the problem is that he doesn't try to play the role of antagonist or even devils advocate. he just straight up trolls. he doesn't offer differing opinions because he legitimately believes the things he says. he does it just to piss people off, like a reddit poster gone rogue.
i love when people disagree on this board. if we didn't, this would turn into a football discussion on AO and we would have a giant dutch rudder circle jerk going on, but instead, we get post after post of simplestupid trolling for no reason and making retarded predictions only to hedge them all or find a way to bisch out of them. we're all tired of his schtick. it's played out.