Finn Maccumhail said:
ATM9000 said:
Finn Maccumhail said:
Miller will learn how to be physical and get away with it. He's not a small dude at WR- listed at 6'2" 216#; he's just still very much learning how to play WR.
If Braxton Miller is in the league 2 seasons from now, I'd be shocked. He's a sloppy and inefficient route runner and, while he's a great athlete, he's not near athletic enough to get away with that inefficiency. Maybe he gets better, but I've not seen it yet.
But that's my problem generally w/ Bill O'Brien and why I think he sucks. Rick Smith gets too vilified as a GM in my opinion. What should bug everyone is that you see little development and growth from players under O'Brien. That's on the coach and why I think our staff stinks. It's more than just we've had bad quarterbacks... the players on the team just don't really get much better... especially on the offensive side of the ball. As the starts get older, that's going to get to be a big problem.
That could potentially be true on Miller. He was drafted largely on athletic potential and it's definitely on the staff to develop him, teach him to run routes properly, etc.
But taking him with a 3rd round pick is on Smith. There's no chance in hell he deserved to go that high. He was a 5th or later pick, maybe should have been a UFA. And Smith's problems in the draft predate O'Brien by a long time.
O'Brien sucks but you cannot let Smith off the hook. Smith has been the GM since 2006 but his first draft was 2007. Look at his picks after the first round since then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Houston_Texans_draft_history#2006
There's a whole lot of nothing in there.
Couple of points:
1. Miller was basically projected in the mid-2nd to mid-3rd round in 2016. As a prospect, he wasn't considered a 5th round or later prospect. The problem isn't that Rick just takes a **** on draft values and drafts guys way early or late. In fact, just search Texags Texans drafts and you'll see for the most part, people aren't pissed off on the Sunday after the draft... that's a good indicator that he's not drafting guys way early, etc.
2. Even the best GM's draft history is going to look like that after the first round. If you look at 2007-2013-ish, he drafted a lot of NFL starters and contributors that lasted more than 4 seasons in the league... that's a good indicator he's not **** the bed in the draft. What would bug me is break that list down now between 2007 and 2013 (Kubiak years) and then the BOB years... If you look at it that way, you should notice a drop off in late round player contributions and general early career development.
I don't love Rick Smith by any means, but people should be pissed and pretty concerned with how little players develop under the current regime. Butt chin is a bad coach. That's not even mentioning his putrid offensive mess... Good God he's such an aimless playcaller.
But hey... he drops a lot of f bombs and yells so the non-football players can get their little boners over what a hardnosed coach he is. QB guru my ass.