This past two weeks have been an eye opener for me. The only serious cold weather jacket I have is my duck hunting one. I'm looking for something that is a little more casual. Currently I've been looking at Patagonia Down Sweater, TNF ThermoBall, and a Simms Downstream down sweater.

Are there better options out there? Looking for something that can handle temps down into the thirties and can block wind (water resistant would be nice, but not a deal breaker). Price wise would like to keep under $200 if possible.

Should I be looking at fleece instead of down type jackets? Or possibly a 3 in 1 type jacket?

Is layering an option for you, or are you wanting an all-in-one?

The jackets you already have would make a good mid layer, just pick up a hard- (or soft-) shell to pair with them.

In the end, you'll have more options to suit the weather.

Edit:
If Outdoor Research's pro program is applicable to you, their shell is a nice option, and in your price range: https://www.outdoorgearlab.com/reviews/clothing-mens/hardshell-jacket/outdoor-research-axiom
If not, check out their soft shell: https://www.outdoorgearlab.com/reviews/clothing-mens/softshell-jacket/outdoor-research-ascendant-hoody

I have this one and love it. It's my go to extreme cold weather jacket. The fleece inner part unzips from the shell outer part and you can wear them separately, but I never have. I just leave them together and stay super warm.

Columbia Men's Bugaboo Interchange Jacket, Black, Large https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00GT4PZVK/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_CGkyAbAY3P7P5

The Patagonia down sweater will not meet your requirements, as it will not block wind very well. You would need to pair it with a shell for windy and/or rainy conditions. This is actually a very good way to go, but any decent shell will put you over your price limit.

I have not used the other two jackets.

My winter jacket:

https://www.duluthtrading.com/store/mens/mens-outerwear/mens-work-jackets/32235.aspx?processor=content

Quote:

---

Sure, down jackets are phenomenally warm and lightweight. But "durable" isn't a word used to describe them until now. Because our down jacket takes high-lofting 700 fill power goose down and puts it in a beefier ripstop Cordura nylon shell that's more durable than the rest, while still being lightweight. Plus we've put hardface reinforcements in the shoulders and arms so a little hard work never leaves this jacket in tatters. Insulated stand-up collar keeps the cold off your neck plus a drawcord adjustable bottom seals out drafts. Diamond Armpit Gussets for freedom of movement, so you can get your arms around the big jobs.

---

I find it comfortable into the minus teens.

I love the two carhartt jackets I have, they are awesome at keeping you warm especially if you pick one with the quilted lining in it. The outer lining is "water repellent" but I wouldnt call it totally waterproof.

This is one I wear every day that its really cold, including as I type this:
Carhartt Bankston Jacket

As other have mentioned, I'd look at layering. My preferred way is an rain jacket over a fleece jacket. North Face, Columbia, LL Bean, and others make things that will work. I'm sure REI or another store has a brand that will work too.

I really love my Marmot soft-shell. Thing has been with me for years and it's great. Blocks 100% of the wind. Fleece lined. DWR coating. Does fine in a light rain. Even started wearing it skiing as it's less bulky and easy to layer under and it cuts the wind and driving ice just fine.

Also looked at the North Face Apex jacket, but liked the fit/finish of the Marmot a little better. There are a lot of good options out there.

***also look at the Marmot Scree pants they are awesome in weather like this.

Buy a nicer duck jacket and you're all good!

https://www.filson.com/men/coats-jackets/sportsman-jackets/shelter-waterfowl-upland-coat.html

Everyone should own one of these. It's the best jacket I've ever owned, and keeps you much warmer than you'd expect by looking at it. Pair it with a base layer under a button down, and you can dress it up to "nice casual" even on the coldest days. In Texas, you don't need anything more than a soft shell and, a couple of times a year, a good base layer to wear under it.

I second the quilt lined Carhartt jackets. I have a couple...not sure on style name. But they are warm and durable/rugged.

I prefer the heavy canvas/duck coats (several Carhartt types)....and the longer coat (versus a "jacket") to prevent cold air from traveling up my backside!

jabberwalkie09 said:

---

As other have mentioned, I'd look at layering. My preferred way is an rain jacket over a fleece jacket. North Face, Columbia, LL Bean, and others make things that will work. I'm sure REI or another store has a brand that will work too.

---

This is my go to. Usually just a rain jacket over my fleece. I was warm going to my 9:10 yesterday in the low teens.

Layer and a pea coat when I'm in a setting I can't get away with camo/hunting gear.

I have been rocking my lined Wrangler blue-jean jacket over a sweater. Keeps me very warm and denim-on-denim is a classic look.

Wizard said:

---

I have been rocking my lined Wrangler blue-jean jacket over a sweater. Keeps me very warm and denim-on-denim is a classic look.

---

Canadian Tuxedo

I bought a tnf inlux for skiing for 89 bucks a year or two ago off steep and cheap. I also have an OR from there that has been great. I'll typically wait until after season and grab a cheap one 50-100 bucks vs. in season 180+

I am a fan of a classic pea coat when the temps drop this low.

GSS said:

---

I prefer the heavy canvas/duck coats (several Carhartt types)....and the longer coat (versus a "jacket") to prevent cold air from traveling up my backside!

---

I second this. Guess it depends on what you are doing outdoors. I have a model that is Sherpa lined with hood and is a little bit longer coat. Don't know the name. It is VERY warm. Usually when I'm outdoors in very cold weather, I don't want to be concerned about ripping the coat or getting it dirty.

anyone heard of this website...thewonelm.com?

found some killer deals on jackets? almost too good to be true? If it is legit I will probably order a 3 in 1 jacket just to get the most bang for my buck

Also, if you can afford it, Filson makes some really nice looking and warm jackets.

If ****kicker fashion is your thing, then the Schaefer Cattle Baron Drifter is an excellent choice. It works very well.

http://www.schaefer-ranchwear.com/250-cattle-baron-drifter.html

Currently living in Northern VA, so my primary winter coats are a Patagonia NanoPuff and TNF Thermoball for just running around town.

If conditions get to below freezing and are Wet/Windy then I add a Rain/Wind proof shell.

I believe in layering. If outside for long period of time Baselayer (like smartwool), fleece (TNF TKA100), Nanopuff or Thermoball, and shell. All without the surprising bulk of some all in one options.

I prefer the NanoPuff and Thermoball over the Patagonia Down because you don't have to worry about the wet eliminating insulation capacity.

Snow Monkey Ambassador said:

---

Everyone should own one of these. It's the best jacket I've ever owned, and keeps you much warmer than you'd expect by looking at it. Pair it with a base layer under a button down, and you can dress it up to "nice casual" even on the coldest days. In Texas, you don't need anything more than a soft shell and, a couple of times a year, a good base layer to wear under it.

---

I highly suggest this jacket as well. It is light and warm.

I love my north face Tri climate. The outer rain jacket is extremely water proof and the inner liner is very warm. I'm a landscaper and outside daily and almost use use it daily during the fall/winter

I have this from a few years ago, and it is my goto jacket all the time. Has the Omni heat inside which keeps me plenty warm. I have another Omni heat camo jacket I wear in the field as well.

https://www.amazon.com/Columbia-Thermarator-Jacket-Heather-XX-Large/dp/B00AI3J9WO/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1516293359&sr=8-1&keywords=columbia+thermarator+mens+jacket

https://www.thenorthface.com/shop/mens-jackets-vests-3-in-1-jackets/mens-thermoball-triclimate-jacket-nf0a2tck?variationId=DYZ

Just Get a carhart

I moved up north last year, and luckily I had an old Dri Duck jacket (similar to Carhart) that a friend gave me years ago. That has been surprisingly warm. It does a good job cutting the wind, repelling moisture, and keeping me warm. It's just kinda ugly. Especially with bleach stains on it.

But I'm kinda in the same boat as you. I don't know how to dress for this kind of weather. Do I layer? Do I do all in one? Do I just run from building to building and to the car and avoid as much time outside as possible?

Snow Monkey Ambassador said:

---

Everyone should own one of these. It's the best jacket I've ever owned, and keeps you much warmer than you'd expect by looking at it. Pair it with a base layer under a button down, and you can dress it up to "nice casual" even on the coldest days. In Texas, you don't need anything more than a soft shell and, a couple of times a year, a good base layer to wear under it.

---

I've worn this jacket the past two days in BCS with only a long sleeve underneath. Have had it for 4 or 5 years and this cold snap proved it to be the best jacket I've ever owned. Blocks wind and keeps body heat inside better than my heavy duck hunting coat.

C4D said:

---

Just Get a carhart

---

I kept thinking....Why has no one said Carhart. Can't go wrong with those.

https://www.mensfitness.com/styleandgrooming/fashion/top-10-winter-jackets-under-200

I second Northface triclimate with thermoball. You can also layer up with a base layer, vest, and rain jacket. Base layers make a big difference for being outdoors.

BoozerRed78 said:

---

If ****kicker fashion is your thing, then the Schaefer Cattle Baron Drifter is an excellent choice. It works very well.

http://www.schaefer-ranchwear.com/250-cattle-baron-drifter.html

---

This - 24oz melton wool is toasty warm & windproof.

Schaefer's not my style but I have a Sterlingwear melton peacoat that's go-to for 40's and below. It works at the office & kicking around the woods when ice is on the ponds. Not cheap, but it will last decades if you treat it right.

bigtruckguy3500 said:

---

I moved up north last year, and luckily I had an old Dri Duck jacket (similar to Carhart) that a friend gave me years ago. That has been surprisingly warm. It does a good job cutting the wind, repelling moisture, and keeping me warm. It's just kinda ugly. Especially with bleach stains on it.

But I'm kinda in the same boat as you. I don't know how to dress for this kind of weather. Do I layer? Do I do all in one? Do I just run from building to building and to the car and avoid as much time outside as possible?

---

What is "up north" and how cold are we talking? How you're personally wired, and what level of "nice" or "professional" dress you require is really important as well.

We've had a lot of near zero days lately (-8 to 8*) and it's cold. But you (I) get used to it pretty quick. It's amazing how quick your body adjusts. The first October morning in the 30s I freeze my ass off. But I'll shovel snow this time of year in shorts in single digit temperatures.

If I'm going casual I'll just wear a nice pullover sweater, or nicer 1/4 zip fleece under a soft-shell jacket like the NorthFace jacket posted above (Mine is a Marmot). If I'm headed to work I have a black wool mid-length overcoat (just below my ass, not to my knees) that I'll wear first thing in the mornings (I wear a suit to work every day this time of year). It was 14* this morning and I walked the dogs and went to work in just a shirt and tie, didn't even wear my suit coat until I got into the office and needed to for appearances.