Zobel said:

---

You're obfuscating. You do that a lot. No one said anything about changing God. But those who are practicing sin, especially knowingly and in defiance of the teaching of the Church, should not approach the chalice or the altar.

When people say "being" gay they mean actively engaging in homosexual activities, not some kind of identifier that they have same sex attraction. If being a sinner barred us from the chalice no one would be there, so clearly that isn't what people are suggesting. But you knew that.

---