StonewallAggieDEFENSE said:
txags92 said:
Not a Bot said:
I feel bad for people entering some professions that require a college degree but also don't pay very well.
Think about your local assistant prosecutors, public defenders, teachers (the good ones), social workers, etc.
These are very needed public service professions that are increasingly expensive to enter thanks to tuition increases but without much financial reward.
If there's any sort of debt forgiveness on the table, it should always be structured around public service.
I have zero interest in using my tax dollars or printing money to hand to people with gender studies degrees or other useless invented sociology indoctrination that doesn't do anything to serve society. Would much rather use my tax dollars and/or print money to give to people who are actually doing good for the community.
The reasons the tuition and fees have gone up so much are:
1) Because we have decoupled the value of the degree from the cost to get it by making student loans so easy to get and backing them with federal guarantees. If the banks funding the loans had to rely on people to actually pay them back, they would never make 90% of the loans they are making right now. If the banks will loan anything to anybody for any degree, why not raise the tuition and fees, because the students will just take out bigger loans to pay them.
and
2) With that "easy money" of higher tuition, colleges have gone on an orgy of hiring administrators and staff and propping up brand new departments and degree programs offering popular but worthless degrees to students willing to take out loans to pay for them. If you graph the cost of a college degree alongside the growth in administrative staff, the growth in administrative and faculty salaries, and the growth of student loan debt, they will match up really closely. But if you add a line showing the "value" of the average degree, you will see that it has not grown nearly as fast.
Easy solution. Take away federal backing for student loans and let the financial institutions take the risk on who they give loans to. The # and amount of loans will go WAY down. The universities and degree programs not offering good values for their degree costs will have banks unwilling to loan their students money to attend. Ultimately, the universities will have to reduce the costs back to a level that is commensurate with the value their degrees provide to the students, which will result in the elimination of a lot of useless administrators and shutting down departments and degree programs that can't demonstrate that their degrees are worth what they cost.
That's too unreliable. Make the college/universities loan "their" money to the students, payable in monthly increments from the paychecks the graduates earn from the job those degrees prepared them for. That should end the non-engineering,non-business, non-marketable skills bullsh*t degrees in a hurry.
I understand the sentiment on this board runs heavily against BA degrees, but I think it's a bit extreme to start and push for any policy that totally eliminates the arts. My history and language degrees have allowed me to contribute quite a bit to society and the protection of our country. Currently, I use them at work training officers and enlisted in our military on how to learn languages and how to interact with peoples and cultures around the world. Formerly I used my knowledge of the middle east and middle eastern languages to help kill terrorists. I'm fairly sure engineers and doctors can't do what I can do, and we've always needed people like me.
For context I took a BA in History and French before moving into Middle Eastern languages for my graduate work and then moving into military applications of my expertise. In your paradigm, I would have never been able to professionalize my skills in college.
ETA, I'm not excited about the existence of gender studies, race studies, etc. degrees, but once you go down the path of destruction of the arts, it's hard to draw the line. Are language degrees good? But music worthless? Who makes that call? I personally love music, it's one of the most beautiful things about the human race, our ability to make music, but yet the free market clearly doesn't value degrees in it. Should that be enough to cut music programs?