12 like the Aggie Quad.

Limited Cadet Leadership Opportunities At VMI, there are only a handful of leadership positions compared to A&M so not that many cadets get to be a Platoon Leader, Company Commander, Regimental Commander, etc. Those folks are referred to as "Rankers" and get made fun of a lot by their Brother Rats (BRs).

There is no Civilian Option Obviously the biggest difference overall. If you OP from the Corps at VMI, you're also leaving the University.

Ca-dating - You're not allowed to date in your chain of command and as a Rat, you're not allowed to date at all. With the upperclassmen, some cadets will move between companies for dating purposes.

Leaving Post - Rats are not allowed to leave campus except at special times of the semester like when there's a Football Game and their parents can take them out for dinner afterwards.

Cars - Only First Class cadets are allowed to have cars on campus so there is a culture of ride sharing. Especially for out of state cadets who need a ride from Roanoke, or Washington, D.C. to get to campus.

Duration of their Rat Year versus our fish Year - The Rats get dogged out until they "breakout" which usually occurs in February when the Rats have achieved the standards required.

I know things are different today but when I was in the Corps (BG Michaelis was in the same Army ROTC Year Group as me), Corps Brass was earned in the Fall at random times by random Corps outfits. In the Band, we technically earned our Corps Brass after our first "Perfect Drill" (which in my case was before classes even started) but, we continued to get dogged out until sometime around "March to the Brazos" in April. Some minor chilling out during Bonfire cut but otherwise, it was balls to the wall.

Rat - First Class relationship - During my time, we were always 1:1 between the fish and sophomores. The Juniors were enjoying Junior Privileges and the Zips were pretty much dead except for the Zips who wanted to be Super Pissheads. They'd stop by to make sure the Sophomores were doing their jobs to their degree of satisfaction.

At VMI, the (Seniors) First Class Cadets are assigned a Rat. Sometimes, they might have more than 1 because there are more Rats than First Class Cadets. The well being of that Rat is the responsibility of the First Class cadet and they take pride in ownership so to speak. They want their Rat to do well. They want their Rat to learn and survive and continue their lineage.

Everybody at VMI can trace their "heritage" so to speak back to whomever trained them. Who their Rat to First Class cadet relationship was. So, my Armor School buddy who was VMI Class of 1993, would have trained 1996, they would have trained 1999, 2002, 2005, 2008, 2011, 2014, 2017, 2020, etc. So, it would have been a big deal if his son had been 2020 instead of 2021.

One key takeaway here is that at VMI, their Class Year and their "Line" matters more to them than what cadet company they were in.

The other key takeaway in the VMI system is that the First Class cadets are invested in the success of the Rats. They set the standard and hold their Rats to the standard but it's more of a 1:1 relationship rather than dogging out some random cadet in your company that you don't know. Because with the larger company sizes, you won't know everybody.

Summer Transition Program - We didn't know about this program before my daughter attended VMI but it's helpful for many. What they do is, teach summer school classes not in uniform. So there's no Corps active and no uniforms but, they have two terms where students can earn 6 hours per team.

During STP, they work with upper class cadets to improve things like running, PT, fitness. I know that they break up the incoming cadets (the call them "Pre-Strains") into running ability groups and work with them on that.

Meals - Once the Fall school semester starts and they're marching down to Crozet Dining Hall for meals, it's very much like the old Duncan Dining Hall meals were.

Breaks - VMI gets a Furlough for a week over Thanksgiving. And they get some relief after home football games but other than that, it's a long slog.

I was confused when I was reading the earlier statements about Texas A&M having a Fall Break. During my era of the Aggie Band traveling to every football game, our first "break" was after the Thanksgiving game against t.u. in Austin.

Politics - One last thing I'll say about the VMI Corps is that they're way more politically connected in Virginia but just like Texas A&M, a frequent target for the media and haters. We had Governor Perry, they had the Coonman.

Probably more information than any of you every wanted to know and I'm sure I left some stuff out.
Hopefully that info is useful as the Aggie Corps looks at making changes.
This is interesting. I always wondered about that place.

Does anyone know anything about Virginia Tech's Corps? I am guessing it's more like A&M because they have a lot of non-regs. It's notable that Virginia has two senior military colleges.
pacecar02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
NICU Dad said:

pacecar02 said:

We're there 3 of them? Then yes.

And after the corps we became neighbors.
Same family. My ol lady is the oldest of the 3.
Yup, thems good people for sure. I also went to high school in SA with one of your buddies
no sig
aggiez03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Update...

Keep the pressure on, if you have called, then tell someone else to call.

If you haven't called, then call the CCA or the Corps Office and voice your displeasure.

There is a major groundswell against this, but we need to keep it up...


Start by calling the Corps of Cadets association (979-221-1998 )

AND

emailing:

bruce@corpsofcadets.org
Bruce Hamilton is CEO.

He will send you a letter saying he is 100% in support of the Commandant.
Let them know you are against it and it will kill the Corps.
NICU Dad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
pacecar02 said:

NICU Dad said:

pacecar02 said:

We're there 3 of them? Then yes.

And after the corps we became neighbors.
Same family. My ol lady is the oldest of the 3.
Yup, thems good people for sure. I also went to high school in SA with one of your buddies
The Marine or the AF one?
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bobbranco said:

I really don't care what you do. It's embarrassing. Good luck.
who else got shaved from the neck down?
Gator_2
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gator92 said:

bobbranco said:

I really don't care what you do. It's embarrassing. Good luck.
who else got shaved from the neck down?


Our outfit was almost gutted for that…
Easy come, easy go
Ensign Mayo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
For those of you that like to write letters:

Patrick R. Michaelis '93
Office of the Commandant HQ
Texas A&M University
Military Sciences Building
College Station, TX
77843-1227
Jack Ruby
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The only thing I have to add is this:

Whiskey Bent, Hell Bound, We Drink More Beer.

Apparently it worked out well for Eric Smith.
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gator_2 said:

Gator92 said:

bobbranco said:

I really don't care what you do. It's embarrassing. Good luck.
who else got shaved from the neck down?


Our outfit was almost gutted for that…
Was this about the time that little johnny's parents started complaining about not sleeping under ur sheets?

For those uninformed, we slept in a sleeping bag on top of our rack which was "short sheeted w/ one sheet and the corps issued bed cover.

Hard to splain, but if you know, you know...
Ensign Mayo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
EagleCamden said:

For those of you that like to write letters:

Patrick R. Michaelis '93
Office of the Commandant HQ
Texas A&M University
Military Sciences Building
College Station, TX
77843-1227
I'm going to write him one hand written note a day with my thoughts on his proposal. no doubt in my mind this will get squashed. he didn't ask for any approvals, just came up with an idea. Doesn't work like that in aggieland.
Jack Ruby
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gator92 said:

Gator_2 said:

Gator92 said:

bobbranco said:

I really don't care what you do. It's embarrassing. Good luck.
who else got shaved from the neck down?


Our outfit was almost gutted for that…
Was this about the time that little johnny's parents started complaining about not sleeping under ur sheets?

For those uninformed, we slept in a sleeping bag on top of our rack which was "short sheeted w/ one sheet and the corps issued bed cover.

Hard to splain, but if you know, you know...


It was a privilege in FTAB for sophomores to sleep on the floor. I don't want to hear your griping.
Gator_2
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Probably so. I'm class of '15.

I know I used a sleeping bag on top of my rack until I was a white belt though
Easy come, easy go
HollywoodBQ
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Houston Lee said:

Look. Just have the fish go in the new way. Then when they eventually get to their individual units, make them earn something specific to the unit. They can get their Corps Brass, or in my case, their Band Lyre. But then make them earn something else for the unit.

Crap them out and put them through hell. It just may be delayed a bit while they do the generic corps stuff for the first semester.

I was in B-Company "Street Fighters". Make it so they cant earn their official Street Fighter shirt until they complete the "initiation process"...


Funny story from the end of the marching season my fish year.

Our section sergeant had a bunch of us fish into his room in B-Battery to chill out because the Fall was almost over and we needed it.

One of my fish buddies asked him what the Spring semester was going to be like. He described how it would be more chill and more focused on academics. He looked me square in the eye and said, "B-Company will continue to do push-ups". My heart sank and I'm sure he saw it in my face.

Only one funnier than that with all the discussion about winding up in "random" outfits. When I was in the Band Room for my New Student Conference in the summer of 1988 and Jay Brewer said to me (in his Texas drawl), "I'm gonna put you in my old outfit, B-Company". I thought he was doing me a solid.

But, I can't imagine experiencing the Aggie Band any other way, Corps Bloody Cross and everything (and I hate running). The most notorious sophomore in the Corps was my ASL (he's now my insurance agent - because I trust him implicitly). He and I were also part of the Bonfire Cut team where the drum major dropped a tree on a truck. And my country music claim to fame - I was fish Creager's ASL. Being assigned an outfit at random worked out for me.
Boozer92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I don't understand what happens to non fish in this plan. Do outfits only live together in the spring? What exactly does no unified hallways mean? 2 outfits sharing a floor or outfits scattered across the quad randomly to further eliminate outfit pride? Do they only gather for tailgates before march in?(unless the game is Thanksgiving week and the Corps pretends there isn't a football game)
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gator_2 said:

Probably so. I'm class of '15.

I know I used a sleeping bag on top of my rack until I was a white belt though
Ha ha.

I think that dust up was before your time.

I think I'm beyond the statute of limitations, but I'd be honored to buy you a beer and exchange notes.

If you are in the Houston, Austin, SA area, DM me.
Dark_Knight
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think I'll reserve judgment until I see it straight from the Commandant. Seeing 2nd hand info from cadets or others isn't good enough and a lot can get lost in translation.

From what I've seen, I don't see the big deal over it. Might work and be a good idea. A lot of these upperclassmen aren't ready for leadership roles, I remember seeing a lot of terrible leaders in my day.
Weren't freshmen segregated at one point back in old army, when they used to live at riverside?
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
did you not read pg 4 of this thread?

ETA: https://texags.com/forums/16/topics/3445138/replies/66999556
aggiez03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dark_Knight said:

I think I'll reserve judgment until I see it straight from the Commandant. Seeing 2nd hand info from cadets or others isn't good enough and a lot can get lost in translation.

From what I've seen, I don't see the big deal over it. Might work and be a good idea. A lot of these upperclassmen aren't ready for leadership roles, I remember seeing a lot of terrible leaders in my day.
Weren't freshmen segregated at one point back in old army, when they used to live at riverside?
Cool. Then don't complain when it is too late to do anything about it.

There is not going to be any big discussion where everyone can all chime in their opinion.

The Commandant and bulls decided to do this without ANY input from anyone in the university. Not Sharp, Not Welsch, Not BOR, not AFS, not Rick Perry, Not CCA, not Corps Advisory board, Not current cadets, Not former cadets, No future fish parents, NO ONE outside the Trigon.

Your reserve judgement will be done in the post-mortem of the Corps or his tenure, whatever comes first.

And yes, cadets were segregated 70 years ago when there was not room on campus after WW2. I am not sure, but don't think we are facing the same challenges today as we did post WW2.
Boozer92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Seems to the obvious result is fish are now fish for 3 semesters. Until new fish arrive in the outfit first semester pissheads are still fish.

Unless no unified hallways mean there are no outfits in the fall. Which would mean outfits will take outfit activities off campus in the fall. That is likely not going to work out well.

I see no upside to this plan. I have read every response on this thread and while some make arguments for a needed change none give any reason why this would help in any way
pacecar02
How long do you want to ignore this user?
both
no sig
ELREY
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dark_Knight said:

I think I'll reserve judgment until I see it straight from the Commandant. Seeing 2nd hand info from cadets or others isn't good enough and a lot can get lost in translation.

From what I've seen, I don't see the big deal over it. Might work and be a good idea. A lot of these upperclassmen aren't ready for leadership roles, I remember seeing a lot of terrible leaders in my day.
Weren't freshmen segregated at one point back in old army, when they used to live at riverside?


The logic for the decision is out there and after having read it the decision makes less sense.

The truth is the process on how this decision was made was actually worse than the decision. No one knew, he did this in secret with some "working group" that know one knows whose is on. That is not how serious people make decisions.


I have seen a point by point rebuttal to the arguments that is very well thought out but have not seen it on TexAgs. Please don't wait or trust leadership the Corps is too important and we owe it to the current cadets.

Btw the Cadets hate this as well. Last count I Heard 500 have signed a petition opposing this decision. He may create the very problem he is trying to solve.



Posting on my phone please forgive any typos….
ELREY
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
aggiez03 said:

Dark_Knight said:

I think I'll reserve judgment until I see it straight from the Commandant. Seeing 2nd hand info from cadets or others isn't good enough and a lot can get lost in translation.

From what I've seen, I don't see the big deal over it. Might work and be a good idea. A lot of these upperclassmen aren't ready for leadership roles, I remember seeing a lot of terrible leaders in my day.
Weren't freshmen segregated at one point back in old army, when they used to live at riverside?
Cool. Then don't complain when it is too late to do anything about it.

There is not going to be any big discussion where everyone can all chime in their opinion.

The Commandant and bulls decided to do this without ANY input from anyone in the university. Not Sharp, Not Welsch, Not BOR, not AFS, not Rick Perry, Not CCA, not Corps Advisory board, Not current cadets, Not former cadets, No future fish parents, NO ONE outside the Trigon.

Your reserve judgement will be done in the post-mortem of the Corps or his tenure, whatever comes first.

And yes, cadets were segregated 70 years ago when there was not room on campus after WW2. I am not sure, but don't think we are facing the same challenges today as we did post WW2.




Preach! You are exactly right!!!!


One more point about the poor leadership examples. I actually think that is a feature of the fish year. I know I had some awful upperclassmen leaders that were frankly learning themselves. I used them as examples of how not to lead. Plus the good ones were mentors and set an example. We are going to take that away? Seriously the more you think about this the dumber the idea gets….

Someone tell me where I am wrong, I want to hear the other side.
Boozer92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Math says this is doomed

41 Corps outfits. 200 whitebelts handle fish training. 100 pissheads join the leadership training.

The rest of corps has no job. Zero chance they fall in line behind the guys chosen by the Trigon to handle training. That leaves 1200 or more non fish corp members to create their own Corps experience completely outside and opposed to Trigon efforts. You can't tell that many people that they don't matter and expect them to follow those you claim do matter. Anyone who was in the Corps knows how this ends. Complete disaster
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
NICU Dad said:

aggie93 said:

pacecar02 said:

2nd here

Streetfighter '02
So do you also agree that while you are more loyal to your outfit than the Band that it really isn't a big deal for your fish to be a part of your outfit from the beginning? Of course that also won't work in the Band since you guys are marching at Kyle so quickly unless you want Band fish not to march.

See where this is going?
Wrong again. It was and is crucial for the fish to be part of the outfit from day 1. Especially since Hell Week died.
I couldn't agree more. The original response was a BQ talking about how the Corps could do a separate fish thing and then come get a tshirt after they join the outfit. Then of course for the Band that's unthinkable.

My point is that both suffer equally. Technically BQ fish could just not march at Kyle and just be part of the Corps. It would just be a terrible ldea just as this plan to separate fish from their Corps outfit is.
"The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help."

Ronald Reagan
Dark_Knight
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I feel like everyone is getting too caught up with "how it's always been", the emotions, nostalgia, etc. I get it. It's jarring to me. I'm a bit confused on the why this isbhappening exactly.

I can understand and see what the Commandant is saying with regards to leadership training, etc. I think a lot of things got worse because they made the Corps too easy, not holding people accountable.

I don't know. I'm not as up in arms over it because I'm sure there needs to be an overhaul somewhere. I don't see the Corps having the respect it once had. Definitely doesn't seem like they have the commissioning numbers they did in the past. The logistics of this does seem a bit off, but fish aren't supposed to have much anyway. I had to change holes several times due to buddies punching.

So I don't know. I don't think this is going to "kill" the Corps. This might be a good thing.
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This...

Quote:

One more point about the poor leadership examples. I actually think that is a feature of the fish year. I know I had some awful upperclassmen leaders that were frankly learning themselves. I used them as examples of how not to lead. Plus the good ones were mentors and set an example. We are going to take that away? Seriously the more you think about this the dumber the idea gets….
All kinds of examples to learn from both good and bad.

It is human nature to learn more from the bad than the good.

Snowplow generation might be worse than the everyone gets a trophy gen...
aggiez03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Boozer92 said:

Math says this is doomed

41 Corps outfits. 200 whitebelts handle fish training. 100 pissheads join the leadership training.

The rest of corps has no job. Zero chance they fall in line behind the guys chosen by the Trigon to handle training. That leaves 1200 or more non fish corp members to create their own Corps experience completely outside and opposed to Trigon efforts. You can't tell that many people that they don't matter and expect them to follow those you claim do matter. Anyone who was in the Corps knows how this ends. Complete disaster
Not sure it matters. The training will be done by the contract cadets as the D&C cadets will quit or be treated as 2nd class citizens (as many are now), who need to 'get with the program'.

It will be a bigger time boof wasting study or potential class time for mandatory training time that cadets will have to schedule around.

My thoughts if this goes through, is that this year, the fish will still get to choose their outfit. In the next 2-3 years, that will be taken away, and fish will be 'randomly' assigned by the Trigon.

They absolutely cannot stand that some outfits excel, while others lag behind. They want everything to be equal.
TA-OP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
They want everyone to be equal? So do I! I want every effing one of them to be the best we have to offer.
Dark_Knight
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Boozer92 said:

Math says this is doomed

41 Corps outfits. 200 whitebelts handle fish training. 100 pissheads join the leadership training.

The rest of corps has no job. Zero chance they fall in line behind the guys chosen by the Trigon to handle training. That leaves 1200 or more non fish corp members to create their own Corps experience completely outside and opposed to Trigon efforts. You can't tell that many people that they don't matter and expect them to follow those you claim do matter. Anyone who was in the Corps knows how this ends. Complete disaster


I feel like this still sorta happens in larger outfits where you have too many upperclassmen for any meaningful leadership roles. I remember encountering this with my outfit. As a zip, those who weren't in on the training Cadre weren't supposed to "train" the fish. You just kinda had to stand by. Really took the fun out of it.
So yea, I see how on a larger level this might not work out very well at all.
aggiez03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TA-OP said:

They want everyone to be equal? So do I! I want every effing one of them to be the best we have to offer.
No, that would be great.

More like this...

Dark_Knight
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Gator92 said:

This...

Quote:

One more point about the poor leadership examples. I actually think that is a feature of the fish year. I know I had some awful upperclassmen leaders that were frankly learning themselves. I used them as examples of how not to lead. Plus the good ones were mentors and set an example. We are going to take that away? Seriously the more you think about this the dumber the idea gets….
All kinds of examples to learn from both good and bad.

It is human nature to learn more from the bad than the good.

Snowplow generation might be worse than the everyone gets a trophy gen...



I think there will be plenty of time to see the examples of good and bad leadership. I had seen it all 4 years and carried that with me ever since.
ELREY
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dark_Knight said:

I feel like everyone is getting too caught up with "how it's always been", the emotions, nostalgia, etc. I get it. It's jarring to me. I'm a bit confused on the why this isbhappening exactly.

I can understand and see what the Commandant is saying with regards to leadership training, etc. I think a lot of things got worse because they made the Corps too easy, not holding people accountable.

I don't know. I'm not as up in arms over it because I'm sure there needs to be an overhaul somewhere. I don't see the Corps having the respect it once had. Definitely doesn't seem like they have the commissioning numbers they did in the past. The logistics of this does seem a bit off, but fish aren't supposed to have much anyway. I had to change holes several times due to buddies punching.

So I don't know. I don't think this is going to "kill" the Corps. This might be a good thing.


I certainly understand that perspective but I am not one of those Ole Army people. I 100% agree that the Corps needs to improve the leadership training, which can be done without these radical changes.

Let the Cadets lead, make changes around the edges and recruit better. The Corps is still a great organization, the current Cadets are top quality folks, I promise.

Maybe you're right and it doesn't ruin the Corps but do we really want to take that risk?
aggiez03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Dark_Knight said:

I feel like everyone is getting too caught up with "how it's always been", the emotions, nostalgia, etc. I get it. It's jarring to me. I'm a bit confused on the why this isbhappening exactly.

I can understand and see what the Commandant is saying with regards to leadership training, etc. I think a lot of things got worse because they made the Corps too easy, not holding people accountable.

Then you will love his new ideas, that I have not even gotten into yet..

Pissheads CANNOT talk to a fish in a 'threatening' way.

Chow is meant as a time to have a 'professional' conversation with whitebelts. Pissheads not at the table

Morning formation 2 days per week.

No pushups before or during formation

Lots more that I don't remember. These are just ideas for now.

Quote:

I don't know. I'm not as up in arms over it because I'm sure there needs to be an overhaul somewhere. I don't see the Corps having the respect it once had. Definitely doesn't seem like they have the commissioning numbers they did in the past.
The Corps does not have the respect it once had because the traditions of the Corps are not being preserved. Soph & Jrs apparently no longer whip out. Why? I don't know, probably cause no one makes them. This can be fixed without removing the fish.

Commission numbers are way down? Well probably so. You have a woke military, that is paying for transgender surgeries, requiring the jab, and a gov't that won't take care of its veterans.

No one is saying the outfits should not conform to Corps standards. No one is saying that nothing needs to be fixed. What we are saying is removing the fish isn't going to fix the upperclassmen's habits or behavior for several years. It only takes 2-3 years to complete remove outfit culture. Once you get two classes that don't buy in, by the third year, those seniors (who were the original fish in former Corps experience) will be going against 3 classes and they will just check out...
Boozer92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
aggiez03 said:

Boozer92 said:

Math says this is doomed

41 Corps outfits. 200 whitebelts handle fish training. 100 pissheads join the leadership training.

The rest of corps has no job. Zero chance they fall in line behind the guys chosen by the Trigon to handle training. That leaves 1200 or more non fish corp members to create their own Corps experience completely outside and opposed to Trigon efforts. You can't tell that many people that they don't matter and expect them to follow those you claim do matter. Anyone who was in the Corps knows how this ends. Complete disaster
Not sure it matters. The training will be done by the contract cadets as the D&C cadets will quit or be treated as 2nd class citizens (as many are now), who need to 'get with the program'.

It will be a bigger time boof wasting study or potential class time for mandatory training time that cadets will have to schedule around.

My thoughts if this goes through, is that this year, the fish will still get to choose their outfit. In the next 2-3 years, that will be taken away, and fish will be 'randomly' assigned by the Trigon.

They absolutely cannot stand that some outfits excel, while others lag behind. They want everything to be equal.


When the disenfranchised outnumber the chosen 4 or 5 to one. The disenfranchised are the actual Corps

I know we are 11 years apart so things may have been different somewhat. In my time we shunned any guys who went battalion or brigade staff. They got fed the sane bs we fed the bulls. Corps Staff was ignored pretty much universally across the Corps. The respect went to the people chosen among their peers. This plan is that on steroids. Cadre exists outside the outfit. Inside the outfit the majority of the corps will operate on their own with no oversight and clear message those in charge of oversight are to avoided at all costs. It is a terrible idea.
Gator92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The other thing I can't believe about this thread 11 pages in...

muh, the corps is ghey.

muh, we need cheerleaders.

muh, the corps is why we can't win a MNC.

cause croots won't come her cause corps is ruining the "brand"

C'mon non regs!

WTH?

happened on pg juan in f5 tho...
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.