Movies that depict the US Military accurately

4,020 Views | 26 Replies | Last: 1 yr ago by ArmyAg2002
Andrew Dufresne
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Looking for recommendations from former service members on flicks that you feel portray things in a realistic manner.

This can be fiction or non-fiction btw.

TIA to any suggestions
OldArmyCT
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Nothing about Vietnam.
bigtruckguy3500
How long do you want to ignore this user?
OldArmyCT said:

Nothing about Vietnam.


I thought We Were Soldiers was pretty good.
clarythedrill
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Platoon.
CT'97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'm not sure there are any movies that get everything correct because they are movies and if they did they would be boring and unwatchable. There are those that get some things correct.

Generation Kill gets day to day life of an enlisted infantryman pretty correct. There are problems but it gets a lot right.

Greyhound gets life on board a WW2 destroyer during an Atlantic crossing pretty accurate from several Naval experts I know.

Both Band of Brothers and Pacific get it pretty close. They of course follow real life accounts so have a lot of reality to base the series on and Tom Hanks went to pretty extreme lengths to get the little things right.
Trench55
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just watched "Danger Close: The Battle of Long Tan." It is a depiction of the Australian army in Vietnam. It comes the closest I've seen showing the role of field artillery in Vietnam. Based on what I've read about the battle, it is probably as accurate as a movie can come to actual history.
Rabid Cougar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Hornets Nest - Afghanistan Documentary. Operation Strong Eagle III Kunar 2011.
I am not a veteran but I had an up close and personal experience with this operation.
Aggie12B
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Restrepo (documentary)
The Hornet's Nest (documentary)
Dealin' (documentary about the Battle of Wanat, Afghanistan)
The Outpost (about the Battle of Kamdesh, Afghanistan)
Megan Leavey (pretty accurate portrayal of the bond between Dog handlers and their working dogs)
Danger Close; the Battle of Long Tan
Hell And Back, Again (documentary about Afghanistan and a wounded Sgt's return home after being Medevac'd out of Afghanistan)
Gunner Palace
Thank You For Your Service (a very realistic portrayal of what a lot of service members experience after coming home from combat)
We Were Soldiers
Full Metal Jacket (just the basic training part)

maverick2076
How long do you want to ignore this user?
They Shall Not Grow Old. Not the US military, but still accurate…since it's all real footage.
Claude!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Not a former service member myself, but my brother said that Gunner Palace (2004 documentary) is pretty accurate to his experiences elsewhere in Iraq.
Martin Cash
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Stripes
rgleml
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
That's a fact jack. What kind of training? Army training, sir!
Jock 07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Martin Cash said:

Stripes

Damnit, beat me to it.
Kyle98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Trench55 said:

Just watched "Danger Close: The Battle of Long Tan." It is a depiction of the Australian army in Vietnam. It comes the closest I've seen showing the role of field artillery in Vietnam. Based on what I've read about the battle, it is probably as accurate as a movie can come to actual history.
Watched it last night thanks to this post. Thought it was pretty well done. Curious about the accuracy of some parts, but there are always some things changed for dramatic effect.
Aggie13B
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HBOs "Generation Kill", gave the best view of an average enlisted persons life. I wasn't in the invasion of Iraq nor was I a marine but the same BS they dealt with and the same stupid and asinine conversations between dudes in the same humvee was pretty spot on. My first deployment was the surge in 2007 and after watching Generstion Kill several years later that very well could have been my platoon and the vehicle I rode in on screen.

Now I can't speak to the accuracy of the invasion or what they saw in combat just the interactions amongst the people.
bigtruckguy3500
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The first season of Space Force on Netflix is a great depiction of military bureaucracy.
Aggie13B
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Shame they pulled the plug on Space Force. I enjoyed it tremendously.
Trench55
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Not sure how the Aussies were organized re: their artillery, but I would bet the U.S would have had a battalion firing instead of the single battery depicted. That's assuming that there was a battalion within range. But then I remember the time I had to fire close support (and Danger Close) with my battery of 175mm guns.
Kyle98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Trench55 said:

Not sure how the Aussies were organized re: their, but I would bet the had a battlalion firing instead of the single battery dipicted. But then I remember the time I had to fire close sopport (and Danger Close) with my battery of 175mm guns.
At one point they were doing regimental fire missions.
Rabid Cougar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Aggie13B said:

HBOs "Generation Kill", gave the best view of an average enlisted persons life. I wasn't in the invasion of Iraq nor was I a marine but the same BS they dealt with and the same stupid and asinine conversations between dudes in the same humvee was pretty spot on. My first deployment was the surge in 2007 and after watching Generstion Kill several years later that very well could have been my platoon and the vehicle I rode in on screen.

Now I can't speak to the accuracy of the invasion or what they saw in combat just the interactions amongst the people.
I had the experience of watching this series and then traveling to the battlefield, much like watching the Gettysburg movie then visiting Gettysburg National Battlefield.

Was at Talil in 2009 and ran the roads (Highway 1/ MSR Tampa ) and Route 8 and 7 (AKA "Ambush Alley") the routes that Task Force Tarawa took through Nasiriya on a daily basis. Traveled the exact route that Jessica Lynch and the 507th Maintenance Company took through the city and met their eventual demise. Also went right by the hospital she was rescued from.

You could easily see the why the Marines took such heavy losses with their LVTP-7s.

Traveled Route 7 north all the way to Al Hay.. exact same route the 1st Recon Marines took in the series.

The series got the scenery about as close as you could get to the actual locations. On Route 7 north to Al Hay it is scrub brush desert similar to the high basins in Colorado and Wyoming with lots of irrigation canals, thus lots of farming. Very unlike the sea of sand south of Nasiriya towards Basra on Tampa.

The banter back in forth in the trucks is spot on with what I witnessed. My experience was not Marines but a Massachusetts National Guard company from Boston with fill-ins from Tennessee and Georgia in Afghanistan. The differences in the dialects alone was hilarious let alone the topics of discussion and "the stupid and asinine conversations". Yep, that statement pretty much nailed it.


Hey Nav
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Not quite realistic combat action films, but my recs:

The Great Santini. (pretty autobiographical, the novel written by Pat Conroy). It's an emotional story of a Marine pilot and his family, especially his oldest son. I enjoyed it as I was a child of an Air Force father, and I was the father of daughters when I was Air Force. It was also a film that Hank Hill rented at least 18 times :-)

Another film based on a Conroy novel is Lords of Discipline - based on experiences at The Citadel. It's not "military" yet is about life in their Corps. The Citadel was not too happy with this movie.

Twelve O'Clock High. An excellent study in the demands of leadership during a very bloody war. The special effects are from the 1940s.

Rabid Cougar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Sat with my 80 year old father in a hospital waiting room for 12 hours yesterday and discussed this topic...

His recommendations were:

The Blue Max (1966)
Hamburger Hill (1959) Robert Mitcham
Bridges at Toko Ri (1954)
BAT-21 (1988) Note : The movie was made before the actions of the actual hero of the operation who earned the Medal of Honor were declassified. There is no mention of him in the movie.
Trench55
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just one observation here. I know that some combat veterans have said that there are films that more accurately depict the horrors of combat better than others, e.g. the first 20 or so minutes of "Saving Private Ryan." And that is true as far as it goes. But no movie can give the audience the true experience of combat, since the audience is merely observing the events on the screen, regardless of how horrifying the events are shown, and not facing the real danger of receiving return fire from an enemy doing their best to try to kill you.
$3 Sack of Groceries
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My Vietnam vet father was always very partial to Hamburger Hill (1987) in terms of the relationships of the Joes and their disdain of the news media covering the war.
Rabid Cougar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rabid Cougar said:

Sat with my 80 year old father in a hospital waiting room for 12 hours yesterday and discussed this topic...

His recommendations were:

The Blue Max (1966)
Hamburger Hill (1959) Robert Mitcham
Bridges at Toko Ri (1954)
BAT-21 (1988) Note : The movie was made before the actions of the actual hero of the operation who earned the Medal of Honor was declassified. There is no mention of him in the movie.
Pork Chop Hill- the other white meat.
Eliminatus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bigtruckguy3500 said:

OldArmyCT said:

Nothing about Vietnam.


I thought We Were Soldiers was pretty good.


It was.

I encourage everyone though not familiar with the battle to read the actual book. I know money, time, and let's face it, optics dictated the movie but it only depicted half the battle. It's honestly a little sad knowing that a sister battalion was trying to reach them the whole time on the ground and ended up getting butchered as parts of it were overrun. Horribly. Battlefield torture and executions level. And very few know of their story and sacrifices.
ArmyAg2002
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
In the Army now.
Reservist that thought they were signing up for 1 weekend a month and 2 weeks a year.
Deployed and given a job they're not trained for.
Somehow actually manage to do job while arguing about who has to be in charge.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.