Ocho Ag said:
born on third base and think they hit a triple
Look AzulAg/Hedge/NotHedge,
Remove your current frame of reference of 2023 american politics.
From the dawn of man up until the industrial revolution, you lived on your families land amongst a tight nit group of extended family. This is literally the definition of a clan. Your parents worked hard to create productive land, you worked on it, and then when you grew up, you would own a chunk of it and do the same. There wasn't this idea of bootstrapping and beating your own chest about how you made it on your own. If you didn't have a family network you were basically going to be broke and starve. On a good day you were at the mercy of a local religious organization.
Even during the industrial revolution, those huddled masses crammed into apartments and worked as a family to support the family. You again, hoped to one day use your parents net worth and network to spring for a life better than they had.
This ethos basically persisted until...the soviet revolution. And the family was one of the things that communism tries to crush. Because if everyone is equal you can't have families better positioning themselves (outside of the elites).
I've got kids of my own now, and its opened my eyes to the accomplishments I've achieved 'on my own.' From the moment you bring that kid home from the hospital you bend over backwards to provide for them, educate them, bring them up in knowledge and wisdom, and hope they go make a career for themselves.
Would 20 year old me say I did it all on my own? No, but I would say its an 80/20 split my effort/parents effort. Now mid 30s me would say its a 50/50 split effort wise and I'd be shocked if I stay at 50/50 as my kids get older.
So why do you want so much unnecessary struggle? Their battles will come. It ain't called shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in 3 generations for nothing. Why rob a family of the ability to maintain their wealth? Why must the government be so powerful that they get to dictate you will be so wealthy but no more?
And remember, there will always be a ruling class that can hide their money. Any wealth transfer tax is just hand waiving over the richest people. It always crushes the middle class the most.
Furthermore, we're approaching a society where certain demographics are kept away from institutions that accelerate wealth because of immutable traits. Why should I get crushed by a wealth tax one day in the name of fairness but my son will be last in line for every wealth creating opportunity? College admittance. College scholarships, job interviews, job cuts.
I'm seriously considering owning my own business just so I can give my last placed demographic children a job one day. Thats the page we're on.
If that requires allowing people to be born on third base, so be it.