Teacher backlash

33,617 Views | 567 Replies | Last: 6 days ago by ts5641
AustinCountyAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
redcrayon said:

AustinCountyAg said:

redcrayon said:

AustinCountyAg said:

redcrayon said:

Aggieterri said:

Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.

This time a million. Some of you don't have a clue as to what they have to deal with. By the way, I am not a teacher.


They don't HAVE to deal with anything! They aren't forced to teach.

god forbid some people have a heart and want to help kids grow and learn.


Then don't ***** when the pay is low and the kids are awful.

I don't. Hence, why I am still in public education. It's a tough job and someone has to do it. A job that someone like you obviously couldn't handle.


You don't know me and what I've handled. So kindly STHU. Again, no one is forcing anyone to teach. Stop being a martyr.

right back at ya buddy
Tex100
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.
. Amen. My mom was a teache who cared about her students and worked really hard for them.
cevans_40
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tysker said:

Quote:

Most teachers are not happy with the system, as it is currently structured, but also don't feel it needs to be completely blown up. They are mostly naive to how the private sector works, having never been in it. There are a bunch of good people in the field and plenty of lazy ones, just as any field. The disdain that this board and much of society has for teachers is mostly unfounded and borderline psychotic.

Vouchers will give teachers more opportunities to create educational platforms and reach people outside current structures.

Why do they not see this? Is seems so obvious to those of us on the outside


They believe that if the current system were fixed that it would truly benefit all. They have pride in what they do and their schools.

I believe most people feel this way about their work. What do you do for a living? Lets all take shots at your industry and employer and see your reaction.
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I think we can mostly agree that the system would benefit greatly if it could fail more students, have them retake courses until they reach basic levels of mastery, and let teachers and admins kick out students who behave badly.

Public education should be considered a privilege, not a right.
Featured Video Previews
AxelFoley85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Why are you so angry?
OlRock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
you're trolling or special.

High performing teachers don't fit in your complainer or lazy teacher category. How idiotic it is to think so shallow. You must be on par with the type of teachers you continue to describe on this thread.

I reread your posts. I agree about teachers who complain about pay. This thread is a slap in the face to teachers who show up everyday and kick ass. Those teachers DESERVE more pay!
austinAG90
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cevans_40 said:

I tried to warn this board of this very thing on election day. I am in a pretty rare situation in that I got into teaching after 15 years in the private sector and will likely get out of teaching as soon as my kids are done. I did it to teach and coach my kids and hopefully have an impact on some lives along the way. This decision came at a huge financial cost to me. My last year in the private sector I made 3x what I make teaching. Most teachers are not happy with the system, as it is currently structured, but also don't feel it needs to be completely blown up. They are mostly naive to how the private sector works, having never been in it. There are a bunch of good people in the field and plenty of lazy ones, just as any field. The disdain that this board and much of society has for teachers is mostly unfounded and borderline psychotic.

Now to the election. The republicans launched a full-scale attack on public education and it turned a lot of teachers against them. Most teachers want to fix the system, not totally dismantle it. They hate that government has said they must keep all of the kids in one big group and teach to the lowest common denominator because "no child can be left behind." They hate the SPED, 504 (disability), and ESL programs they must follow. They hate that they can't send problem kids home because attendance equals funding. They hate that no matter how well or poorly they do their job, they are only getting a $500 raise every year. They don't like the increase in the number of administrators but also understand they are basically essential personnel because someone has to track all of the programs in order to keep or obtain funding for anything. They would love to see more local control and be able to operate more like private schools can. The irony here is that the democrats are promising that but will in no way deliver on that promise. It goes against everything they are.

Basically, the voucher program went a step too far. There were some things that republicans got right. TIA was designed to allow schools to pay their better teachers more but the implementation of that was totally trash. Its too long to lay out all of the issues here but it is awful and in no way a reflection of what actually goes on in the classroom.

Now, proceed with the teacher flaming.



I don't blame teacher nearly as much as the Dept of Education and of course, the wonderful Teachers' Union.
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cevans_40 said:

tysker said:

Quote:

Most teachers are not happy with the system, as it is currently structured, but also don't feel it needs to be completely blown up. They are mostly naive to how the private sector works, having never been in it. There are a bunch of good people in the field and plenty of lazy ones, just as any field. The disdain that this board and much of society has for teachers is mostly unfounded and borderline psychotic.

Vouchers will give teachers more opportunities to create educational platforms and reach people outside current structures.

Why do they not see this? Is seems so obvious to those of us on the outside


They believe that if the current system were fixed that it would truly benefit all. They have pride in what they do and their schools.

I believe most people feel this way about their work. What do you do for a living? Lets all take shots at your industry and employer and see your reaction.

I work on Wall Street. Many people tell me the fundamental purpose of my job is immoral.

The amount of change in finance in my 25 years is staggering.
It's constantly changing, and many jobs that existed even 5-10 years ago are getting automated away. I also find it interesting that much of the employment opportunity and growth is no longer in trading or finance, but in the admin, compliance, and customer service side of the business.


eta: In my business, if you're not getting better and providing results, you're going to be fired, or your business will eventually get swallowed up. And if the regulators (FINRA, SEC, CFTC) don't like your business, they can basically fine it out of existence
cevans_40
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Flack said:

Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.

Honest question, when was the last time you saw a teacher get fired for performance? Not for cause but for poor results? Bet you it was a while ago (if you've ever even seen it). When was the last time you saw a school or school district get shut down for bad results? See, in the private sector, if you consistently do a ****ty job you get canned. If your company consistently does a ****ty job you can get laid off, your division can get shut down, and/or your company can go out of business. Happens all the time. That makes our jobs harder than yours.

The numbers are old but doubt they have changed much, a quick search shows Texas fires ~1.3 teachers per school district per year for poor performance... not a percent, actual number of teachers, one to two per district per year. LMAO y'all have it easy.

https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/sass/tables/sass1112_2013311_d1s_008.asp



I disagree. In the private sector, you get some control over your working environment. I have little to no control over what students are assigned to me and what curriculum I have to teach. Not just the subjects, but the actual material and order in which I teach is all chosen for me. So, I challenge you to go out and sell a really crappy product in a market that doesn't want it and then I will sit back and critique the job you do and fire you for not doing it well.
AGC
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What I'll say is, if teachers want raises without taking responsibility for output (blame the parents), we should just blow up the system and lay them all off. If they're not able to overcome such things, we need to end the welfare state called public education. Everyone's job is to overcome objections and external consequences.

Good teachers take responsibility for failures with bad students. If you only had good students with good parents you'd probably take less money right? "You're paying me too much, this is too easy." Not likely. The parenting issue obscures reality. If we took the hard kids out would you be ok with 1/3 less money?

Yall are right: you feed the kids, educate them, watch them when their parents work and the school day is over, provide emotional support and more. You've never stepped back and viewed yourselves as welfare workers though, because you got a degree with a specialization.

But you're all afraid of what it takes: CPS and orphanages or a foster system (boarding school?). If a family doesn't feed or clothe their kids, if they're exposed to violence or handed screens from the age of two which kill their ability to focus, the only thing that solves this is removing them. Otherwise it's perpetual. And we have this debate endlessly: "I'm a babysitter and don't get paid enough!"

Oh well. Voting for Hinojosa will fix all this I'm sure.
GIF Reactor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
YouBet said:

Timberwolf said:

Heard an interesting caller into Mark Davis show yesterday say there was a strong likelihood that public school teachers across the state came out in droves to vote against Abbott and Paxton- Regardless of their party affiliation. They are very upset about school vouchers and the negative impact its had. Curious to hear from you teachers if that's accurate


I think it's a fact and not a strong likelihood. My SIL is a teacher and she said every one of her teacher friends voted for Democrats down the line specifically calling out Abbott and Paxton solely because of vouchers.

Akin to women who vote solely on the abortion as single issue voters.

It is not just women. Murder should be a pretty big issue to everyone.
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cevans_40 said:

Flack said:

Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.

Honest question, when was the last time you saw a teacher get fired for performance? Not for cause but for poor results? Bet you it was a while ago (if you've ever even seen it). When was the last time you saw a school or school district get shut down for bad results? See, in the private sector, if you consistently do a ****ty job you get canned. If your company consistently does a ****ty job you can get laid off, your division can get shut down, and/or your company can go out of business. Happens all the time. That makes our jobs harder than yours.

The numbers are old but doubt they have changed much, a quick search shows Texas fires ~1.3 teachers per school district per year for poor performance... not a percent, actual number of teachers, one to two per district per year. LMAO y'all have it easy.

https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/sass/tables/sass1112_2013311_d1s_008.asp



I disagree. In the private sector, you get some control over your working environment. I have little to know control over what students are assigned to me and what curriculum I have to teach. Not just the subjects, but the actual material and order in which I teach is all chosen for me. So, I challenge you to go out and sell a really crappy product in a market that doesn't want it and then I will sit back and critique the job you do and fire you for not doing it well.

Vouchers would help teachers and educators create venues and platforms to take more control of their work life and environment.

I would kill for a set of microschools in my area for me to choose from so I could choose the best opportunities for my kids and for my family.

The one-size-fits-all model is dying. It's been dying since the internet.
AustinCountyAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
austinAG90 said:

cevans_40 said:

I tried to warn this board of this very thing on election day. I am in a pretty rare situation in that I got into teaching after 15 years in the private sector and will likely get out of teaching as soon as my kids are done. I did it to teach and coach my kids and hopefully have an impact on some lives along the way. This decision came at a huge financial cost to me. My last year in the private sector I made 3x what I make teaching. Most teachers are not happy with the system, as it is currently structured, but also don't feel it needs to be completely blown up. They are mostly naive to how the private sector works, having never been in it. There are a bunch of good people in the field and plenty of lazy ones, just as any field. The disdain that this board and much of society has for teachers is mostly unfounded and borderline psychotic.

Now to the election. The republicans launched a full-scale attack on public education and it turned a lot of teachers against them. Most teachers want to fix the system, not totally dismantle it. They hate that government has said they must keep all of the kids in one big group and teach to the lowest common denominator because "no child can be left behind." They hate the SPED, 504 (disability), and ESL programs they must follow. They hate that they can't send problem kids home because attendance equals funding. They hate that no matter how well or poorly they do their job, they are only getting a $500 raise every year. They don't like the increase in the number of administrators but also understand they are basically essential personnel because someone has to track all of the programs in order to keep or obtain funding for anything. They would love to see more local control and be able to operate more like private schools can. The irony here is that the democrats are promising that but will in no way deliver on that promise. It goes against everything they are.

Basically, the voucher program went a step too far. There were some things that republicans got right. TIA was designed to allow schools to pay their better teachers more but the implementation of that was totally trash. Its too long to lay out all of the issues here but it is awful and in no way a reflection of what actually goes on in the classroom.

Now, proceed with the teacher flaming.



I don't blame teacher nearly as much as the Dept of Education and of course, the wonderful Teachers' Union.

teachers can not unionize in TX
TxSquarebody
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If you compell the consumer to buy it through legal action, I would probably perform just as well.
redcrayon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AustinCountyAg said:

redcrayon said:

AustinCountyAg said:

redcrayon said:

AustinCountyAg said:

redcrayon said:

Aggieterri said:

Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.

This time a million. Some of you don't have a clue as to what they have to deal with. By the way, I am not a teacher.


They don't HAVE to deal with anything! They aren't forced to teach.

god forbid some people have a heart and want to help kids grow and learn.


Then don't ***** when the pay is low and the kids are awful.

I don't. Hence, why I am still in public education. It's a tough job and someone has to do it. A job that someone like you obviously couldn't handle.


You don't know me and what I've handled. So kindly STHU. Again, no one is forcing anyone to teach. Stop being a martyr.

right back at ya buddy


This makes no sense. You claim I couldn't handle teaching without knowing the first thing about me or what I've done. But we ALL know how hard it is for you.

Stuff like this created the teacher stereotypes. You don't have the hardest job in the world. You aren't a hero.
B-1 83
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.

You must be new to F16. All teachers are worthless idiots who could not pass any other major in college, and they spend their off periods plotting on how to introduce Marx and Che Guevara into all their lessons. Any poster on this forum could slip into any public teaching job and have a classroom of well behaved geniuses in no time that would miss zero questions on standardized tests.
Being in TexAgs jail changes a man……..no, not really
Sweep4-2
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Danny Vermin said:

There's no profession I have the least amount of respect for out of all of them more than " teachers" . Nurses are not far behind but most " teachers" are truly despicable. We have a few around here that are scum of the earth.


Wow, I hope you have the fortitude and strength to refuse all medical assistance a nurse tries to provide you with. And I'm assuming you are 100% responsible for your own education without any secondary or college instructors?

There are crappy teachers and nurses as there are in all profession but your opinion that the entire profession and all in it deserve no respect is an interesting view of the world (but it's yours and I respect your right to despise who you want to)
Consistency: It's only a virtue if you're not a screw-up.
cevans_40
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AGC said:

What I'll say is, if teachers want raises without taking responsibility for output (blame the parents), we should just blow up the system and lay them all off. If they're not able to overcome such things, we need to end the welfare state called public education. Everyone's job is to overcome objections and external consequences.

Good teachers take responsibility for failures with bad students. If you only had good students with good parents you'd probably take less money right? "You're paying me too much, this is too easy." Not likely. The parenting issue obscures reality. If we took the hard kids out would you be ok with 1/3 less money?

Yall are right: you feed the kids, educate them, watch them when their parents work and the school day is over, provide emotional support and more. You've never stepped back and viewed yourselves as welfare workers though, because you got a degree with a specialization.

But you're all afraid of what it takes: CPS and orphanages or a foster system (boarding school?). If a family doesn't feed or clothe their kids, if they're exposed to violence or handed screens from the age of two which kill their ability to focus, the only thing that solves this is removing them. Otherwise it's perpetual. And we have this debate endlessly: "I'm a babysitter and don't get paid enough!"

Oh well. Voting for Hinojosa will fix all this I'm sure.

Good night. Teachers are not welfare workers and if you believe they are you are wrong. They are there to create a learning environment for kids. Their job is not to raise kids. Their job is to educate.

This may be the dumbest post I have ever read in regards to teaching. EVER
EFR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ok, have you been a teacher?
redcrayon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AxelFoley85 said:

Why are you so angry?


LOL. I'm not. The teachers are!! No one has it as bad as they do!
Funky Winkerbean
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cevans_40 said:

5Amp said:

cevans_40 said:

5Amp said:

Aggieterri said:

Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.

This time a million. Some of you don't have a clue as to what they have to deal with. By the way, I am not a teacher.

No question they have a tough job but it is irony they are the least educated on the issues except turf protecting.

Vouchers help lower income families near crappy public schools put their kids in private schools.

Except, in Texas, it didn't work out that way at all. The majority of families that received voucher money already had their kids in private or home school.

It just started last year. My wife teaches at a private Catholic school after leaving public schools. Most of the students are from middle class families. Enrollment increased once the word got out that vouchers were approved. Most of their parents do not have the time to keep up with current events, they actually do manual labor, mechanics, nurses, delivery, sales, etc.

these families are all lower middle class and represent the demographics of the population. The teachers are black, white, and brown.

Most will still not go back to public schools, they will continue to find a way to pay for private schools, especially schools that still display the Ten Commandments.

Texas Public schools turning Texas blue to turf protect their cheese tells you all you need to know.



That's great for you and your family. I am not upset with that at all. Its great you have that option for your family. We don't have a private option where I am. We didn't lose any kids to private schools. Lost a few to homeschool but that's fine as well. The issue we have here, is we would love to operate more like private schools but we can't due to government mandates. Supposedly conservative policy makers taking away local control. The worst part is that now people are voting blue and thinking that they will somehow allow more local control. Hell, its what Hinojosa is claiming. I am smart enough to know that is never going to happen but many aren't.

Trump dismantled the department of education to allow for more local control. I guess if it wasn't fixed in one year turning to socialism is the answer? Instant gratification is an expectation of kids, not adults.
Bob Lee
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That's what breeds contempt. Teachers need it to be prohibitively expensive to leave the public schools because from their perspective the worst possible outcome is shrinking the system. I don't think they hate me personally, and I think that if they could see what my children's education looks like they would have to admit it's miles better than anything they could provide them even under the best circumstances. But they're contemptuous toward any alternative, including just homeschooling as a broad category because public school is an end unto itself. Whatever public school is, the fact is that it MUST continue to exist at any cost.

And their ideas and mine about what it would mean to "fix" the public schools are so divergent it's not even worth engaging them in a conversation about it.
cevans_40
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TxSquarebody said:

If you compell the consumer to buy it through legal action, I would probably perform just as well.

Good. Then you wouldn't get fired but everyone would just talk about how worthless you are and you could just sit back and laugh all the way to the bank with your 50k/year.
cevans_40
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Funky Winkerbean said:

cevans_40 said:

5Amp said:

cevans_40 said:

5Amp said:

Aggieterri said:

Your Mom And Them said:

Until you've been in a classroom and in charge of teaching students...most of you can shut the **** up! You have no idea until you've been in those shoes.

This time a million. Some of you don't have a clue as to what they have to deal with. By the way, I am not a teacher.

No question they have a tough job but it is irony they are the least educated on the issues except turf protecting.

Vouchers help lower income families near crappy public schools put their kids in private schools.

Except, in Texas, it didn't work out that way at all. The majority of families that received voucher money already had their kids in private or home school.

It just started last year. My wife teaches at a private Catholic school after leaving public schools. Most of the students are from middle class families. Enrollment increased once the word got out that vouchers were approved. Most of their parents do not have the time to keep up with current events, they actually do manual labor, mechanics, nurses, delivery, sales, etc.

these families are all lower middle class and represent the demographics of the population. The teachers are black, white, and brown.

Most will still not go back to public schools, they will continue to find a way to pay for private schools, especially schools that still display the Ten Commandments.

Texas Public schools turning Texas blue to turf protect their cheese tells you all you need to know.



That's great for you and your family. I am not upset with that at all. Its great you have that option for your family. We don't have a private option where I am. We didn't lose any kids to private schools. Lost a few to homeschool but that's fine as well. The issue we have here, is we would love to operate more like private schools but we can't due to government mandates. Supposedly conservative policy makers taking away local control. The worst part is that now people are voting blue and thinking that they will somehow allow more local control. Hell, its what Hinojosa is claiming. I am smart enough to know that is never going to happen but many aren't.

Trump dismantled the department of education to allow for more local control. I guess if it wasn't fixed in one year turning to socialism is the answer? Instant gratification is an expectation of kids, not adults.

This has more to do with Abbott and Morath than Trump, in my opinion.
Gigem314
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Omperlodge said:

Or they want their 15000 raise that Gina is promising .
Gina's not gonna do a damn thing for them except lip service and helping to increase the size of the student population and classrooms with her border stance.
redcrayon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
EFR said:

Ok, have you been a teacher?


I subbed in college. Terrible kids and admins. Still didn't *****. I chose to do it.

My mom taught for years. She says no one can complain like a teacher.
No Spin Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tysker said:

I think we can mostly agree that the system would benefit greatly if it could fail more students, have them retake courses until they reach basic levels of mastery, and let teachers and admins kick out students who behave badly.

Public education should be considered a privilege, not a right.


Stop making it mandatory. It'll destroy the economy but it'll also have schools be places where kids that want to learn thrive and those that don't can, well, who gives an eff, so long as they're not a drain on the education system.

I'm sure teachers would be thrilled to only teach kids who want to learn.
There are in fact two things, science and opinion; the former begets knowledge, the later ignorance. Hippocrates
OlRock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If you were a teacher, you'd be angry that you couldn't post on this thread right now. And, you'd be angry because you'd have to wait until you got home to read all 5-10 pages because your 10 minute lunch break didn't give you enough time to even finish doom scrolling socials
Spotted Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Teachers have gulped down the Abbott and Republicans are evil line without a second thought. Public school teachers, in general, most but not all, think they are the most oppressed and tortured group in the nation. Their overall sense of entitlement is beyond reproach and if you dare say anything against their line of thought you are labeled as fascist. I see it all day every day. If you kid is in public school you better be getting details about what goes on each day. Most of these morons are people that would never hack it in the private sector bc they wouldn't have every single one of their "needs" catered to.

Ask one this, What has Abbott or Republicans done that is so bad for public ed. They will regurgitate every single talking point from the AFT and that evil ***** Randi Weingarten. They won't ever give specific details because they don't know. They are only telling you what their moron admins, that keep getting raises each year that far outpace the teachers, tell them. They keep saying they deserve more pay, all the while their admins and best friends get the raises they want but they don't have an issue with that.
Covidians, Communists, CNN, FOX, and all other MSM are enemies of the state and should be treated as such.
AGC
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cevans_40 said:

AGC said:

What I'll say is, if teachers want raises without taking responsibility for output (blame the parents), we should just blow up the system and lay them all off. If they're not able to overcome such things, we need to end the welfare state called public education. Everyone's job is to overcome objections and external consequences.

Good teachers take responsibility for failures with bad students. If you only had good students with good parents you'd probably take less money right? "You're paying me too much, this is too easy." Not likely. The parenting issue obscures reality. If we took the hard kids out would you be ok with 1/3 less money?

Yall are right: you feed the kids, educate them, watch them when their parents work and the school day is over, provide emotional support and more. You've never stepped back and viewed yourselves as welfare workers though, because you got a degree with a specialization.

But you're all afraid of what it takes: CPS and orphanages or a foster system (boarding school?). If a family doesn't feed or clothe their kids, if they're exposed to violence or handed screens from the age of two which kill their ability to focus, the only thing that solves this is removing them. Otherwise it's perpetual. And we have this debate endlessly: "I'm a babysitter and don't get paid enough!"

Oh well. Voting for Hinojosa will fix all this I'm sure.

Good night. Teachers are not welfare workers and if you believe they are you are wrong. They are there to create a learning environment for kids. Their job is not to raise kids. Their job is to educate.

This may be the dumbest post I have ever read in regards to teaching. EVER


Sounds like you agree with me. Your posts are the epitome of the 'what I think I do, what I actually do' meme. The school systems fill in all the gaps for lousy parents and they're also first people you blame when someone points out educational outcomes (and the lack of bang for the buck that raises bring).

But to the last point, if we get rid of disciplinary issues, you'll gladly do your work for 1/3 less and stop asking for raises, right?
TxSquarebody
How long do you want to ignore this user?
cevans_40 said:

TxSquarebody said:

If you compell the consumer to buy it through legal action, I would probably perform just as well.

Good. Then you wouldn't get fired but everyone would just talk about how worthless you are and you could just sit back and laugh all the way to the bank with your 50k/year.

I mean, there a good chance those talking might be correct!
ETA: Not bad for part-time work!
CampSkunk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
B-Rabbit said:

My wife is a teacher. Some of these comments... Sure, there are some crazy teachers out there, but most are completely normal, hardworking people who want the best for their students. We've probably spent thousands over the years out of our own pocket on supplies, etc. To suggest that all teachers are lazy babysitters trying to spread some sort of indoctrination agenda is mind-blowingly stupid. People also don't realize how tied teachers' hands are. They often can't discipline kids in any meaningful way, and in a lot of districts they can't even fail a student who earned it because of admin pressure or grading policies. They get blamed for outcomes they aren't allowed to control. The real problem starts at home.

Spot on. My wife was a teacher as well, until she retired four years ago, at the young age of 55. She keeps in touch with the teaching community and confirms that a good majority of them are BSC liberals. And a good number of them are lazy, useless slugs who only teach because they are too incompetent to do anything else. (Who would know better than the teaching partners of those slugs). But they can't all be labeled with the same brush. For many of them it's a mission - they could do better, but they love the kids, literally, and wouldn't think of doing anything else. I classify my wife among those. But you can guess why she retired early. The BSC parents who think that their kids shat don't stink, and the bumbling school administrators who think that discipline involves giving a piece of candy to the kid in the office while they calm down. The public school system does nothing to help those kids who are not parented, and teachers shouldn't take the blame for the kids who are not parented. That being said, the majority can be blamed for thinking that Dems are going to help them, but why should we single out teachers for that position? In that respect they are just the same as everyone else.
tysker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No Spin Ag said:

tysker said:

I think we can mostly agree that the system would benefit greatly if it could fail more students, have them retake courses until they reach basic levels of mastery, and let teachers and admins kick out students who behave badly.

Public education should be considered a privilege, not a right.


Stop making it mandatory. It'll destroy the economy but it'll also have schools be places where kids that want to learn thrive and those that don't can, well, who gives an eff, so long as they're not a drain on the education system.

I'm sure teachers would be thrilled to only teach kids who want to learn.

Both prohibitions and compulsory mandates rarely remain effective over the long run. Society and its behavior evolve faster than these institutions can manage, and over time the institution loses control
AxelFoley85
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The hatred for teachers is mystifying. Maybe we should make everyone responsible for educating their own children and see how well that goes over.

And in before, fine as long as I don't pay property taxes guy.
Silent For Too Long
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Voucher programs are objectively one of the best things we can do for our students, but they have become politically difficult because people are ******ed
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.