jdwAg20/91,
I thought your true Aggieness was determined by that little thing by your name

Actually, everyone should be FORCED to get the antique finish. It takes years and years of being an Aggie before you can wear off the antique and have the natural look.
So if you don't get the antique look, I won't say you are less Aggie, rather you are trying to look more Aggie than you really are

Oh and one more thing. Real Aggies are ENGINEERING majors