quote:
This is not stupid but rather is basically the correct ratio for our soil. Producers in Bryan makes and sells their own fertilizer (Brazos Best) specialized for our area soil at a ratio of 23-0-3, because there is so much phosphorus here already (see Neil Sperry recommendation above by taxpreparer). Scotts is just made with a larger southern audience in mind, not only the Brazos valley. Any low middle number fert will work well here, inc. the scotts.
3(or4)-1-2 is a general national recommendation, but is basically much too much phosphorus for repeated applications here. Results might be good with a 3-1-2, but will be better with something with much much less P...
Funny, the 3-1-2 is the recommendation of the Texas Agrilife Extension for our county... and I could swear I have Neil Sperry's book on gardening in Texas, and that's what he says is best for a zone 8 St. Aug lawn.
Brazos County has several soil types and not all of them are overdosed in phosphorous, especially if you're on fill that was hauled in from elsewhere to a new subdivision.
My experience with the all-nitrogen Scotts weed&feed products was poor. I uesd them last year and the year before. The St. Aug grass (from sod, 3 yo lawn) did not root deeply and had no drought tolerance. I lost most of my lawn last year to the point where the HOA was making grumbly noises in my direction and I had to irrigate almost nightly just to get it through the hottest months. This year, I've been applying the cheapest 3-1-2 at Lowe's ($5 a bag for 15-5-10) once a month and my lawn looks ten times better, and deep watering has been effective. I also added some lime and iron.
[This message has been edited by superspeck (edited 5/11/2009 1:06p).]