Isn't this akin to a threat of violence? Should be immediately removed just like with any other threats (guns, bombing, etc).

Under the law, no it's not a threat.

Rumor has it that the Chemistry teacher is the MSA 'advisor', and organized the walkout.

Im Gipper said:

---

Under the law, no it's not a threat.

---

Let's agree to disagree. Terroristic statements supporting terrorists are loud and now visible threats. You can't go to an airport and do that, why is a local school acceptable? They have the same laws on firearms

Would a student be expelled for chanting the south will rise again or singing Dixie to disrupt normal school activities?

TAMUallen said:

---

Im Gipper said:

---

Under the law, no it's not a threat.

---

Let's agree to disagree. Terroristic statements supporting terrorists are loud and now visible threats. You can't go to an airport and do that, why is a local school acceptable? They have the same laws on firearms

Would a student be expelled for chanting the south will rise again or singing Dixie to disrupt normal school activities?

---

it feels especially threatening to me as it relates to Jewish students

It's not a threat under the law. Not trying to be combative, just telling you what the law is on this.

A student very well may be expelled for chanting south will rise again given the liberal schools. And that kid would have a great civil rights lawsuit against that school.!

agz win said:

---

C@LAg said:

---

punish the kids for disruptive and hateful behavior, throw them in detention for a month.

simple.

---

I'd go with the rest of the year and require apology letters and community service at a Jewish Center. High schools should be for learning and not disruption.

---

Agree with the sentiment, but do you really want kids chanting for the genocide of Jews to be mapping out the buildings and identifying personnel for the people that have raised them to hate Jews to the point of eradication?

Im Gipper said:

---

It's not a threat under the law. Not trying to be combative, just telling you what the law is on this.

A student very well may be expelled for chanting south will rise again given the liberal schools. And that kid would have a great civil rights lawsuit against that school.!

---

I know you aren't being combative and thank you. I'm being combative myself towards double standards and same behaviors being excused because of who is doing it.

It isn't acceptable and while borderline terrorists, they should, at minimum, be expelled instantly. Not expelled after backlash rises against terrorists protesting at school using the 1st amendment not given to other students

Why 'Free Palestine from the River to the Sea' Means Genocide against Jews

Palestinian-Americans and their supporters march as the conflict between Israel and the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas continues, in downtown Chicago

By PHILIP KLEIN October 25, 2023 11:48 AM

The phrase "Free Palestine from the river to the sea" or "From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free" may seem innocuous to those unfamiliar with the geography of the region, but in reality, it represents calls for genocide against Jews.

Those of us who follow these issues closely have recoiled whenever we hear the phrase chanted at rallies around the world, or, as was the case last night, projected in massive letters on the library of my alma mater, George Washington University.

We may take it for granted that everybody else understands why these words are so alarming. But it strikes me that, to the unacquainted, saying, "Free Palestine from the river to the sea" may seem like an innocent call for people to be free. How could that be objectionable?

Well, the issue is that "from the river to the sea" refers to the entire area in between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea an area that encompasses not just territories captured by Israel in 1967 during the Six-Day War, but the entirety of Israel.

Referring to that entire area as "Palestine" is not a call to end the occupation, to create a two-state solution, or even to return Israel to the borders that existed before 1967. It is a call for the elimination of Israel in its entirety. Israel is home to nearly half of the world's Jewish population.

The only way you can eliminate Israel and turn that whole area into Palestine is by killing millions of Jews.

There is simply no way of getting around the fact that anybody who utters the phrase "Free Palestine from the river to the sea" is advocating genocide.

Don't Fall for the Pro-Hamas Propaganda

Probably not a good idea to have the chemistry teacher supervise a group of students who support a cause with a propensity for blowing things up.

agz win said:

---

C@LAg said:

---

punish the kids for disruptive and hateful behavior, throw them in detention for a month.

simple.

---

I'd go with the rest of the year and require apology letters and community service at a Jewish Center. High schools should be for learning and not disruption.

---

Community service sweeping and mopping floors, cleaning bathrooms, and emptying trash cans at a Jewish Center.

TxAgLaw03RW said:

---

Probably not a good idea to have the chemistry teacher supervise a group of students who support a cause with a propensity for blowing things up.

---

It'll be a mostly peaceful coincidence

This is what happens when you have constitutional rights but also have really dumb immigration policies.

As I think more about this, what Christian, Jew, Hindu, Buddhist or any other peaceful religion, in our lifetime or even in generations we have interacted with, led walk outs to chant for the expansion of their territory against a clearly defined enemy?

I mean we can say Nepal and India for sure but they're not ambushes against civilians.

There's zero hate that is equivocal to Islam.

Anybody who does not agree and consent is then an honor to kill

No other religion does this or molests children with a prophet that is nearly God

As a former teacher at Mcmillen High School, I can tell you that there is a huge muslim population there. It is not far from the Mosque that hosted the Holy land Foundation, which was an unindicted co conspirator in 911. So you know these are the children of those terrorist parents. Furthermore, the past principle is a BLM supporitng liberal who was "promoted" to the DIE office created at PISD Headquarters.

When these kids are chanting "from the river to the sea" and im sure their Teacher sponsor, who is Jordanian, taught them exactly what to say, she is teaching them to call for extermination of the Jews and the wiping out of Israel.

And Nikki Hailey wants us to bring 1 million so called "palestinian" refuges to America? HELL NO!

Im Gipper said:

---

Under the law, no it's not a threat

---

They dont care about the law when they assult or stab Jews. Look at what happened when Iran called for a day of rage?

These kids walked out of class. They should be punished. They also called for the destruction of israel and Jews.

Imagine if this had been a group of white kids who walked out chanting "hang all the negroes" There would be a firestorm and they would have been arrested for terroristic threats to the fellow students at the school and counselors would have been bought in to help terrified blacks deal with all the trauma while their parents would be marching and screaming bloody murder out front of the school and at the District HQ.

If i was a jewish parent, I would have pulled my child out of that school STAT!

Parents should not use their kids for political purposes. The parents poisoned their minds..

Pookers said:

---

This is what happens when you have constitutional rights but also have really dumb immigration policies.

---

100% not all those protesting are entitled to constitutional protections as they are NOT all American citizens

AgNav93 said:

---

Parents should not use their kids for political purposes. The parents poisoned their minds..

---

Right, but we dealing with a totally different culture, set of moral / religious values and norms as to what is acceptable and just in a society. Back to immigration, always.

C@LAg said:

---

frito said:

---

AggieT said:

---

It wasn't in the video, but if they truly "chanted for the genocide of Israel" as the tweet suggests, they should be expelled.

---

Hint: they didn't chant for genocide... But you know, it feels good to say and get worked up over feels.

---

except they did.

the chant about from the river to the sea these days is explicitly about eradicating Jews from that area. Utterly.

EARTH!

---

pdc093 said:

---

Plano. Staged a walkout, chanting for the genocide of Israel.

High school kids at McMillen High School in @Plano_schools, Texas walked out of class today and chanted for the genocide of Israel.

The rally was organized by the school’s Muslim Student Alliance.
pic.twitter.com/FZyUWlUBkN

— Greg Price (@greg_price11) October 24, 2023

Unbelievable this sentiment is spreading across the Country.

---

Future Democrat voters

They would not have liked pulling that at my high school when I was attending.

"the past principle is a BLM supporting liberal...."

This was at Tulane University today…

When you wrap your face in a keffiyeh like this you know exactly what you’re doing…you know the kind of image you’re trying to project.

When you attempt to light the Israeli flag on fire, you know exactly what you’re doing.

And to be… pic.twitter.com/qClK3UPcHt

— Yashar Ali 🐘 (@yashar) October 27, 2023

NY high schools giving Plano Muslims a run for their money:

Female Muslim Students calling for Genocide in New York City

at least we have only allowed in the best and brightest the last 20 years. our country is so much better now - just look at these all American athletes

Join up with us all anti-American Jew haters!