I've watched with great interest the many and varied comments concerning both the green tabs and the cords worn by our cadets today. Hopefully I can shed a little bit of light on what exactly has occurred and why. But I will say that several people on this thread have been very eloquent - and accurate - with respect to the impact of both green tabs and cords in our Corps.
First, we decided to go with green tabs for all leaders - from ASLs to the Corps Commander - to instill some pride and recognition in those who truly lead others in our Corps. It was also an attempt to combat apathy among those cadets - especially white belts - who felt they had no leadership position and thus basically "quit" and did the bare minimum they could while in the Corps. In many cases we had cadets who felt they were "non-leaders" not going to formation, not going to PT, and in some cases, not going to Corps march-ins and football games. It was simply unacceptable to have cadets feeling that they no longer had to participate simply because they felt they were not "leaders." The mindset was, "the only one who wears the green tabs is the Commander, and if you're not the Commander, you're not really a leader in the Corps." It was a backward and irresponsible way to view leadership in the Corps, and we realized early on that we needed to fix it.
We instituted the green tabs for ALL cadets who lead other cadets basically from the Army's system of having leaders of soldiers wear green tabs. We instituted the system 3 years ago, and its been a huge success. Cadets take pride in wearing their green tabs, recognizing them as those who directly lead other cadets, and its proven very successful - along with the Platoon System for all units - in helping to combat the apathy that was rampant in the Corps when I first got here. Its not perfect, and we still have to fight apathy all the time, but its a huge step in the right direction, and our cadets have taken it and owned it. Commanders have the authority to remove green tabs from those cadets not meeting the standard, and that has proven very effective also. The bottom line is that now all cadets wearing green tabs know they are leaders, accept that responsibility, and fully understand that they must lead well or risk losing their position and their tabs. Its been far more successful than I ever anticipated.
When I got here as Commandant I too felt that the Corps had over-proliferated cords, and 2 years ago we cut back on over half of them. Charlie Brown is correct - most of the cords listed by 740A are no longer worn by cadets. Again, I'm not sure we'll ever have a perfect system of awards and decorations, but in my opinion, after 31 years of military service, if a cord, ribbon, badge, or even a coin can make a soldier or cadet perform better, or instill pride in them and what they and their fellow soldiers/cadets have achieved, then I'm ok with that.
I knew soldiers who would go to hell and back for you for a coin or just a pat on the back and a "you done good" in front of his buddies, and our cadets are no different. We've cut back a lot on cords and other decorations in the time I've been here, but I still firmly believe that a little positive recognition goes a LONG way when it comes to soldiers and cadets. And if it helps them perform better, helps instill pride in them, their unit, and their Corps, then I'm all for it. You can say its all about this generation feeling "entitled," but I wear a chest full of medals, ribbons and badges that I EARNED over 31 years of military service, and I'm PROUD to wear them, and I was proud to have received them. This generation is no different, and I'll gladly award them with a ribbon, a badge, a cord, or even a coin for a job well done if they've earned it, if it helps make them better cadets, and if it helps instill pride in them and their unit. You don't have to agree, but I would argue that it works in our military today, and it also works in our Corps today - for all the RIGHT reasons.
One last point: I couldn't agree more with Tomb Daddy about the unit at Carson. Not only a stupid decision by that Cdr, but I can't believe that a Division Cdr would allow that to happen. Its not about "look at me." Its about treating soldiers right, and rewarding them for a job well done. Seriously, something as small as an Army Achievement Medal, Army Commendation Medal, or even a Good Conduct Medal is a problem for our Army?? Not in the Army I was in. I wonder how many of those officers at Carson wear their uniforms for promotion boards with no awards, ribbons, badges, or other decorations they've been awarded? And I wonder how our 7 MOH recipients would feel about that policy? Absolute idiocy, and I can't believe anyone would allow Army leaders to do that to our soldiers. Our soldiers - many of whom are combat vets with multiple deployments today - deserve better.
I hope this clears things up concerning the issue that started this thread. Again, you don't have to agree, but at least now you know the rationale behind the decision. I appreciate your love and passion for our Corps.
Thanks and Gig 'em!