Israel/Hamas going at it

1,958,702 Views | 10849 Replies | Last: 4 days ago by DirtyMikesBoys
Naveronski
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
txwxman said:

According to Axios, citing a US administration official, the American captives unit in Israel assisted in the release of the four Israeli captives in Gaza.

I wonder if this was intel only, or if we had shooters on the ground.

DEVGRU and Delta are some of the absolute best hostage rescue units on the planet, but I'm not sure the US would want to put our fingerprint on this.
SunTunnel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
txags92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
buzzardb267 said:

Having absolutely no knowledge of the details of the operation, and just using common sense, how could hamas sit by watching such a devastating assault with enough firepower to kill and maim that many civilians, and not kill the hostages? Surely it would take some time and a LOT of noise to massacre that many innocents. If one iota of that reporting is true, they had plenty of time to kill the hostages and blend into the crowd and escape.
For starters, take any estimate of killed or wounded and cut it by about 90% if it came from Hamas. Then take that number and assume about 80% were Hamas fighters or willing human shields trying to help by getting in the way.

So if Hamas is saying 100 were killed, assume it was actually about 10 killed, and that only 2 were non-combatants.
OPAG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The hard core fundamentalist Muslim, wants to die a martyr. They are true, but deceived believers. Families have been getting payments and honor for suiciding themselves in the name of Allah.

The history is the PLA originally got this tactic from the Japanese Red army. Create martyrs for the cause to win.

It will work on some in the west.

But as Patton said, you do not win a war by dying for your country, you win it by making the other poor dumb b***** die for his.
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sudden jihadi syndrome is real and can pop up in any moslem/family of moslems at any time. An Al Jazeera 'journalist' and his family were participating directly in the imprisonment of one of the rescued hostages and…found out;



nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Disgusting.

nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So infuriating. All of those NGO's, 501C3's, and 'press' organizations in Gaza are vermin partners with Hamas, period.

agent-maroon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


Excuse me Ramy, but doesn't this all fall within the standards of behavior hamas set when they took these hostages in the first damn place?

**** this POS
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
BQRyno
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yeah, this is a weird way of saying they killed the people who were holding hostages who were kidnapped 8 mi the ago.
BQ78
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
*Leftist Hamas lover*They weren't hostages, they were guests*Leftist Hamas lover*
JFABNRGR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Naveronski said:

txwxman said:

According to Axios, citing a US administration official, the American captives unit in Israel assisted in the release of the four Israeli captives in Gaza.

I wonder if this was intel only, or if we had shooters on the ground.

DEVGRU and Delta are some of the absolute best hostage rescue units on the planet, but I'm not sure the US would want to put our fingerprint on this.


I believe there is still 6-8 American hostages not accounted for an absolutely a reason for Delta to be in a position to assist in their release either directly or indirectly.
txwxman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Naveronski said:

txwxman said:

According to Axios, citing a US administration official, the American captives unit in Israel assisted in the release of the four Israeli captives in Gaza.

I wonder if this was intel only, or if we had shooters on the ground.

DEVGRU and Delta are some of the absolute best hostage rescue units on the planet, but I'm not sure the US would want to put our fingerprint on this.

Intel from air assets and cyber is what I read somewhere.
Build It
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
These are the American hostages. Don't think anyone in our administration knows their names.

Edan Alexander
Itay Chen
Sagui Dekel-Chen
Hersh Goldberg-Polin
Gadi Haggai
Judith Weinstein Haggai
Omer Neutra
Keith Siegel
JFABNRGR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Build It said:

These are the American hostages. Don't think anyone in our administration knows their names.

Edan Alexander
Itay Chen
Sagui Dekel-Chen
Hersh Goldberg-Polin
Gadi Haggai
Judith Weinstein Haggai
Omer Neutra
Keith Siegel


Thank you for posting their names.
tylercsbn9
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Agthatbuilds said:




Always with the women and children

If the numbers are even real than it's just proof Hamas uses them as human shields. Nothing new
fixer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Any non-trivial chance Hamas executed a good portion of this 274 either from recklessness or intentional killing ( to blame it on Israel)?
JFABNRGR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
fixer said:

Any non-trivial chance Hamas executed a good portion of this 274 either from recklessness or intentional killing ( to blame it on Israel)?


Like 99.9%….for sure.
samurai_science
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fixer said:

Any non-trivial chance Hamas executed a good portion of this 274 either from recklessness or intentional killing ( to blame it on Israel)?
The numbers are a lie, but who cares anyway
Who?mikejones!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yes, more info is leaking out saying hamas opened up on the column when they were on the way out
Ag87H2O
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
nortex97 said:

Disgusting.


If this is true, they need to be rounded up and put on the next plane to Tel Aviv.

Let the Israelis put them on trial, or better yet, drop them in Gaza in the areas of heaviest fighting.
Raiderjay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tylercsbn9 said:

Agthatbuilds said:




Always with the women and children

If the numbers are even real than it's just proof Hamas uses them as human shields. Nothing new
In Norm McDonald voice:

"Here's an idea....Don't take hostages of a country that can kick your ass...."
Raiderjay
How long do you want to ignore this user?
There are still American's being held hostage.....I thought we left no American, behind??? Where the hell is our military doing everything we can to free every American????

Sickening.....
Ag In Ok
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Agthatbuilds said:

Yes, more info is leaking out saying hamas opened up on the column when they were on the way out


If true, Israel would likely have video and data - who comes back, communicates to whom, followed by action is intel.
EX TEXASEX
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tylercsbn9 said:

Agthatbuilds said:




Always with the women and children

If the numbers are even real than it's just proof Hamas uses them as human shields. Nothing new
I am surprised they didn't pull out the POC card and use that. Since these Muslims, play the left and the media in the U.S. like a fiddle 24/7/365
#FJB
Naveronski
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Thank y'all for the info, I wasn't aware.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
there are DOZENS of examples of this - often times the exact same Palestinian Actor who is seen all over the Strip and has "died" 17 times already.

LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
this is a pretty interesting tactical issue: the Hamas terrorist has an advanced RPG. so if the Merkava tank simply rolls up to the spider hole, the terrorist could be at the bottom and shoot the RPG right into the soft underbelly since the tunnel is likely reinforced with concrete.

what is the best way to kill the occupants of the tunnel if you are in a 40 ton tank?

LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
txags92 said:


FA FO

Don't want your civilians killed? Don't attack your powerful neighbor and hide the hostages you took amongst civilians. Otherwise, I have no sympathy for them whatsoever.

It's actually more sordid than that though.

it's not just that Hamas "attacked" a stronger neighbor. that happens all the time.

it's that they butchered innocent men, women and children, tortured the elderly, took hundreds of hostages, defiled bodies.

THEN they hid the hostages amongst their own civilian population, where they also hide their weapons and their own terrorists literally hide in little girl's bedrooms.

then they assign "civilians" to guard the hostages

then when there is a rescue mission the terrorists open fire like in Black Hawk Down Mogadishu

THEN they cry about it
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
txwxman said:

According to Axios, citing a US administration official, the American captives unit in Israel assisted in the release of the four Israeli captives in Gaza.

i would best most of my mortgage that means the USA allowed some of their drone intelligence to be shared with the IDF.

if anyone really thinks that Biden has "boots on the ground" then that is laughable.
A_Gang_Ag_06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I am not Jewish but this subject, in the exact same way as Covid, is something I'm willing to lose friends and family members over. Covid exposed a lot of people for who they really are. This is the same for me and where I draw a line in the sand. I rarely become this impassioned about something where it's either black or white with me. This is one those times. If you can sit there with a straight face and tell me you support Hamas and/or the Palestinian people who are mostly willing participants, I have zero desire to coexist with you.
Build It
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
https://www.ajc.org/news/meet-the-eight-american-hostages-still-held-by-hamas

Here are the forgotten Americans. Somehow we lost the balls to go get them.

1. Edan Alexander

Edan AlexanderEdan Alexander's sister Mika describes him as her best friend. Growing up in Tenafly, New Jersey, whenever any of their favorite artists put out a new album, Edan would grab the car keys and take his sister for a drive so they could analyze every song.

A happy-go-lucky guy, a champion swimmer for his high school team, and a big fan of the New York Knicks, Edan spent most of his young life in Tenafly. But he was born in Israel just a few months before his parents moved to the U.S. He spoke Hebrew at home and visited Israel often to see both sets of grandparents. He even celebrated his bar mitzvah there.

His mother, Yael, was surprised when Edan announced his senior year in high school that he wanted to postpone college and try Garin Tzabar, a program founded in 1991 for young Jewish adults who want to explore serving as lone soldiers in Israel's Defense Forces.

Edan and 16 other American high school graduates, including a classmate in Tenafly, moved to a kibbutz and did four months of training before committing to serve in the IDF. He returned for a visit home in August and expected to return again in April for his brother Roy's bar mitzvah.

He was on patrol at a kibbutz on the morning of October 7 and called his mother after the Hamas attacks began.

"I told him at the end of the call: 'Listen to me, Edan. I'm here. I'm with you. I love you. Just protect yourself. Just be safe,'" Yael recalled on AJC's podcast, People of the Pod. "And that's it, we hang up. I didn't know I'm not gonna hear from him again."



2. Itay Chen Z"L

Itay ChenItay Chen, 19, is the youngest American hostage in Hamas captivity. After months of holding out hope that their son would return, Chen's parents, Ruby and Hagit Chen, learned that he died on October 7 defending civilians living in an agricultural area near the Gaza border. His body is still being held by Hamas.

Born in the U.S., Itay grew up in Israel, in the city of Netanya, just north of Tel Aviv, but the family frequently visited his father's hometown of New York. He was a Boy Scout who played basketball and, like many teenagers, loved his PlayStation.

The fun-loving middle child, he was also the "life of the party" and the "connector" of their family, his father said. The only reason he was on duty that day was because he had switched weekends with another soldier so he could attend his brother's Bar Mitzvah the following week.



3. Sagui Dekel-Chen

Sagui Dekel-ChenAn avid fixer-upper who often repaired his farm equipment by hand, Sagui Dekel-Chen, 35, had been working in his machine shop 200 yards from his home when Hamas terrorists entered Kibbutz Nir Oz after sunrise on October 7.

He and a few others sent text messages warning neighbors to seek shelter from the gunmen in their safe rooms. He made sure his then-pregnant wife Avital and their two other daughters were safe inside a bomb shelter before confronting the terrorists. His wife heard him fighting off the terrorists when they broke into their home. She last heard from Sagui around 9:30 a.m. She gave birth to the couple's third daughter in December.

Hostages who returned home months ago say they saw Sagui alive in Gaza. The grandson of Holocaust survivors whose parents were raised in the U.S. but came to Israel to raise their family, Dekel-Chen was one of the few Israelis who knew how to play baseball, playing in Israel's junior national league as a kid.

"I'd love to share all kinds of photos: him as a little boy, as a baseball player," his father Jonathan told Slate. "A lot of the photos that we've had for Sagui and from my other kids and grandkids were burned on Oct. 7."



4. Hersh Goldberg-Polin

Hersh Goldberg-PolinHersh Goldberg-Polin, 23, was born in Berkeley, California, and moved to Israel with his parents and two other siblings at age 7. A quiet guy with a quick wit, he fervently believed in the possibility of peace and supported an Israeli soccer team that championed Arab and Jewish coexistence.

From a young age, Hersh also loved to read. Even at the age of 8, his parents, Rachel Goldberg and Jon Polin said on AJC's podcast People of the Pod that he could rattle off facts such as the details of every American president. Not long after that, he developed a fascination with atlases, maps, globes, and travel. He had planned a trip around the world, starting with a ticket to India in December.

His previous international excursion was a nine-week excursion through six European countries to attend a series of music festivals.

Three days before he was taken hostage, Hersh went to a music festival in northern Israel, but police closed it down for having the wrong permits. He returned home to celebrate Simchat Torah with his family and friends, then left at 11 p.m. to go to the Supernova desert festival.

He was last seen at a field shelter with others who tried to escape when Hamas terrorists descended on the festival after sunrise. Video footage captured him on the back of a truck, his left arm missing from the elbow down and wrapped in a tourniquet.

His mother last heard from her son that morning, when he sent two WhatsApp messages, one telling his parents he loved them, the other saying, "I'm sorry."



5. Gadi Haggai Z"L

Gadi Haggai Z"L"Here in the fields, we are full of fear. People are dying, and birds aren't flying."

Those prescient lyrics, composed in the 1980s by Gadi Haggai, capture the last moments of the musician's life on the morning of October 7. Haggai, 73, died face down in a field as Hamas rockets streaked across the sky and terrorists stormed his kibbutz, kidnapping and murdering its residents.

Haggai, 73 was a retired chef, jazz musician, father of four, grandfather of seven, exercise guru, and pacifist. During his mandatory military service, he served as the first flutist in the IDF orchestra.

After several years in the U.S. pursuing a jazz career, Haggai returned to Israel where he met his wife Judi, an American-Canadian volunteer. The couple founded their own jazz orchestra called the Jazz Union. Unable to support his wife and four children as a musician, he studied cooking and the family eventually moved to Kibbutz Nir Oz where Gadi served as chef.

Gadi and Judi had been on their daily stroll outside Kibbutz Nir Oz when rockets and gunfire tore through the early morning tranquility. Laying face down in the field, they called their daughter in Singapore to tell her what they saw. Shortly after, Haggai was shot by terrorists on a motorcycle. Paramedics tried to send an ambulance, but it was struck by a rocket en route. Though Israel confirmed his death in December, his body is still being held by Hamas.



6. Judith Weinstein Haggai Z"L

Judith Weinstein Haggai Z"LBorn in New York and raised in Toronto, Judi Weinstein Haggai, 70, made aliyah to Israel in 1976. There, she and her husband built a life around music, art, family, and healthy living. They ate a plant-based diet and walked every morning, which is why they were in a field near Kibbutz Nir Oz in the early morning hours of October 7.

Even after decades in Israel, Judi still added ing to every verb she spoke in Hebrew. English was the language in which she wrote and which she taught both Israeli and Palestinian students.

As the security situation along the Israel Gaza border deteriorated, Judi introduced mindfulness into her curriculum, to help her students cope with their anxieties. Following retirement, she continued helping children with anxiety through puppeteering.

In addition to her books of poetry, Judi practiced her own mindfulness by writing haikus, which she posted on her Facebook page daily. She posted her last verse on the morning of October 7.

"pulse accelerates

mind makes new connections

as Fall shows her face"

Judi called paramedics when her husband was shot that morning. But the ambulance never made it. Terrorists returned and shot Judi too. Her death was confirmed in December, six days after her husband's, but her body remains in Hamas captivity.



7. Omer Neutra

Omer NeutraOmer Neutra, 22, another grandson of Holocaust survivors, was born in Manhattan a month after the September 11, 2001 terror attacks, and more than a year after his parents immigrated from Israel.

A loyal Knicks fan, he knew the stats of every player, led the local chapter of the United Synagogue Youth group, and served as captain of the basketball, volleyball, and soccer teams at the Conservative Jewish school he attended from first grade until high school graduation.

After being accepted to Binghamton University in 2020 to study business and medicine, Omer decided to take a gap year in the country where his parents were raised and stayed, opting to serve in the Israel Defense Force's tank brigade.

When Hamas attacked, Omer's team drove two miles to the border, where Hamas militants ambushed his tank with rocket-propelled grenades.

Urge Congress to Continue Demanding the Release of ALL the Hostages
Join American Jewish Committee (AJC), the global advocacy organization for the Jewish people, in urging Congress to act to secure the immediate and unconditional release of all hostages.


8. Keith Siegel

Keith SiegelKeith Siegel, 64, originally from North Carolina, moved to Israel 40 years ago. He met Aviva, a kindergarten teacher originally from South Africa, and fell in love. They lived on Kibbutz Kfar Aza, close to the Gaza border, where he worked as an occupational therapist.

Keith's mother, Gladys, still lives in North Carolina in an assisted-living facility where the staff has shielded her from knowing that the youngest of her four children is a hostage.

Keith has four children of his own and five grandchildren. He is a calm person and an optimist and loves the outdoors.

On October 7, he and his wife were taken hostage and driven to Gaza in their car with a neighbor and her two children. Aviva was released on November 26 as part of a hostage-release deal. Keith remains, his ribs broken from being captured on October 7, his wife said.

"My parents have an innate faith in the goodness of humankind," his daughter Elan wrote on Fox News. "That is why, even after living through decades of conflict, they believe that peace can be reality … Their worldview can be summed up in the conviction that love of humanity will always defeat hatred."
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
nortex97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I am concerned they really haven't committed the quantity of troops/units to 'get the job done' and thus have to basically move from one part of Gaza to another. It's brutal work no doubt and I don't know how many soldiers with the skills to do this the IDF actually has/is currently equipped for, while also maintaining security up north etc.

UNRWA is (still) an evil organization:


Iranians getting pretty sloppy delivering weapons to Lebanon;
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
the IDF has roughly 170,000 troops in the regular standing Army- so imagine if 15,000 of them are in Gaza and you also have Lebanon border, Syrian border, West Bank, Jordanian border, Egyptian border.

they have another 470,000 reservists under the age of 45 but when you call them up that harms the economy.
First Page Last Page
Page 268 of 311
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.