He was a stupid hire in the first place. I have wanted to fire him after every season he has been the head coach. Maybe now we will move on.
Infection_Ag11 said:Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:
Jerry will make a bunch of emotional decisions after this, that being one of them. Objectively firing a coach that won 37 games in 3 years is really stupid. The chances that you hire someone better are very, very, very low.
It's not an emotional decision at all. How can anyone say "I need to see more from McCarthy and Quinn".
NFL playoffs are about getting in over and over until you get lucky
Yes he will be.Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:
Jerry will make a bunch of emotional decisions after this, that being one of them. Objectively firing a coach that won 37 games in 3 years is really stupid. The chances that you hire someone better are very, very, very low.
It's not an emotional decision at all. How can anyone say "I need to see more from McCarthy and Quinn".
NFL playoffs are about getting in over and over until you get lucky
If they retain him you'll be posting this again next year.
Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:
Jerry will make a bunch of emotional decisions after this, that being one of them. Objectively firing a coach that won 37 games in 3 years is really stupid. The chances that you hire someone better are very, very, very low.
It's not an emotional decision at all. How can anyone say "I need to see more from McCarthy and Quinn".
NFL playoffs are about getting in over and over until you get lucky
If they retain him you'll be posting this again next year.
TyHolden said:
Bellicheat is 71 and looks beaten down. He hasn't won anything since Brady. Why take that chance?
mncag said:
weak game plan from the start.
If you know you have problems running the ball and stopping the run why not go uptempo and put up points . They let Green Bay dictate flow of game then got behind and put to much pressure on Dak.
lots of issues, but the gameplan was putrid , its like they changed everything they had been doing for this game.
If your going with Dak, let DQ and MM go, you cant trust them.
Ozamataz Buckshank 01 said:
The Cowboys Achilles Heel is the run defense. Quinn is overrated, and he designed the defense to be a pass rush team first. Good teams neutralize the Cowboys defense by controlling the line of scrimmage and using mobile qbs to complete throws down field.
You do not promote a DC to head coach after today's performance. The Cowboys have to bring in a DC that can force 3rd and longs and not give up 5+ yards a carry.
Many would argue winning one Super Bowl with 13 years of prime Aaron Rodgers is underachieving.Project Gemini said:
He won a Super Bowl. It is a gross misstatement of fact to say as a coach he cannot win in the playoffs.
94chem said:
Vince Young was 31-19 as a starter.
McCarthy can't keep his job just because he piles up regular season wins.
Name one signature win he had this season.
At SF - fail
At Buffalo - fail
At Miami - fail
At Philly - fail
DET at home - miraculous escape
Philly at home - doesn't count
Sure, he can bludgeon haples teams with journeyman QB's. So what.
Only in your make-believe world does reading partial posts count. Or perhaps you believe DET was a signature win.MookieBlaylock said:94chem said:
Vince Young was 31-19 as a starter.
McCarthy can't keep his job just because he piles up regular season wins.
Name one signature win he had this season.
At SF - fail
At Buffalo - fail
At Miami - fail
At Philly - fail
DET at home - miraculous escape
Philly at home - doesn't count
Sure, he can bludgeon haples teams with journeyman QB's. So what.
only in your make believe world does the Det and philly games not count
This is the first year in a while they have choked. The last two years weren't chokes. They just didn't have the best team. Period. Just like if they would have gone to the NFC championship this year. Losing to the 9ers in SF would not have been a choke. It would have been expected.ABATTBQ11 said:
It's not McCarthy. It's the cowboys. No other team chokes as hard in the playoffs. They will not get near another Superbowl until Jerry is dead or sells.
Dak Prescott has a 2-5 record in the postseason.
— NFL on CBS 🏈 (@NFLonCBS) January 15, 2024
No QB has a lower win pct in NFL history, among those with 5+ starts pic.twitter.com/k02Au8gYTV
Source: Cowboys defensive coordinator Dan Quinn will interview for the Panthers and Titans jobs on Wednesday, the Commanders job on Thursday, and the Chargers job on Friday. Those will all be over Zoom.
— Albert Breer (@AlbertBreer) January 15, 2024
FireAg said:
This roster with Belichick is what I think Jerry will pursue…
We can debate it as right or wrong all we want, but this is what I think the future holds…