In a half ppr keeper league - can keep up to 3 players from last year - pay $5 more ($100 budget) what you paid last year.

I have Mahomes from last year - paid $7 for him so would be $12 to keep him which is still good value I think.

Last year at the end of the draft Jalen Hurts was available so I grabbed him for $3.

Which do I keep? All things equal I think I go with Mahomes with the little bit of uncertainty in Philly being the decider but Hurts may have more upside and is $4 cheaper.

I considered keeping both as a strategy against the other teams but that hinders my budget and would force me to drop either Barkley for $23 (paid $18 last year) or Chris Olave who I got for a buck last year.

Flip a coin. It's so close i don't think you can go wrong either way, outside of just some unforeseeable bad luck.

If i kept both, it would be with the intent to try to trade one of them right away. There's a lot of value there, no use stashing one of them on your bench when you could get something back.