I've recently gone deep down this rabbit hole recently and while I haven't pulled the trigger on one yet, I've settled in on the Weber genesis. The napoleon rogue line was the runner up, but the Weber won out on for easier cleanup and better parts availability as well as just appearing to be overall a better build. Go to your local backyard BBQ retailer instead of a box store to get a better model. The Weber spirit would probably work just fine, but why skimp on something that will probably last you the next 15 years at least