docb said:
TarponChaser said:
76Ag said:
The Chinese don't fish for bass. How can I get a decent bait casting rod made in the USA and where?
There are only a handful of rod companies cooking blanks in the USA. All of the USA-based fly rod companies build their own high-end rods and blanks here. However, I do believe they all make their blanks and rods on the lower end abroad; St. Croix has some made in Mexico and the others in South Korea, IIRC.
I'm only aware of a couple other companies making rod blanks here in the USA, and most of those are not building conventional rods, they're fly-rod specific.. North Fork Composites is Gary Loomis's company after he sold G. Loomis and they sell blanks while also making Edge Rods which I believe are factory-direct only and run $300+.
There just aren't many manufacturers building the blanks and they certainly aren't making inexpensive blanks. Even the volume manufacturers like Waterloo or Falcon or whomever is the flavor of the month that advertise their rods as "Made In America" aren't being wholly truthful. A more accurate statement is "Assembled in the USA from Foreign-made Components."
Frankly, the concept of a "lifetime guarantee" drove a lot of rod companies into the ground and ended up being sold to larger multi-national corporations. I used to be acquainted with the original All Star rod folks when they had their entire operation from cooking blanks to assembly up off 290 and where the be-all, end-all rods. They ended up losing so much money from people who would fish a rod for a year or two then break it on purpose and demand a free replacement. That's completely unsustainable for a business.
The idea that you can't get a good rod built in Asia is absurd. Sure, you get some junk but the same factory will crank out crap rods will also turn out some of the best rods on the planet. It all depends on what you want to pay.
Then, there's the question- what are you looking for in a rod? What do you consider "decent?" Do you want light weight? Do you want durability? Do you want a faster or slower action? What lures are you going to be chunking with it for bass?
I'm sure you can get some nice rods made in China these days. I remember the old All Star rods were the bomb when they first came out, then I feel the product eventually became just a run of the mill rod when the rods started coming from China. Seems like the same thing happened to CastAway rods. My worst experience personally was with a bunch of Laguna Graphite rods. Looked nice and very light. Those rods ended up breaking like a dry twig. Frankly, I think it's hard to find a really nice rod at Academy these days. But luckily there are some really nice rods still available. The G Loomis GLX, NRX and even the IMX graphite make really nice rods. I'm thinking these are all still made in the USA.
You've always been able to get good rods built in Asia whether it's from China, Taiwan, Japan, or South Korea. The issue is expecting a $30 Berkley Lightning Rod to perform like a $300 rod from Asia.
All Star had to go abroad to be manufactured because they were hemorrhaging money like crazy. People were purposely breaking their rods and demanding replacements. When they tried to walk back their guarantee to prevent this, people went on to the next flavor of the month and did the same thing. So they sold themselves to a multi-national which basically just bought the brand and the distribution network so the original owners could capitalize on what value was left. Manufacturing goes overseas and perception drops. All Star rods are still a good value IMHO.
Personally, I think people get way too caught up in all these supposed characteristics and benefits of high-end rods. I get the value of having a lighter weight rod when you're wading all day or chucking & winding lures. And maybe something really sensitive when fishing really light finesse stuff for bass. People are free to spend their money how they will but two things I really learned when I started kayak fishing and then moving to fly fishing were that having a metric crap-ton of gear was not only not necessary but often detracted from my ability to catch fish because I was too worried about the gear and not finding the fish.
As for those really lightweight rods snapping, that's pretty inevitable. Graphite cloth is graphite cloth. Sure, there are varying modulus which relates to the shear strength and weight of the cloth. To get a rod that's both light and responsive you have to build a blank that has thinner walls. Thinner walls = more likely to break.
That being said, the vast majority of rod breakages are caused by three categories:
1) unseen damage to the rod; ie- breaking of microscopic graphite fibers by banging jig heads off the rod, or the rod off of other hard surfaces. This causes weakening of the rod blank walls until it snaps.
2) carelessness; ie- slamming the rod in a car door or ceiling fan or whatever
3) poor fish-fighting technique; ie- high-sticking and the like