"What he said next surprised me. He said he would never do what he did again. He wasn't afraid of jail time but the caning was something he would never want to go through again. He told me he blacked after the first stroke of the cane that split the skin off his tail bone and blood spurted out. He had to be stitched up. Rested for a few days and the canning continued for the remaining 3 strokes. He could not sit on his butt for days and would sleep face down. He said he feared the caning more than his time in jail."
Others have had trouble controlling their bowels after the caning.
Matt Walsh: "One of the basics of human psychology is that every person on the planet responds to incentives and disincentives. The idea of being stripped naked and beaten so hard with a cane that the guy doing the caning has to take breaks to let his arm rest throughout the ordeal is a disincentive. Criminals in the United States are convinced that there will not be any significant penalty. If they do end up with a short stint in prison, the experience is only likely to increase their street cred. An added element of extremely painful corporal punishment creates a profound disincentive so even those unbothered by prison would be bothered by it. Caning is also humiliating, degrading, emasculating. Which means the experience isn't going to enhance anybody's street cred. You are not going to get out of prison bragging about getting caned. It is not the kind of thing you can imagine a rapper boasting about in a song. That is precisely why it is an effective form of punishment. When you think about the types of penalty we should have for violent criminals. If it is the kind of penalty you can imagine a rapper bragging about in a song that becomes a big hit and streamed a 100 million times on Spotify. If it is that kind of penalty, then it is not a good penalty. Let's imagine penalties they would be too embarrassed and too ashamed to brag about. Those are the good penalties. Those are the effective ones."
Idaho would have the appetite for this. Idaho recently passed the firing squad into law for the death penalty. Also Idaho in the recent past elected Janice McGeachin to lieutenant governor. Also Idaho is a state full of Republican refugees who fled Democrat states over two issues: crime and taxes. https://sos.idaho.gov/dashboards/moving-voters/ Obviously it would be immediately stayed by the federal court system, but they could eventually get in front of the new 6-3 conservative majority on the Supreme Court. Many people don't understand that our Supreme Court was supermajority liberal for the better part of the last 100 years. The liberals did not actually get much of their garbage through Congress. It was passed by liberal judicial activists in the courts when they had control for almost a century.
