According to the article you linked a couple dozen trolls out of almost 10k signatures is hardly worth dismissing the rest of the legitimate ones.

AgDev01 said:

---

According to the article you linked a couple dozen trolls out of almost 10k signatures is hardly worth dismissing the rest of the legitimate ones.

---

AgDev01 said:

---

According to the article you linked a couple dozen trolls out of almost 10k signatures is hardly worth dismissing the rest of the legitimate ones.

---

Don't forget all the massage therapist as well.

nai06 said:

---

AgDev01 said:

---

According to the article you linked a couple dozen trolls out of almost 10k signatures is hardly worth dismissing the rest of the legitimate ones.

---

Don't forget all the massage therapist as well.

---

So what about the actual article do you disagree with?

dermdoc said:

---

nai06 said:

---

AgDev01 said:

---

According to the article you linked a couple dozen trolls out of almost 10k signatures is hardly worth dismissing the rest of the legitimate ones.

---

Don't forget all the massage therapist as well.

---

So what about the actual article do you disagree with?

---

Derm - I agree with you 100% on this but this is argumentative discourse in the era of Trump - if you have no good argument, ridicule the other side. Our President has turned it into an art.

Quote:

---

You mean the same Great Barrington Declaration signed by thousands of doctors and scientists?

People like Dr. Johnny Bananas. Dr. IP Freely, Dr. Person Fakename, and my personal favorite Dr. Harold Shipman. Shipman was a serial killer who murdered over 200 of his patients (he died in 2004).

---

This. The Great Barrington Declaration was denounced in The Lancet...THE most prominent journal in the field of medicine.

And Scott Atlas's social media posts are becoming increasingly unhinged, and adding to the mounting speculation that he's absolutely unfit for the position he (unfortunately) occupies.

That the same Lancet that published the "peer reviewed" paper based on data from Surgisphere?

Of course, the strongest affirmation of how correct The Great Barrington Declaration experts are was, is, and will continue to be Sweden.

Quote:

---

https://themarketherald.com.au/sweden-walks-from-lockdown-approach-to-covid-19-as-cases-surge-2020-10-23/amp/

---

Yeah Sweden's doing great.

Their 7 day moving average of deaths per day is one.

nai06 said:

---

Keegan99 said:

---

Depends on which experts.

The Great Barrington Declaration experts generally agree with his assessment.

As a reminder, the lockdowns that Fauci and Birx and others have advocated for were part of NO plan for a moderate flu pandemic, and were specifically advised AGAINST.

---

You mean the same Great Barrington Declaration signed by thousands of doctors and scientists?

People like Dr. Johnny Bananas. Dr. IP Freely, Dr. Person Fakename, and my personal favorite Dr. Harold Shipman. Shipman was a serial killer who murdered over 200 of his patients (he died in 2004).



https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/520961-white-house-officials-promote-herd-immunity-declaration-signed-by-fake

https://news.sky.com/story/coronavirus-dr-johnny-bananas-and-dr-person-fakename-among-medical-signatories-on-herd-immunity-open-letter-12099947

---

Do you and the people who starred that post really think that's at all a relevant criticism of the Declaration?

The significance of it is who authored it: three of the most eminent scientists in their field.

Citing to some troll names signing the online petition supporting it as some type of rebuttal is not just disingenuous, but silly.

Do better.

A lot of "Doctor" Atlas's former colleagues in the medical profession seem to have recognized him for what he is, pretty early on.


https://www.cnbc.com/2020/09/10/stanford-medical-faculty-lambaste-former-colleague-and-trump-coronavirus-advisor-dr-scott-atlas.html

And yet those colleagues - overwhelmingly Democrat donors - stoop to attacking Dr. Atlas and eschew a discussion of the underlying science and policy. Telling.

The Great Barrington Declaration authors have challenged these charlatans - these lockdown advocates, trashing decades of established policy on pandemic management - to debates, and they refuse.

If their ideas are so plainly superior, why their unwillingness to an open public discussion?

Oh, and it's Dr. Atlas, not "Doctor".

Was it really necessary to quote that long ass post?

Why do in God's name people do this?

Why??

I know I'd spring for the PPV to to watch Dr. Scott Atlas debate Dr. Johnny Bananas.