I've got a guy in the league who will miss the playoffs and wants keepers for next year. I've got a lot of young talent I could trade.

League:
1QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 Flex, 1 TE, def, k

My team:
CJ Stroud
Russel Wilson
CMC
Najee Harris
Gus Edwards
Zack Moss
Devon Achane
Tyreek Hill
Mike Evans
Jordan Addison
Calvin Ridley
Deandre Hopkins
Dalton Kincaid

His Team:
Josh Allen
Joe Mixon
Jerome Ford
James Conner
Bijan Robinson
Chiba Hubbard
Garrett Wilson
Brandon Aiyuk
Chris Olave
Rashee Rice
Tyler Boyd
Travis Kielce
Logan Thomas

I'd Give:
Gus Edwards
Dalton Kincaid
Jordan Addison

I'd Get:
Joe Mixon
Travis Kielce
Garret Wilson


What do you guys think?

YourMyBoyBlue said:

---

I've got a guy in the league who will miss the playoffs and wants keepers for next year. I've got a lot of young talent I could trade.

League:
1QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 Flex, 1 TE, def, k

My team:
CJ Stroud
Russel Wilson
CMC
Najee Harris
Gus Edwards
Zack Moss
Devon Achane
Tyreek Hill
Mike Evans
Jordan Addison
Calvin Ridley
Deandre Hopkins
Dalton Kincaid

His Team:
Josh Allen
Joe Mixon
Jerome Ford
James Conner
Bijan Robinson
Chiba Hubbard
Garrett Wilson
Brandon Aiyuk
Chris Olave
Rashee Rice
Tyler Boyd
Travis Kielce
Logan Thomas

I'd Give:
Gus Edwards
Dalton Kincaid
Jordan Addison

I'd Get:
Joe Mixon
Travis Kielce
Garret Wilson


What do you guys think?

---

I think you smash yes. Also depends on how many keepers you mean and what the cost of keeping is.

Reasons
1. I think TEs are seeing a rise in prevalence and thus a decrease in specialness. Kincaid, Ferguson, LaPorta, Trey McBride.
2. Gus Edwards is not the Baltimore's future RB he is their present RB1...kind of.
3.Garret Wilson i like more ROS than addison with JJ coming back. I'm guessing it is a 3 keeper league and you will likely be keeping Achane, CMC and Hill

Definitely take that deal.

Piggybacking on this. Ten-man, .5 PPR, two flex league.

Would y'all trade Mike Evans and Brandon Aiyuk for Jonathan Taylor and Chris Godwin with this team?

QB: Herbert
RBs: Breece, Achane, Ford, Charbs
WRs: Jjettas, Keenan, Aiyuk, Mike Evans, Tank Dell, Drake London, Demario Douglas, Jerry Jeuedy
TE: Kelce

Zachary Klement said:

---

Definitely take that deal.

Piggybacking on this. Ten-man, .5 PPR, two flex league.

Would y'all trade Mike Evans and Brandon Aiyuk for Jonathan Taylor and Chris Godwin with this team?

QB: Herbert
RBs: Breece, Achane, Ford, Charbs
WRs: Jjettas, Keenan, Aiyuk, Mike Evans, Tank Dell, Drake London, Demario Douglas, Jerry Jeuedy
TE: Kelce

---

If you think JT is a top 5 RB or think Evans will get hurt then I can see it. Otherwise you are trading two players you'd start every week for 1 player that is a slight upgrade (higher floor) and really needing JJ to return otherwise you'd have a drop off with Godwin or Demario Douglas. I think Dell is closer to equal with Aiyuk.

boy09 said:

---

YourMyBoyBlue said:

---

I'd Give:
Gus Edwards
Dalton Kincaid
Jordan Addison

I'd Get:
Joe Mixon
Travis Kielce
Garret Wilson

---

I'm guessing this is a trade you would propose, because no one in their right mind would offer that to you.

---

It is keeper, so the guy could potentially keep 3 very late picks that if it is based on draft spot would make them huge value for next year. If you could have a top 5 TE for a 9th round pick, a top 24 WR for a 10th round pick and a RB30 for 11th round pick.

Please stop trying to sell Gus Edwards as some kind of keeper steal. Sure the other 2 have some value, but Edwards likely won't even be drafted next season.

Edited for typo*

YourMyBoyBlue said:

---

I
I'd Give:
Gus Edwards
Dalton Kincaid
Jordan Addison

I'd Get:
Joe Mixon
Travis Kielce
Garret Wilson


What do you guys think?

---

Instant Veto - I don't even care what the circumstances are or anything you wrote above the actual trade proposal.

Trade is lopsided, but in fairness, keepers leagues are harder to judge. How much longer is Kelce going to play? Kincaid has 10-12 years left with a great QB. Again, the trade is lopsided but some people are just stupid

Dynasty league. I was offered
My team: Achane + Tank Dell for
His team: Lamb + Saquon Barkley

League with no playoffs and best record wins. I'm in second place one game back. It seems like a fair trade for 2023 but possibly get hosed for 2024 and 2025.

Rest of my team: RB: McCaffrey, Swift, Ty Chandler
WR: Sutton, Mike Evans, Gabe Davis, Smith-Nijigba, Higgins
TE: Jake Ferguson, Waller

Opinions? Stupid to consider trading Dell/Achane in a dynasty league?

I'd make that trade 100 out of 100 times