AggieFrog said:
Decay said:
Yeah God forbid you let people vote on schools with their dollars
But it's not. It's a subsidy for those who can already afford private school. It's not enough to cover private tuition, so those who can't afford it today, can't afford it with the subsidy tomorrow. And it's putting public money in private schools who are not subject to the same requirements as publics (to teach those with disabilities, to be held to standardized test results, etc.). Note that I say that as someone who had three kids in a private school for multiple years (spending $20k+ a year to do so) - my tax dollars should support public schools, IMO.
There's so much misinformation in this short paragraph, its hard to know where to start.
For one, the concept of vouchers is more than just about affordability; it is about choice. More importantly, it is about breaking up a system that forces the public school system monopoly on the people you're talking about -- those that supposedly can't afford private school -- into THEIR (the public school) system with no reasonable alternative. For another, private schools deal with special needs kids all the time. Shelton School in Plano is a school that specializes in special needs kids. Other private schools welcome such students. Not all, of course, but you're kidding yourself if you think the public school system is providing those kids with a) what they actually need and b) what is legally mandated. In most cases, they do as little as they can get away with and they have pretty good law firms there to defend them when they get called on that. The idea that vouchers are going to make a good situation bad is idiotic; AT WORST it will be status quo, which admittedly isn't great, but that isn't the fault of the voucher plan.
And I say that as someone who's mom was a pioneer in the Special Ed field from the late '60s on, a wife who's spent her whole career (35 years) in special ed of some sort and has a masters degree in it, as a lawyer who's both represented clients against school districts and defended districts in litigation and other matters, and as someone who's both studied and been a strong proponent of vouchers since the early '80s. So I think I can speak fairly intelligently to this issue.