gA_CMAB_FA said:

---

Who cares? Jennings and SMU won 11 games and did what they had to do to make the playoffs.

Reed and Texas A&M did not.

SMU had the better season.

---

Dumb post is dumb.

You think SMU would have sniffed the CFP (or even our record) with our schedule?

Pumpkinhead said:

---

The Porkchop Express said:

---

Pumpkinhead said:

---

SMU QB stats with about 19 minutes of game left.

15/29 142 yds, 4.9 YPC, 0 TDs, 3 INTS
7 carries, -21 yards, 0 TDs

---

He's playing in the CFP today.
What's our team doing today?

---

How is this argument tactic offering compelling evidence that the SMU QB would be a better option for A&M as an SEC QB than Marcel Reed? The Ole Miss & Bama QBs are also not playing in the CFP today. Is the SMU QB also better than their QBs? Better than the QB of any team not playing in the CFP today?

---

It's not an argument tactic. It's a post on an Internet message board.

13B said:

---

gA_CMAB_FA said:

---

Who cares? Jennings and SMU won 11 games and did what they had to do to make the playoffs.

Reed and Texas A&M did not.

SMU had the better season.

---

Dumb post is dumb.

You think SMU would have sniffed the CFP (or even our record) with our schedule?

---

Idiot post is idiotic.

The only thoughts (and votes) that matterted were the ones on the Playoff committee. Is that too hard to comprehend?

Reed > Jennings but Jennings was a state finalist qb and good athlete for South Oak Cliff, played high level high school ball. He's a great G5 QB with potential.

Every single measurable favors Reed by a lot.
Speed: Reed by a lot. Same for other athletic measurables like acceleration and vertical jump
Height/length/wingspan: Reed
Arm Strength: Reed
Accuracy: Reed
Mental game: Reed (film reviews of decisions)

Just wish patting players on the back followed by stabbing them in the back followed up with trying to pat them again on the back was not what so many Aggies act like.

TxAg76 said:

---

In this place, if QB1 isn't playing like JFF, they suck.

Of which QB2, or anybody else's QB1 that completes a pass, is automatically perceived as better

---

This. We were all spoiled for two glorious years with a once in a lifetime player at the college level.

Can't make JFF comparisons. You will never be happy.

Speaking of...damn. We really have been cursed at the QB position ever since.