Per twitter
Post Reply
1 of 1
Tracy McGrady to the hall of fame
3,106 Views |
19 Replies |
Last: 6 yr ago by Bodhi
Head Ninja In Charge
Joined:
Oct 10, 2005
Posts:
18,732
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Very deserving. I know he got knocked for never winning a playoff series but he probably had the worst luck of any superstar. He never had a great teammate who could stay healthy.
Ag Natural said:
Very deserving. I know he got knocked for never winning a playoff series but he probably had the worst luck of any superstar. He never had a great teammate who could stay healthy.
He won 3! Should have won a championship...
As a Spur?
The 13 in 35 and dunk on Shawn Bradley I'll never forget.
And yet, Rudy T gets stiffed again. Have a hard time believing McGrady has contributed more to basketball than Rudy T.
Mavs fan here and I just went and watched that. So good.Dan Scott said:
The 13 in 35 and dunk on Shawn Bradley I'll never forget.
I have no idea about your rooting interests but I am curious about your thoughts on Tony Romo?Ag Natural said:
Very deserving. I know he got knocked for never winning a playoff series but he probably had the worst luck of any superstar. He never had a great teammate who could stay healthy.
As a Cowboy fan this is generally my argument for Tony. Just crap luck when it mattered most.
t - cam said:I have no idea about your rooting interests but I am curious about your thoughts on Tony Romo?Ag Natural said:
Very deserving. I know he got knocked for never winning a playoff series but he probably had the worst luck of any superstar. He never had a great teammate who could stay healthy.
As a Cowboy fan this is generally my argument for Tony. Just crap luck when it mattered most.
If I had a vote Romo would be in. I think he's a top 5 most talented QB of his generation. He was plagued with pretty bad to mediocre teams and never a good defense. One season of a good running game then he gets hurt. I don't think he'll get in but I'd be in favor of it.
Lot of people to contend withAg Natural said:t - cam said:I have no idea about your rooting interests but I am curious about your thoughts on Tony Romo?Ag Natural said:
Very deserving. I know he got knocked for never winning a playoff series but he probably had the worst luck of any superstar. He never had a great teammate who could stay healthy.
As a Cowboy fan this is generally my argument for Tony. Just crap luck when it mattered most.
If I had a vote Romo would be in. I think he's a top 5 most talented QB of his generation. He was plagued with pretty bad to mediocre teams and never a good defense. One season of a good running game then he gets hurt. I don't think he'll get in but I'd be in favor of it.
Manning
Other Manning
Brady
Brees
Rogers
Warner
Roethlesberger
Rivers
Ryan
Palmer
Warner was born in 71 (retired on 09)
Farve was born in 69 (retired after 10).
I would not include either in Romo's "generation".
Farve was born in 69 (retired after 10).
I would not include either in Romo's "generation".
NBA HOF is becoming a participation award
AKA 13-0
McGrady is not HOF worthy, and Romo being talked about HOF is an even bigger joke
It's hard to consider someone who peaked at 24 a HOFer.
Isn't it the Basketball Hall of Fame ? Not the NBA Hall of Fame? If so, Rudy T is very deserving in my very biased opinion. From College All American through NBA as player, plus his time as a two time World Champion coach.
McGrady? Not sure. But I can see arguments either way.
McGrady? Not sure. But I can see arguments either way.
Peaking in your 7th year in the NBA isn't exactly unusual.
True. Still, is induction waters down the HOF even more. He's in the "Hall of Gilbert Arenas/Michael Redd/Baron Davis Very Good."Guitarsoup said:
Peaking in your 7th year in the NBA isn't exactly unusual.
NoahAg said:True. Still, is induction waters down the HOF even more. He's in the "Hall of Gilbert Arenas/Michael Redd/Baron Davis Very Good."Guitarsoup said:
Peaking in your 7th year in the NBA isn't exactly unusual.
Gilbert arenas seems like good comp.
TMac won two scoring titles, was AllNBA first team twice and made an all NBA team seven total times and was Mr Basketball USA.
Arenas never won a scoring title, never made an All NBA first team and only made three all NBA team
Arenas never won a scoring title, never made an All NBA first team and only made three all NBA team
Shouldn't be. HOF now a joke.