Labor Talks/ Holdout Discussion

10,113 Views | 118 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by Fuzzy Dunlop
91AggieLawyer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

I just can't understand why we'd want to punish the well run clubs by creating a welfare league for the poorly run clubs by capping teams out.

I don't know that I would use "punish" and "welfare," but the answer to your point is simple: you NEED those teams to have a viable league and not every team is going to be a large market, rich one.

On the field, the Rangers (for example) want to beat the Astros (and vice-versa) but neither want the other to fold. Essentially a form of a cartel. If you want to scrutinize small market teams for relocation, go for it. But for dissolution, that's not a good idea.
double aught
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

we're condemning ourselves to a future of average teams competing to be the least bad to make the playoffs.

The future has arrived! The AL West!
BigD_03
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TarponChaser said:

I think these would piss off both sides pretty equally but would actually work well for the game.

  • Hard salary cap
  • Hard salary floor
  • End blackouts
  • Fix the ability of fans to stream all games across multiple platforms
  • Pooling and equal distribution of all media rights proceeds
  • Fix the service time manipulation (something like 90-100 days on the MLB active roster)
  • Arbitration eligible after 2 years
  • Unrestricted after 5 years
  • Owners required to re-expand MiLB rosters and clubs so that players actually have a path to develop
  • Increase MLB active rosters to 30 players w/ 16 pitcher max (September call-ups go to 32)
  • End deferred contracts (clubs can grandfather in 50% of their current deferred contracts, otherwise they have to trade guys)



this would be awesome
AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Interesting stories in the news the past couple of days about MLB possibly rooting hard for the Dodgers so they can use it as ammunition to force a salary cap on the players.

I found this quote from Alex Kirshner particularly relevant to our discussion here.

( https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7688886/2026/10/14/dodgers-nlcs-mlb-lockout-the-pulse/ )

My two cents, as someone who roots for a different low-paying ballclub (the Pirates): Baseball isn't "fair," but few things in life are, and the biggest impediments to my team's competitiveness are that the owner doesn't try hard and his executive team has done a terrible job. This makes me disinclined to support the owners, whose real interest is not "fairness" but a simpler path to escalating franchise values.

Featured Video Previews
TarponChaser
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieEP said:

Interesting stories in the news the past couple of days about MLB possibly rooting hard for the Dodgers so they can use it as ammunition to force a salary cap on the players.

I found this quote from Alex Kirshner particularly relevant to our discussion here.

( https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7688886/2026/10/14/dodgers-nlcs-mlb-lockout-the-pulse/ )

My two cents, as someone who roots for a different low-paying ballclub (the Pirates): Baseball isn't "fair," but few things in life are, and the biggest impediments to my team's competitiveness are that the owner doesn't try hard and his executive team has done a terrible job. This makes me disinclined to support the owners, whose real interest is not "fairness" but a simpler path to escalating franchise values.




Meanwhile I've seen conspiracy theories on social media which claim the bigger market teams like the Yankees & Dodgers threw their respective playoff series to undermine the owner's claims to need a salary cap.

Nobody reputable saying it that I can see but just wild conspiracy theories.
AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I love conspiracy theories. Imagine losing on purpose with the Dodgers roster just so they could all get a year older. I won't be surprised if the Dodgers dynasty is done, they've got major problems up and down the roster with big money committed to aging and injured stars.
Zut alors!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieEP said:

I love conspiracy theories. Imagine losing on purpose with the Dodgers roster just so they could all get a year older. I won't be surprised if the Dodgers dynasty is done, they've got major problems up and down the roster with big money committed to aging and injured stars.


That's part of the plan. Once the owner has to sell for fraud, the new owners won't honor the contracts. So the current players can join the fans in hating that POS organization.
TarponChaser
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AggieEP said:

I love conspiracy theories. Imagine losing on purpose with the Dodgers roster just so they could all get a year older. I won't be surprised if the Dodgers dynasty is done, they've got major problems up and down the roster with big money committed to aging and injured stars.


Seems that some orgs have done that in the past. Like, it's been a while but the Marlins loaded up with an expensive roster of FA guys to make a run and it paid off with World Series wins in 1997 and 2003 but I remember them fire-selling to dump salary immediately after each run.

The Yankees & Braves of the 90's and early 00's, Astros from 2017-2024, and Dodgers recently having sustained success are the exceptions.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So realistically, what are the chances that next season is locked out?
EABC_AG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A lock out taking place is a near certainty, but I think it's unlikely a full season is lost with the media rights negotiation upcoming
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
so when a lockout occurs...

owners save money in player salaries, travel costs, some medical costs, and certain stadium operating costs (utilities, employees, security, etc..,)

owners lose money in ticket sales, parking, concessions, and TV revenue / advertising

in the old days...the money lost would be greater than the money saved. But with skyrocketing salaries and travel costs...is that still the case?



AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Both sides have rainy day funds in case the lockout goes on for long enough to impact salaries or revenues. It's how they maintain unity the longer this goes on because not all 30 owners or all 750 players can financially weather a long strike without these funds.

Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieEP said:

Both sides have rainy day funds in case the lockout goes on for long enough to impact salaries or revenues. It's how they maintain unity the longer this goes on because not all 30 owners or all 750 players can financially weather a long strike without these funds.




What would be considered a long strike? I feel zero pity for anyone that loses revenue from this strike and can't float themselves for a year (or two) with how much money these people make. What do you think so many regular American families have been going through for ages?
Mathguy64
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This just feels different than previous lockout/.strikes.

The players are united as always. The owners seem fractured. You have the group that don't care about any tax structure or salary limitation (LAD, NYY, NYM, CHC), the group at the other end that needs structure and won't spend money and the middle group will spend but is limited by the tax and draft penalties (Houston, Atl, Philly). With the owners a bit in lockstep I wonder which group will lose out. If 2 of the 3 band together the other gets stuck. My guess is the big money spenders lose out.
AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sea Speed said:

AggieEP said:

Both sides have rainy day funds in case the lockout goes on for long enough to impact salaries or revenues. It's how they maintain unity the longer this goes on because not all 30 owners or all 750 players can financially weather a long strike without these funds.




What would be considered a long strike? I feel zero pity for anyone that loses revenue from this strike and can't float themselves for a year (or two) with how much money these people make. What do you think so many regular American families have been going through for ages?


What is the point of this post? You don't think a kid that just got called up to the big leagues in September and has never had any sort of bonus or big pay day in his career should be able to make it indefinitely without getting paid?

As for the owners, obviously a different dynamic at play, but they also have their limits for how long they feel comfortable pushing this thing. I only point out the rainy day funds that both sides have as those are relevant to keeping the solidarity of each side and prevent defections.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It's hard to have much sympathy for either side of this, to be honest. How many of the players are "kids that just got called up"? Its essentially looked at as millionaires fighting with billionaires by a lot of folks. The league minimum is $780k and with this strike looming any smart player would have been socking away money to float themselves through it.
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'd think the lack of 81 home games will have more negative effects on all the tangential employees and businesses though, and that sucks for them, truly.
AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
There were 255 players who debuted last year and have anywhere from 0-1 year of service time. Some of these guys undoubtedly had signing bonuses from when they were drafted but I'd guess it's still a pretty big number of guys that have career earnings well under a million.

Sure you can try to simplify it down to millionaires vs. billionaires, but that glosses over the fact that 99% of baseball players aren't on mega deals paying them 20 million per year. You don't have to have sympathy for any of them if you don't want, but IMO the players have a much more defensible position.
Dr. Doctor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I'd also point out that players are probably like most of us: we have mostly cash assets with some income producing stuff and other investments. But not huge sums of cash to wait out no income for long periods.

Compared to owners who are probably cash poor but asset rich. If you're using the team to fund your business(es), then a stop in cash flow can be harder to weather. Compared to players who should have some savings but might be living a little high on the hog with an expensive wife/ gf/babies.

Will be interesting to see who might blink first.

~egon
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
also some advantage for the college guys

the best players in the SEC made $100k to $250k to $500k via NIL last year
AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Lol at the owners.

They know they are cooked on this and are already trying to amend their offer. But what they don't understand is that pushing the salary cap to 2028 isn't seen as a concession by the players. Their position has been clear since the beginning, no salary cap of any type and at any time will be accepted.

This does make me more optimistic that we'll see baseball in 2027 because the owners are already showing that they're not confident enough to roll into negotiations demanding a salary cap for next year full stop. It's only a matter of time before they make their first offer without a cap at this point.
All I do is Nguyen
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cross posting from the Astros thread

No matter what!
Epstein didn't do, you know, the thing...
I'm the rare Astros/Cowboys/Spurs fan. We do exist
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
is the players union planning to compromise or give on anything?

appears not
Mathguy64
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Why should they? They are united as always and just look to wait the owners out and give them time to cave.

Like Obi Wan said, "I hold the high ground. You cannot win."

AggieEP
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yeah, the owners like to pretend like they are prepared to play hardball in negotiations, but their franchises are worth nothing without the players. The players could hypothetically play banana ball next year while they wait. The players are the attraction that makes the owners rich. So no matter what, if the players stay united, time is on their side in this battle.

I do give the owners credit for somehow fooling a good number of fans into supporting the billionaires over the players.
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
one issue with the owners as a group of 30...

some have owned their team for a long time...so they have finished paying off the previous owner / bank and already made back their investment so to speak. They can wait.

but new owners...or perhaps owners with new stadiums...will feel the pinch sooner
Langley
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm on whatever side Makes going to games more affordable and actually having a chance to watch a game on ****ing tv without a subscription to mlb tv


How mlb continues to have 10,000 games a year and only 150 of them are on tv mid mind boggling.


They literally make it the most difficult sport to watch including wnba
Sea Speed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wnba is difficult to watch for different reasons.
AustinCountyAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
people watch the WNBA?
Wabs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
A guaranteed contract is a fundamental right? LOL.
Langley
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AustinCountyAg said:

people watch the WNBA?


No, but you can find it on tv easier than mlb games is my point.
W
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
the issue I would like to see resolved...

and it puts me on the owners' side...

there needs to be a way to negotiate a settlement for mega-contracts when the player does not live up to his part of the contract via motivation, injury, or poor performance

so many examples...Rendon, Strasburg, LMj, Jose Abreu (although he wasn't on a mega), et al...

the current way is "just pay the rest of the money on his contract" -- which is not fair to owners who offered the contract in good faith

Zut alors!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Langley said:

AustinCountyAg said:

people watch the WNBA?


No, but you can find it on tv easier than mlb games is my point.


Im assuming this is based on area. Ive never had an issue watching local teams in California (LA area and SF) on the regional sports networks as part of tv packages. In Idaho we get Seattle games by default.

Aside from the ever increasing distribution amongst all the stupid streaming services (which is ridiculous considering that they're literally poached from both the MLB package and local broadcasts, so that's a bigger issue than anything IMO), most games are easily accessible. Is this an issue in Texas now?
Zut alors!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
W said:

the issue I would like to see resolved...

and it puts me on the owners' side...

there needs to be a way to negotiate a settlement for mega-contracts when the player does not live up to his part of the contract via motivation, injury, or poor performance

so many examples...Rendon, Strasburg, LMj, Jose Abreu (although he wasn't on a mega), et al...

the current way is "just pay the rest of the money on his contract" -- which is not fair to owners who offered the contract in good faith




Now do NIL
Enrico Pallazzo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Guaranteed deals are never going away, but it would be interesting to see them steal from the NBA and implement a max length of a deal. Let the current team offer 1 extra year. On the table right now is a 5 year standard max and current team can offer 6.

I think we lose up to half a season, but probably more like 1-2 months. Owners will cave
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.