normaleagle05 said:
Prime is a wide range above choice. It's not all created equal.
ANSC grad here that worked at packing plant in friona back in late 90's. I'll preface that things may have changed since then.....
you are correct in this statement. As another poster pointed out above HEB doesn't grade. It happens at the plant. When I was there after processing they cut amongst the ribs so the grader could see the marbling. That person then stamped the beef with the grade in several places. And this all happened while the hanging carcass was moving down the conveyor line. It's not like they had 1 minute to really inspect it. I'm sure it has changed with technology and so much focus on "CAB", wagyu, etc. But one person might grade something choice and another prime.
For the HEBs in my area....when its labeled prime its been prime. And I say that from having bought individual cuts to entire ribeyes and tenderloins still in cryovac.
What I will say that many times what comes across as Choice has varied greatly. The majority of the time I can find stuff that is labeled as Choice that is damn near Prime. But other times it leans more Select.
Just gotta take a look at it and judge for yourself. I don't buy Select but especially with prices the way they are if they have Choice on sale I'm definitely digging thru what's out there.