File5 said:
What wrong with Reiner's???
Screwed me on two custom settings, a separate jeweler that's highly regarded here had a theory that one was modified from a different sized stone, who knows about the first but was likely also something they had on hand. I've posted the longer version a couple times but don't have time to search right now.
End of the day, I could have sent it back without leaving the store but who the F am I to judge jewelry design and I had a trip to Napa the next day and a question to ask.
My advice to anyone getting something custom is either have the chick or dude recipient involved or get a solitaire to use when asking.