I grew up/ graduated in Cayuga. My niece graduated this past weekend from there and will following me into the Aggie Network. Smaller school but very great atmosphere and good sports if you need that as well. There were 50 graduates and the scholarships awarded equalled 700k including music, arts, academics, and athletics.
You will find that that many in Anderson County try to manuever to Cayuga.
That's just my experience. Wouldn't trade it for the world.