And Stephen McGee played in the NFL for several seasons and I loved his heart as an Aggie QB

Johnny Manziel is the most over rated QB that I've ever seen play for A&M. He was the product of Kingsbury, and the recipient of such good fortune as having played with the OL that he had and Mike Evans.

This is the worst post I have seen. Please don't post anymore.

quote:

---

This is the worst post I have seen. Please don't post anymore.

---

Me?

Yes, you. Why would you say that? Did you not watch the games? I've never seen someone better at creating something from nothing. His open field running ability was incredible. We may never see another player like him.

It's because his "supporting" components never get any credit around here. Without those guys, he's just another quarterback. Was he fun to watch... You bet.
Was he the best QB to ever play at A&M, I don't know. But in my opinion, he's the most over rated.

Mahomes looks just like him tonight.

quote:

---

Johnny Manziel is the most over rated QB that I've ever seen play for A&M. He was the product of Kingsbury, and the recipient of such good fortune as having played with the OL that he had and Mike Evans.

---

Good god you're an idiot

Good God you are a follower with no ability to go against the grain.

quote:

---

It's because his "supporting" components never get any credit around here. Without those guys, he's just another quarterback. Was he fun to watch... You bet.
Was he the best QB to ever play at A&M, I don't know. But in my opinion, he's the most over rated.

---

Tannehill had the same supporting cast in 2011 that JFF had in 2012, yet Tannehill went 7-6 while Johnny went 11-2. I've read some dumb things on this site, but this is up there with the best of them.

quote:

---

Good God you are a follower with no ability to go against the grain.

---

Lol ok, pal.

Tra Carson only has 28 yards passing. What a chump.

quote:

---

Good God you are a follower with no ability to go against the grain.

---

So being totally idiotic about his ability is going against the grain.

Then you're a total genius. See, I'm going against the grain.

Pullig had a bad ass defense to help him. That guy had 6 turnovers against an unranked directional Louisiana team. His "record" as a starter means nothing.

quote:

---

quote:

---

quote:

---

Lance Pavlas was a huge disappointment if I remember correctly.

---

Yep.


Mark Farris. #1

---

Tommy Preston says hello.

---

Anyone ever heard of John Mazur?

Why do we do this to our own people?
Can somebody explain this to me?

This is the worst post I have seen. Please don't post anymore.


Me?
I meant the op .

Lex James

quote:

---

Pullig had a bad ass defense to help him. That guy had 6 turnovers against an unranked directional Louisiana team. His "record" as a starter means nothing.

---

I think you are talking about Brandon Stewart. The game we lost to SWL was in 1996, a year after Pullig left.


Farris is the worst I've seen in regards to QB's who had a meaningful # of starts.

Pullig is the best when it comes to duration as he started most of his 4 years.

Manziel by far the best for the 2 year stretch.

I like Tannehill but the disappointing sr. year vs. expectations for that team left me underwhelmed. He was great for about a 6 game stretch in 2010.

quote:

---

Everyone between Gary Kubiak and Ryan Tannehill was awful.

If your QB doesn't play a couple years in the pros, then he was no bueno.

---

This makes no sense.

And I'll always contend Reggie McNeal was greatness.

Dustin Long is the worst I've seen. I've only been following Aggie football since 2000, though.

quote:

---

Why do we do this to our own people?
Can somebody explain this to me?

---

+1

quote:

---

quote:

---

Pullig had a bad ass defense to help him. That guy had 6 turnovers against an unranked directional Louisiana team. His "record" as a starter means nothing.

---

I think you are talking about Brandon Stewart. The game we lost to SWL was in 1996, a year after Pullig left.


Farris is the worst I've seen in regards to QB's who had a meaningful # of starts.

Pullig is the best when it comes to duration as he started most of his 4 years.

Manziel by far the best for the 2 year stretch.

I like Tannehill but the disappointing sr. year vs. expectations for that team left me underwhelmed. He was great for about a 6 game stretch in 2010.

---

Yeah, that one. That freaking game.

The best Aggie QB's ??

1 Johnny
2 Bucky
3 Kevin Murray

quote:

---

The best Aggie QB's ??

1 Johnny
2 Bucky
3 Kevin Murray

---

I'd put Kevin ahead of Bucky in that list....

quote:

---

Corey Pullig: 33-6-1 mark as a starter, better than Kubiak or Tannehill or anybody else for that matter.

---

And although Pullig didn't make the NFL, he joined the Marines instead after college, so I have huge respect for him.

quote:

---

quote:

---

quote:

---

quote:

---

Kyle Allen has to be on the list. THREE INTS for TDS in one game.

---

I see this on this forum all the time and it bugs me. Kyler also threw 3 ints in a game against a weaker opponent (Auburn). If anyone on A&M dared to make a tackle then people would not keep saying pick 6.

Kyle Allen was worse in the Ole Miss game but all people can talk about is the pick 6s in the Bama game. Some of the blame has to be on the pathetic A&M offense who could not tackle the returner 3 freakin times!.

---

ha ha.. blaming pick 6s on offense not tackling. good one.

---

Not saying the picks were not bad but one went for 93 yards and one for 55 yards. How in the world can't we get a tackle on those 2 picks???

Why does the fact that we can't make a tackle make those worse than some of the lousy ones Kyler threw when we were about to score???

---

I see what you did there...Offense to the tackling drills...Defense lets work on the route tree

For those ripping on Jeff Granger and Lance Pavlas - the videos below may provide a different opinion of their time here:

Pavlas - '88 Cotton Bowl vs ND - his passing and Bucky's running led us to our last New Years bowl win prior to the 2013 Cotton Bowl blowout vs Oklahoma



Side note - Pavlas wore#12 before it became reserved for the 12th man kickoff team

Granger - '92 vs Tech - led us on a game winning drive by avoiding a huge 3rd down sack late in the 4th quarter

There's no benefit in criticizing and tearing down fellow Aggies. These are guys that worked hard to go out and entertain and win for A&M. QBs are at the mercy of their coaches and teammates and get too much credit when they win and too much blame when they lose.

Thank them for their effort and move on.

mark farris got rc fired

quote:

---

mark farris got rc fired

---

No.

1 Johnny

2 Bucky

3 Pullig

Worst: USCw transfer John Mazur

Pavalas was a very good QB. He was a true drop back passer. Bucky on same team was a LB playing QB. Had Pavalas played for a coach like Mike Sherman, he would have lit it up.

I knew Lex James personally. He had all the talent in the world. He had the absolute worst attitude. Kyler is much like him. The players were not his friends. In fact the 1971 team refused to go to Ft Worth unless Stallings benched James and started Joe Mack King.

quote:

---

This pretty much says it all. Watch the video and read the analysis. Only the second pick of 93 yards could have legitimately been stopped by the offense. All three are blatantly KA's fault. In the first pick, you can see where the fullback is wide open and KA could easily have side stepped and made a wide open throw. Instead he throws off his back foot. http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootball/eye-on-college-football/25348360/sec-film-study-texas-am-qb-kyle-allen-gifts-alabama-three-pick-sixes

---

I'm sure I'm one of the few on here to have missed this when it was first posted, but thanks for providing the link. An interesting analysis and good read. Made me rethink some of my opinions on KA's gameplay and JS's play calling.

quote:

---

Worst: USCw transfer John Mazur

---

Fall of 1983. He was so bad no one remembers him.