Wife and I are going away for 5 days later this year, any tips?

Wife is pregnant so other than a glass of wine, all inclusive not necessary. We've been looking and thinking about Margaritaville just so we don't have to venture out too far to do stuff. We'd like to jot rent a car.

Fishing options seemed really limited. Like 3 charter companies to choose from?

Is it worth paying for one of those snorkeling trips? Or can you just jump in and see the same thing?

You should stay at Secret Harbour. It has a great restaurant, beautiful beach. There is a reef off the beach to the left and you can rent gear etc and see a lot. Margaritaville has a bad beach. Bring bug spray.

As soon as you get to St Thomas, get on a ferry and head to St John.

^ THIS!