Ag with kids said:
We all do.
And if he lives out in Canyon West and works in the city, he's got a long commute. Mine was 54 miles each way and I lived close to there.
I could see an EV being reasonable for that drive. Saves a good chunk of $$$ on the commute. Hell, I filled up my Jeep 2.5 times a week on my commute - it was NOT a good choice for that drive.
Winner winner chicken dinner
Previous vehicle was a BMW X3M. It was fun to drive, great performance, decent size in a smaller package. But it was expensive to fuel and maintain.
The Y performance checked all the boxes of the BMW for about the same upfront price and much cheaper to own.
So for me, in my situation it was a perfect fit. Especially since we still had an ICE truck. I readily admit EV's don't work for a lot of people. But some seem ridiculous in saying they aren't a fit for anyone.