12Power said:
I would think binding is mostly used for engineering. It seems almost like football recruiting in the CoE. They are after the very top students from all over and don't want any de-commits.
I don't know about that.
Binding has a couple of main benefits to the school (I don't know of any Public Schools that have it though outside of UVA. It's mainly the Private schools in the 10-25 range (Rice, Johns Hopkins, Duke, etc) that use it. They don't want to be a Safety school for the Ivies. Another big benefit is they don't have to worry about Financial Aid/Scholarship competition for Binding kids as they have no incentive to do so (they might still get it but it's not like they feel a need to bid against someone else). It also takes out the Honors Admissions from consideration or anything else special a school might do to get a kid to choose them. So Legacies that are borderline love Binding for instance. Most of the elite kids that are not going to do Binding because they are going to apply to most of the Top 15/20 schools and see who is going to make them the best overall package. They know they won't get in all of them but they will likely have a few to choose from. Private schools also are very concerned with brand and rankings, they do everything they can to manipulate those numbers to look as good as possible and Binding is just one more potential tool. They can accept in the rich legacy kids who are on the edge while having them not submit test scores as Binding for instance. They can also accept in a kid that they like but don't love on a Binding admit so they don't have to worry about accepting him later and they get into a scholarship bidding war or something with a few other schools of similar level.
The Super Elites (Harvard, Stanford, Cal Tech, MIT) don't do binding because they don't need to, very few kids are going to turn them down but if they do they have no shortage of Super Elite kids with perfect resumes to choose from.
Publics don't tend to like it because they have more politics involved with In State Admits and more oversight on their admissions process. Juice just isn't worth the squeeze for them politically to do Binding and Legacy is less of an issue for them.
"The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help."
Ronald Reagan