***** OFFICIAL A FEAST FOR BROS GAME OF THRONES BEST CHARACTER BRACKET *****

6,899 Views | 97 Replies | Last: 4 yr ago by Fat Bib Fortuna
Ol Jock 99
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


I had to rewatch to remind myself how brilliant it was. Absolutely perfect scene. The music, the setting, the mutilating of Loras, the struggle of Lancel, the death of GM Pycelle, the realizing of Margery, the arrogance turned doubt of the High Sparrow. And deathly brooding of Cersei. Sadly, this one cuts off before Toman's exclamation mark.

Simply brilliant.

Then the dog shat upon the floor.

Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Just checked the results for the first time since Friday - pushing 100 total votes. Two matchups currently separated by 1 vote, and another separated by 3. Will probably call it around 10 or 11 p.m. tonight so if you haven't voted this is your chance.
ChipFTAC01
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Cercei's sniff of her wine before she drinks it is perfect.
Urban Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ol Jock 99 said:



I had to rewatch to remind myself how brilliant it was. Absolutely perfect scene. The music, the setting, the mutilating of Loras, the struggle of Lancel, the death of GM Pycelle, the realizing of Margery, the arrogance turned doubt of the High Sparrow. And deathly brooding of Cersei. Sadly, this one cuts off before Toman's exclamation mark.

Simply brilliant.

Then the dog shat upon the floor.


IMO, literally one of the greatest moments in TV history. And the music, again IMO, is the greatest part.
Southlake
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Where's Roz?
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ROUND 1 SHOCKER: DOWN GOES CERSEI (THAT'S WHAT SHE SAID)

In a smug reversal of fortune, all-time survivor and Witch that starts with a 'B' Cersei Lannister, the #3 seed in the King's Landing Region was upset by #14 seed and serious hottie Margarey of House Tyrell, whose trio of husbands included two teenagers and the most fabulously-dressed Baratheon brother ever.

The final count was 52% Tyrell, 48% Lannister. Cersei was the highest seed to lose in the first round.

Other higher seeds dropping in the first round were Jaquen H'gar, the #6 seed Across the Sea, who had his many faces burned off by Drogon & Company 51%-49%.

Also tumbling was #7 Broken Thing seeded Berric Dondarrion who has the coolest voice of any person ever falling easily to #10 red-headed wildling Ygritte 64%-36%.

Two 9 seeds took out their 8 seed matchups as well. Varys crushed the Mountain 74%-26% while Melisandre burned Missandei 58%-42%.

The biggest margin victory makes Ned Stark wonder WTF happened to you guys sense of honor, as you overwhelming gave a free pass to noted slaver and absentee-lord of Bear Island, Jorah Mormont, who cut off Loras Tyrell's ... chances with 98% of the vote.

Barely avoiding the first-round upset, your King! Bran the Broken, who beat Syrio Forel 51%-49%.

Round 2 is now open! VOTE HERE

The Matchups

#1 Tyrion Lannister vs. #9 Varys - things got a little heated the last time these two met. As did Varys's corpse.

#2 Jamie Lannister vs. #7 Olenna "The Queen of Thorns" Tyrell - wow, 2 straight matchups where one person was directly responsible for the other person's death.

#6 Petyr "Littlefinger" Baelish vs. #14 Margarey Tyrell Barratheon Barratheon Barratheon - doesn't take a maester to figure out what Petyr would like to do with the Littlefinger in this matchup.

#4 Tywin Lannister vs. #5 Bronn - two very likable a-holes


#1 Daenerys Stormborn vs. #9 Melisandre - I've given a lot of thought to this matchup. Sometimes, the two of them get caught outside in a rainstorm and have to huddle together for warmth; sometimes it's like 3 a.m. and Dany can't sleep and is listening to "I Need You Now" by Lady Antebellum and just starts blowing up Melisandre's phone like "YO GET YOUR ASSHAI OVER HERE, WITCH". Trust me, there's never a loser when these two get together.

#2 Jorah Mormont vs. #7 Theon Greyjoy - 2 disgraces to the family name who get offed protecting the home of Ned Stark, who tried to execute one and kept the other as a thinly-veiled prisoner for 10 years.

#3 Khal Drogo vs. #11 The Dragons - The 2 great loves of Dany's life when she wasn't banging her nephew.

#4 Grey Worm vs. #5 Barristan Selmy - It should have been you dying in that alley, Grey Worm! There are 5,000 guys like you, but only one Barristan the Bold!!!

#1 Arya Stark vs. #8 Benjen Stark - One killed the Night King, one was mostly dead for 7.99 seasons.

#2 Ned Stark vs. #7 Hodor! - A big idiot who kept tripping over his own feet and screwing things up vs. Hodor

#3 Sansa Stark vs. #6 Brienne of Tarth - soundtrack by the Jonas Brothers

#4 Bran Stark vs. #5 Robb Stark - Ya know Robb, if you could have kept it in your pants that first season as king, that could have been you banging Emilia Clarke.

#1 Jon Snow vs. #8 Stannis Baratheon - Who can grit their teeth for longer?

#2 Sandor "The Hound" Clegane vs. #10 Ygritte - Both kissed by fire, not quite the same result.

#3 Tormund Giantsbane vs. #6 Davos Seaworth - Great roadtrip comedy in the making.

#4 Oberyn Martell vs. #5 Samwise Tarly - Fighting wise, this is like Jar Jar Binks taking on Darth Maul. But there are lot more people who can identify with Sam than with Oberyn on this board.


Round 1 Results
#1 Tyrion Lannister vs. #16 Grand Maester Pycelle 97%-3%
#2 Jamie Lannister vs. #15 Tommen Baratheon 97%-3%
#3 Cersei Lannister vs. #14 Margarey Tyrell Barratheon Barratheon Barratheon 48%-52%
#4 Tywin Lannister vs. #13 Robert Baratheon 61%-39%
#5 Bronn vs. #12 Joffrey Baratheon 83%-17%
#6 Petyr "Littlefinger" Baelish vs. #11 Podrick "Insane in the Mem" Payne 68%-32%
#7 Olenna "The Queen of Thorns" Tyrell vs. #10 Qyburn 89%-11%
#8 The Mountain vs. #9 Varys 26%-74%

#1 Daenerys Stormborn vs. #16 Euron Greyjoy 93%-7%
#2 Jorah Mormont vs. #15 Loras Tyrell 98%-2%
#3 Khal Drogo vs. #14 Viserys Targaryen 96%-4%
#4 Grey Worm vs. #13 Renly Baratheon 84%-16%
#5 Barristan Selmy vs. #12 Yara Greyjoy 63%-37%
#6 Jaqen H'gar vs. #11 The Dragons 49%-51%
#7 Theon Greyjoy vs. #10 Dario Naharis 58%-42%
#8 Missandei vs. #9 Melisandre 42%-58%

#1 Arya Stark vs. #16 JoJen Reed 94%-6%
#2 Ned Stark vs. #15 Meera Reed 97%-3%
#3 Sansa Stark vs. #14 Catelyn Stark 83%-17%
#4 Bran Stark vs. #13 Syrio Forel 51%-49%
#5 Robb Stark vs. #12 Lyana Mormont 57%-43%
#6 Brienne of Tarth vs. #11 Gendry Barratheon 80%-20%
#7 Hodor! vs. #10 Ramsey Bolton 67%-33%
#8 Benjen Stark vs. #9 Roose Bolton 67%-33%

#1 Jon Snow vs. #16 Walder Frey 97%-3%
#2 Sandor "The Hound" Clegane vs. #15 Hot Pie 97%-3%
#3 Tormund Giantsbane vs. #14 Ser Alliser Thorne 93%-7%
#4 Oberyn Martell vs. #13 Wun Wun the Giant 77%-23%
#5 Samwise Tarly vs. #12 Lord Commander Mormont 68%-32%
#6 Davos Seaworth vs. #11 Mance Rayder 88%-12%
#7 Berric Dondarrion vs. #10 Ygritte 36%-64%
#8 Stannis Baratheon vs. #9 Dolorous Edd 68%-32%




































































Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Return to work bump!

Round 2 is now open! VOTE HERE
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Southlake said:

Where's Roz?
Her name has three letters, but you still spelled it wrong.
[url=https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/04/04/ros-esme-bianco-when-i-died-on-game-of-thrones][/url]
Ros talks about her death on GoT.
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG

Quote:

Margarey Tyrell Barratheon Lannister Lannister Lannister Lannister
FIFY
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
She got married 5 times?
Duncan Idaho
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Due to how horrible this show finished, the only ranking that matters is "who had the best tits on the show?"

Ros is clearly the answer.


Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Duncan Idaho said:

Due to how horrible this show finished, the only ranking that matters is "who had the best tits on the show?"

Ros is clearly the answer.



Sounds like you need to design your own bracket!
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The joke is that Joffrey and Tommen were Lannisters on both sides.
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I hate that Davos and Tormund are facing off this early. Ugh.
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Brian Earl Spilner said:

I hate that Davos and Tormund are facing off this early. Ugh.
bearamedic99
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ditto.

Melisandre will always get my vote
Urban Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Tormund vs. Davos.

You will find little joy in this world Jon Snow.

- Beric
Urban Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
aggietony2010 said:

It went from a 10 to an 8.5 from end of season 6 to s8e3.

The last 3 episodes made me never want to watch it again.
I highly recommend a rewatch and if you have to cut it off after S6 or 7 so be it. I get it.

But just re-watching S1, at least for me, is amazing and such a great reminder as to why so many millions around the world fell in love with this show while the writers still had the books to work with. You absolutely hate Jamie early on. The development of his character in both the books and the series is simply remarkable. Just one example.
CoachRTM
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

#3 Tormund Giantsbane vs. #6 Davos Seaworth - Great roadtrip comedy in the making.


By far the hardest one for me this week. I love both of these characters.
aggietony2010
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I started watching during Season 4.

I re-watched it in its entirety every time in the lead-up to the new season, with one more re-watch during the long winter between seasons 7 and 8. I think 500 hours of my life is enough to have devoted to consuming this universe.

Let's just say this, I'll rewatch it when TWOW hits the shelves.

To not completely derail this thread, I saw the Margaery over Cersei upset coming from a mile away. Absolutely brutal matchup, especially in an arena that is going to play favorites to the attractive mid-majors.
God save the Patriarchy!
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Urban Ag said:

aggietony2010 said:

It went from a 10 to an 8.5 from end of season 6 to s8e3.

The last 3 episodes made me never want to watch it again.
I highly recommend a rewatch and if you have to cut it off after S6 or 7 so be it. I get it.

But just re-watching S1, at least for me, is amazing and such a great reminder as to why so many millions around the world fell in love with this show while the writers still had the books to work with. You absolutely hate Jamie early on. The development of his character in both the books and the series is simply remarkable. Just one example.
I remember feeling the same way about Tyrion while reading Book 1 - you love when Catelyn Stark entraps him at the inn and takes him prisoner because you're convinced he had a hand in Bran's injury; then you cackle with laughter when he uses Bronn to win his trial by combat and escape; all within about 100 pages.

Jaime was my favorite character by the time the books ended.
Urban Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Many consider book four to be the worst of the series, the dullest, most droll. I found Jamie's seemingly endless march about the Riverlands to be an absolutely intriguing deep dive in to the mind of a very troubled fictional character. And I think that only someone who has dealt with some deep seated confliction in their life could write that character.
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Urban Ag said:

Many consider book four to be the worst of the series, the dullest, most droll. I found Jamie's seemingly endless march about the Riverlands to be an absolutely intriguing deep dive in to the mind of a very troubled fictional character. And I think that only someone who has dealt with some deep seated confliction in their life could write that character.
I agree 100%. I was so pleased when they left him negotiating with the Blackfish in the show and I love how he deals with the Blackwoods vs. Brackens. After he loses his hand, he becomes much more like his father in terms of the strategy of "defeating your opponents, then helping them stand back up."
et98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This show had lots of "old bearded white guy with an accent" (OBWGWAA) who all kind of looked & acted the same, even if they were fighting on different sides. There are a few exceptions, but I'm mostly voting for the characters who were more unique and stood out, even if I absolutely hated them.

It's why I voted in the 1st round for Yara over Barristan Selmy, Joffrey over Bronn, & Ygritte over Dondarrion
and in the 2nd round: Theon over Jorah, Grey Worm over Selmy, and Hodor over Ned

Also, Ramsey Bolton got robbed in the 1st round because he faced another interesting character in Hodor, while Benjen basically got a bye when he faced off against a fellow OBWGWAA in Roose Bolton.

Others who got robbed due to seeding: Cersei, Joffrey, Missandei, and Lyana Mormont.

For the record, the OBWGWAAs that I'm OK voting for are Grand Maester Pycelle, Bronn (if facing another OBWGWAA), Tywin (if facing another OBWGWAA), Walder Frey, and Davos Seaworth, even though half of them lost in the 1st round and probably should have due to the seeding.

So in the 2nd round, Tywin vs. Bronn should be close, but I wished they would've faced someone more interesting than each other.

Oh, and anyone facing Robb Stark should win. It should've been Lyana Mormont in the 1st round, and I hope Bran pulls it off in the 2nd round (and then promptly loses in the next round). In my bracket, Bran would lose to just about anyone other than an OBWGWAA or Robb Stark.
MSFC Aggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Brian Earl Spilner said:

I hate that Davos and Tormund are facing off this early. Ugh.

Agreed. But it will be nearly impossible for me to vote against Tormund.
Brian Earl Spilner
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
As much as I love Tormund, I just can't vote against Ser Davos. I refuse.

He deserved the Iron Throne over anyone in the Seven Kingdoms.
Urban Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

This show had lots of "old bearded white guy with an accent" (OBWGWAA) who all kind of looked & acted the same, even if they were fighting on different sides.

well we definitely have diverging views here
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
et98 said:

This show had lots of "old bearded white guy with an accent" (OBWGWAA) who all kind of looked & acted the same, even if they were fighting on different sides. There are a few exceptions, but I'm mostly voting for the characters who were more unique and stood out, even if I absolutely hated them.

It's why I voted in the 1st round for Yara over Barristan Selmy, Joffrey over Bronn, & Ygritte over Dondarrion
and in the 2nd round: Theon over Jorah, Grey Worm over Selmy, and Hodor over Ned

Also, Ramsey Bolton got robbed in the 1st round because he faced another interesting character in Hodor, while Benjen basically got a bye when he faced off against a fellow OBWGWAA in Roose Bolton.

Others who got robbed due to seeding: Cersei, Joffrey, Missandei, and Lyana Mormont.

For the record, the OBWGWAAs that I'm OK voting for are Grand Maester Pycelle, Bronn (if facing another OBWGWAA), Tywin (if facing another OBWGWAA), Walder Frey, and Davos Seaworth, even though half of them lost in the 1st round and probably should have due to the seeding.

So in the 2nd round, Tywin vs. Bronn should be close, but I wished they would've faced someone more interesting than each other.

Oh, and anyone facing Robb Stark should win. It should've been Lyana Mormont in the 1st round, and I hope Bran pulls it off in the 2nd round (and then promptly loses in the next round). In my bracket, Bran would lose to just about anyone other than an OBWGWAA or Robb Stark.
Southlake
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MuckRaker96 said:

Southlake said:

Where's Roz?
Her name has three letters, but you still spelled it wrong.
[url=https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/04/04/ros-esme-bianco-when-i-died-on-game-of-thrones][/url]
Ros talks about her death on GoT.
Well, if I'd had 2 edits maybe I coulda got it right, so there!

And, even tho Theon might have been a more compelling character, I'm picking Jorrah(OMWRB) in a close upset...

And I misspelled Jorrah with 3 edits just for you....
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jorah is the #2 seed, it's not an upset.
AtlAg05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Bran over Syrio?! What is wrong with you people?!
Worst bracket ever!



Did I do that right?
The Dog Lord
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
CoachRTM said:

Quote:

#3 Tormund Giantsbane vs. #6 Davos Seaworth - Great roadtrip comedy in the making.


By far the hardest one for me this week. I love both of these characters.

Oberyn vs. Sam was a close second
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You want to make a Westerosi omelette, you gotta break a few eggs!


Making the bracket really makes me miss the weekly buildup to the great episodes and discussing them at work and online. I read the books by a twist of fate before the show started. My wife had never heard of it before the Red Wedding, then it blew up her Facebook so much she had to see what it is. We binged the first few seasons over a month or 2 and she was a die-hard for the rest of the time.

I got to go see GGRM talk at Rudder back in March 2013, were any of you there? Those of us that were got to watch the Season 3 premiere 9 days early. Let that sink in in terms of how huge the show eventually got. NINE DAYS EARLY.

Also makes me think that 6 years ago I had no frikkin' idea who Pedro Pascal was, and now he played one of my top 5 GoT characters, an incredible Star Wars character, and appears on his way to playing a great DC villain.

Ag 11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Are the books worth the read? I enjoyed the show except for the last season. I've heard they are quite different though
Fat Bib Fortuna
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Long Live Old Bearded White Guys with an accent!


Tuesday's second round validated the truth that most TexAgs members use as their life's mantra: Old Bearded White Guys with Accents are the best thing since wildfire.
Team Beard put 11 people into the Sweet 16. That is a lot of ****ing beards.

The upsets on the day were not severely as before. Another #3, Sansa Stark, fell to Brienne of ****ing Tarth 52%-48%. Sansa wasn't the only Stark going down on Tuesday (now there's an image in your head). Bran the Broken dun got broke by the only actor to have played the love interest of both Cinderella and Elton John in the same decade. Robb Stark has gotten farther in this tournament than he did on the show.

Third-seeded Khal Drogo also took a dive. His performance against the Dragons was almost as disappointing as Aquaman; he fell 57%-43%. The new set of matchups will be coming your way post haste.


Tuesday's Results

#1 Tyrion Lannister vs. #9 Varys 86%-14%
#2 Jamie Lannister vs. #7 Olenna "The Queen of Thorns" Tyrell 72%-28%
#6 Petyr "Littlefinger" Baelish vs. #14 Margarey Tyrell 56%-44%
#4 Tywin Lannister vs. #5 Bronn 37%-63%


#1 Daenerys Stormborn vs. #9 Melisandre 78%-22%
#2 Jorah Mormont vs. #7 Theon Greyjoy 75%-25%
#3 Khal Drogo vs. #11 The Dragons 43%-57%
#4 Grey Worm vs. #5 Barristan Selmy 31%-69%


#1 Arya Stark vs. #8 Benjen Stark 92%-8%
#2 Ned Stark vs. #7 Hodor 80%-20%
#3 Sansa Stark vs. #6 Brienne of Tarth 48%-52%
#4 Bran Stark vs. #5 Robb Stark 23%-77%

#1 Jon Snow vs. #8 Stannis Baratheon 97%-3%
#2 Sandor "The Hound" Clegane vs. #10 Ygritte 77%-23%
#3 Tormund Giantsbane vs. #6 Davos Seaworth 56%-44%
#4 Oberyn Martell vs. #5 Samwise Tarly 69%-31%
Page 2 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.